What rights or public policies must be balanced

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131470420

Question: A troublesome issue concerning the constitutional privilege against self-incrimination has to do with "jail plants"-that is, undercover police officers placed in cells with criminal suspects to gain information from the suspects. For example, in one case the police placed an undercover agent, Parisi, in a jail cell block with Lloyd Perkins, who had been imprisoned on charges unrelated to the murder that Parisi was investigating. When Parisi asked Perkins if he had ever killed anyone, Perkins made statements implicating himself in the murder. Perkins was then charged with the murder. [Illinois v. Perkins, 496 U.S. 292, 110 S.Ct. 2394, 110 L.Ed.2d 243 (1990)]

1. Should Perkins's statements be suppressed-that is, not be admissible as evidence at trial-because he was not "read his rights," as required by the Miranda decision, prior to making his self-incriminating statements? Does Miranda apply to Perkins's situation?

2. Do you think that it is fair for the police to resort to trickery and deception to bring those who have committed crimes to justice? Why or why not? What rights or public policies must be balanced in deciding this issue?

Reference no: EM131470420

Questions Cloud

Argue for or against your own theory : Argue for or against a business decision, organizational plan, business philosophy, policy decision, or concept related to the MM Propositions.

Analyse importance of communication skills in the workplace : BIZ101- Business Communications Essay Assignment.

What are the two elements of criminal liability : Gavin, a fifteen-year-old student, was eating lunch on the grounds of a school. He threw a half-eaten apple toward the outside wall of a classroom.

How will you stay abreast of new developments in industry : How will you stay abreast of new developments in your industry? What new products do you have in development now, in addition to your flagship product?

What rights or public policies must be balanced : A troublesome issue concerning the constitutional privilege against self-incrimination has to do with "jail plants"-that is, undercover police officers placed.

What is the firms labor hours productivity after the change : Plot the control chart and the sample values - What would you conclude about the process, in other words, is the process in control? Explain your decision.

Can ray be convicted of the crime of grand theft of fireman : Ray steals a purse from an unattended car at a gas station. Because the purse contains money and a handgun, Ray is convicted of grand theft of property (cash).

Create a document or spreadsheet where you detail for video : Create a document or spreadsheet where you detail for each video. Any ideas the video gave you for teaching and learning.

Identify the ethical issues that barton needs to consider : For each of the statements made by MsSimmons (see the three dot points above); a. Identify the ethical issues that Barton needs to consider in his response

User Account

All Pages