Whether a fine is constitutionally excessive calls

Assignment Help Project Management

Reference no: EM131274560

Cooper Industries v. Leatherman Tool Group, Inc.
United States Supreme Court 121 S. Ct. 1678 (2001)
Leatherman (plaintiff) sued Cooper (defendant) in federal district court for unfair competition. Leatherman Tool Group, Inc., manufactured and sold a multifunctional tool called the PST that improved on the classic Swiss Army knife. Leatherman dominated the market for multifunctional pocket tools.

In 1995, Cooper Industries, Inc., decided to design and sell a competing multifunctional tool under the name "ToolZall." Cooper introduced the ToolZall in August 1996 at the National Hardware Show in Chicago. At that show, Cooper used photographs in its posters, packaging, and advertising materials that purported to be a ToolZall but were actually of a modified PST.

When those materials were prepared, the first of the ToolZalls had not yet been manufactured. A Cooper employee created a ToolZall "mock-up" by grinding the Leatherman trademark off a PST and substituting the unique fastenings that were to be used on the ToolZall. At least one of the photographs was retouched to remove a curved indentation where the Leatherman trademark had been. The photographs were used not only at the trade show, but also in marketing materials and catalogs used by Cooper's sales force throughout the United States.

The lower court found for Leatherman in the amount of $50,000 in compensatory damages and $4.5 million in punitive damages. Cooper appealed, but the court of appeals affirmed the lower court's decision, seeing no "abuse of discretion" by the lower court as to punitive damages. Cooper appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, petitioning for a de novo review of the facts as to the size of the punitive damages.

Justice Stevens
Although compensatory damages and punitive damages are typically awarded at the same time by the same decision maker, they serve distinct purposes. The former are intended to redress the concrete loss that the plaintiff has suffered by reason of the defendant's wrongful conduct. The latter, which have been described as "quasi-criminal," operate as private fines intended to punish the defendant and to deter future wrongdoing.

A jury's assessment of the extent of a plaintiff's injury is essentially a factual determination, whereas its imposition of punitive damages is an expression of its moral condemnation. The question [of] whether a fine is constitutionally excessive calls for the application of a constitutional standard to the facts of a particular case, and in this context de novo review of that question is appropriate.

Reference no: EM131274560

Questions Cloud

The advertisement of prices for attorney services : What primary ethical norm dominated the Court's consideration of the advertisement of prices for attorney services?

What are some of the important applications of glass-ceramic : What are the advantages of using glass-ceramics as compared to either glasses or ceramics?

Evaluate formation levels along a profile : Find the reduced levels of grid point showing calculation for each grid point and apply the arithmetic checks and draw the Grid on A-3 size graph paper. Plot Contours at 1m interval with a suitable scale showing the relevant data

What are linear and branched polymers : What electrical and optical applications are polymers used for? Explain using examples.

Whether a fine is constitutionally excessive calls : Whether a fine is constitutionally excessive calls for the application of a constitutional standard to the facts of a particular case, and in this context de novo review of that question is appropriate.

Unregulated equilibrium quantity : Solve for the social marginal cost function (that is, the function that takes into account the private marginal cost of production and the social cost of the externality). What are the total costs of production (including the cost due to environmen..

What positive externalities does usps produce : What positive externalities does USPS produce, and how has the value of these externalities changed over time?" Explain how you would calculate the economic value created by the USPS.

Define the humanist theory of ethics : Define the humanist theory of ethics. On the basis of this theory and a reading of the Union Carbide case synopsis, do you think that Union Carbide acted ethically after the Bhopal incident? Explain.

Calculate the number of polyethylene chains : the total length of chains in the rope, assuming that carbon atoms in each chain are approximately 0.15 nm apart.

User Account

All Pages