Which is a genuine ethical dilemma

Assignment Help Management Theories
Reference no: EM131153471

Ethical lapses are often confused with ethical dilemmas! In application, these are two very different things. An ethical lapse is a failure to behave in an ethical way in some specific situation, while an ethical dilemma is a situation in which no good ethical choice or decision is possible. Consider the two following global management situations:

1. A visiting American executive finds that a foreign subsidiary in a poor nation has hired a 12-year-old girl to work on a factory floor, in violation of the company's prohibition on child labor. He tells the local manager to replace the child and tell her to go back to school. The local manager tells the American executive that the child is an orphan with no other means of support, and she will probably become a street child if she is denied work. What should the American executive do?

2. A visiting American executive finds that his manufacturing plant in a poor nation is discharging chemicals into the local river in excess of what U.S. laws would permit. It is likely that such levels of toxic waste pose a potential health hazard but the capital investment required to correct the problem will result in the plant not achieving its profitability requirements for the next 2 years.

3. After considering these two different scenarios, discuss the following:

a. Which is a genuine ethical dilemma and which is an ethical lapse, and why?

b. It is frequently stated that "ethics rises above the law." Explain this reasoning as it would apply to one of these scenarios.

Reference no: EM131153471

Questions Cloud

What''s the highest price a person would pay for such a stock : Why would anyone buy shares of a corporation that had no profits and paid no dividends? What's the highest price a person would pay for such a stock
National survey of family growth : Age at first marriage, Part I: The National Survey of Family Growth conducted by the Centers for Disease Control gathers information on family life, marriage and divorce, pregnancy, infertility, use of contraception, and men's and women's health.
What is the full and complete title of the article : What is the full and complete title of the article you have selected? - Who is the writer of the article? - What journal was this article published in? When?
Explains the normal distribution via binomial distribution : This video explains the normal distribution via the binomial distribution: The distribution of the number of heads thrown on 20 coins approximates the normal. This is used to explain that the normal distribution is the mathematical consequence of ..
Which is a genuine ethical dilemma : After considering these two different scenarios, discuss the following: Which is a genuine ethical dilemma and which is an ethical lapse, and why
Relevance in organizational development : Outline the purposes of a case study and discuss its relevance in organizational development. Describe a situation where a case analysis would be an ideal tool to allow management to make a more informed decision, and a situation where it would not.
What is involved in feasibility analysis : What is involved in a feasibility analysis, and what value might it provide? Why are pro forma financial statement important to the financial planning process? How can an entrepreneur launching a new business forecast sales?
Evaluate the types of employee testing : Evaluate the types of employee testing that companies may require that are discussed in the text. Determine the two tests that you consider the most important. Support your reasoning
Is diversity important in healthcare organizations : Is diversity important in Healthcare organizations? Why are some ethnic groups underrepresented in higher-paying positions? What are some of the issues in helping women advance in management?

Reviews

Write a Review

Management Theories Questions & Answers

  What motivation is there to implement environmental account

What motivation is there to implement an environmental accounting and control system? Construct a sample environmental cost-of-quality report using the four categories.

  Production management & industrial engineering

Differences between production management & industrial engineering

  Designs and manufactures high end fashion clothing

DY Company, based in J Country, designs and manufactures high end fashion clothing, which it sells through its international chain of outlets. The company's customers are willing to pay highprices for DY branded fashion items based on their quality a..

  Aesign golf clubs that provide larger

Golf Technologies Inc. (GTI) relies on high-level scientific testing to design golf clubs that provide larger "sweet spots" resulting in fewer miss-hits and maximum yardage. In the last year, they discovered a technical breakthrough. Their newe..

  A mutually exclusive project is one whose acceptance

A mutually exclusive project is one whose acceptance does not preclude the acceptance of alternative projects.

  Benson purchased a new ford thunderbird automobile

Benson purchased a new Ford Thunderbird automobile. She traded in her old automobile and financed the balance of $4,326 through the Magnavox Employees Credit Union, which took a security interest in the Thunderbird.

  What steps would seguro take to implement a tq process

Complete the simulation "Quality Management and Productivity" found on the page for Week Four and answer the following questions:- What steps would Seguro take to implement a TQ process, and why?

  Inventory turnover rate

Inventory turnover rate

  Suggest ways your corporation might deal with this issue

Choose one of these issues and, based on your reading for the week, write two or three paragraphs in which you suggest ways your corporation might deal with this particular issue.

  Total compensation system

After having studied chapter 10, explain how an organization's total compensation system can help the organization be effective or prevent it from being effective.Note: Your written assignment essay answer should total up to four (4) typed, double-sp..

  New initiatives—especially new product developments

Discuss the approach your organisation used to manage its new initiatives—especially new product developments.

  Write an equation of the family of circles

Write an equation of the family of circles passing through the intersection of the circles: (x^2)+(y^2)-5=0 and (x^2)+2x+(y^2)-12y-7=0 Find the member of the family for which k=1

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd