Why should the appeals court reverse the ruling

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131378590

Curtis Ellison was riding as a passenger in his own vehicle when it was pulled over by the police for a parking violation. The vehicle had actually been targeted because the police had routinely checked the license plate through the department's database. This routine check had revealed that the owner of the vehicle had an outstanding warrant pending against him. When the police searched the van, they found two firearms hidden in the vehicle.

As a result, Ellison was charged with felonious possession of a firearm. He argued that the search had violated his Fourth Amendment rights and that his right to privacy had been infringed. The trial court agreed and dismissed the case. The case went to the appellate court. The issue before the appellate court was whether Ellison had a high expectation of privacy about the number on his license plate.

Although this is a criminal case, it is still interesting to speculate on how the court would rule on the expectation of privacy in relation to a license plate. Why should the appeals court reverse the ruling by the trial court that there is a high expectation of privacy in relation to a license plate? Explain.

United States v. Ellison, No. 04-1925; see also "Criminal Practice: No Privacy Expectation on License Plate Numbers," The National Law Journal, September 18, 2006, p. 16.

Reference no: EM131378590

Questions Cloud

The substitution effect is stronger than the income effect : How many of the following four business cycle facts can be explained if the primary cause of business cycles is temporary changes in total factor productivity: procyclical consumption, procyclical investment, procyclical employment, and procyclical r..

Why use of term informant to describe clawson not libelous : Clawson would have preferred the term "whistleblower" rather than "informant," because that term commands more respect. Why is the use of the term "informant" to describe Clawson not libelous? Explain.

The higher the concentration ratio : The production function is the: The higher the concentration ratio, the

What is the relationship of kanem-bornu to songhai : What is the relationship of Kanem-Bornu to Songhai? Why did Portugal turn to slavery in its colonies earlier than other European states

Why should the appeals court reverse the ruling : Why should the appeals court reverse the ruling by the trial court that there is a high expectation of privacy in relation to a license plate? Explain.

Why city held liable under doctirne of vicarious liability : The city further argued that the officer's real employer was the board, so it, the city, could not be held liable under the doctrine of vicarious liability. Why should the city be held liable under the doctirne of vicarious liability? Explain.

Explain the development of japanese heian court culture : Can you please help with these questions below in 500-600 words and thank you for your help with my assignment. Explain the development of Japanese Heian court culture

Should the court use the actual malice test : Should the Court use the actual malice test in this case to determine whether the newspaper libeled the commissioner? Explain.

What was the basis of martin luther king : What was the basis of Martin Luther King, Jr.'s social justice fundamentalism? How did his faith lead him to move beyond fighting for civil rights to fighting for economic justice as well

User Account

All Pages