What are the potential consequences

Assignment Help Management Theories
Reference no: EM131020375

Case: The Case of the Plant Relocation

You are the chief executive of Electrocorp, an electronics company, which makes the onboard computer components for automobiles. In your production plants, complex hydrocarbon solvents are used to clean the chips and other parts that go into the computer components. Some of the solvents used are carcinogens and must be handled with extreme care. Until recently, all of your production plants were located in the United States. However, the cost of production has risen, causing profits to decline.

A number of factors have increased production costs. First, the union representing the workers in your plant waged a successful strike resulting in increased salary and benefits. The pay and benefits package for beginning employees is around $15/hour. A second factor has been stringent safety regulations. These safety procedures, which apply inside the plant, have been expensive in both time and money. Finally, environmental regulations have made Electrocorp's operations more costly. Electrocorp is required to put its waste through an expensive process before depositing it at a special disposal facility.

Shareholders have been complaining to you about the declining fortunes of the company. Many of Electrocorp's competitors have moved their operations to less-developed countries, where their operating costs are less than in the United States, and you have begun to consider whether to relocate a number of plants to offshore sites. Electrocorp is a major employer in each of the U.S. cities where it is located, and you know that a plant closure will cause economic dislocation in these communities. You know that the employees who will be laid off because of plant closures will have difficulty finding equivalent positions and that increased unemployment, with its attendant social costs, will result. However, you are aware of many other corporations, including your competitors, that have shut down their U.S. operations, and it is something that you are willing to consider.

You have hired a consultant, Ms. Smith, to investigate the sites for possible plant relocation. Ms. Smith has years of experience working with companies that have moved their operations to less-developed countries to reduce their operating costs. Based on your own research, you have asked Ms. Smith to more fully investigate the possibility of operations in Mexico, the Philippines, and South Africa. A summary of her report and recommendation for each country follows:

Mexico. A number of border cities in Mexico would be cost-efficient relocation sites based on both labor, health, and safety/environmental factors. Workers in production plants comparable to Electrocorp's earn about $3 per day, which is the prevailing wage. There is frequent worker turnover because employees complain that they cannot live on $3/day, and they head north to work illegally in the United States. However, a ready supply of workers takes their place.
Mexican health and environmental laws are also favorable to production. Exposure to toxic chemicals in the workplace is permitted at higher levels than in the United States, allowing corporations to dispense to some degree with costly procedures and equipment. Mexico's environmental laws are less strict than those of the United States, and a solvent recovery system, used to reduce the toxicity of the waste before dumping, is not required.
The only identifiable business risk is possible bad publicity. The rate of birth defects has been high in many Mexican border towns where similar plants are in operation. Citizen health groups have begun protests, accusing the companies of contamination leading to illness.

Philippines. Conditions in the Philippines are more favorable than those in Mexico in terms of labor, health, and safety/environmental factors.

The prevailing wage in the Philippines is about $1/day, and young workers (under 16) may be paid even less. As in Mexico, the workers complain that the rate of pay is not a living wage, but it is the present market rate.

The health and safety and environmental regulations are equivalent to those in Mexico, but there have been no public complaints or opposition regarding birth defects, cancers, or other illnesses.

South Africa. Conditions in South Africa are positive in some respects, but not as favorable in economic terms as in Mexico or the Philippines. The prevailing wage in South Africa is about $10/day. Furthermore, there is a strong union movement, meaning that there may be future demands for increases in wages and benefits.

The unions and the government have been working together on health and safety issues and environmental protections. Exposure to toxic chemicals in the workplace is not permitted at as high a level as in Mexico and the Philippines. Although the equipment necessary to reduce toxic chemicals to an acceptable level is not as costly as in the United States, this expense would not be incurred in the other two countries. Furthermore, there are requirements for a solvent recovery system, which also increases operation expenses.

1. What should Electrocorp do?

2. If Electrocorp moves operations overseas, what are the potential consequences?

3. If Electrocorp moves operations overseas, should it adopt a lagging, matching, or leading pay policy?

Reference no: EM131020375

Questions Cloud

What is the general theme of these arguments : Explain the concept of the Time Value of Money (TVM). Does the TVM generally imply that "money today" is worth more than "money tomorrow"? Please explain, providing one or more examples that apply the concept of TVM.
Do you believe that walgreen first decision was ethical : While the debate over corporations moving offshore is political, there were clear business advantages. Do you believe that Walgreen's first decision was ethical? Why do you think Walgreen's management reverse course
Research erp to determine what its purpose is : Research ERP to determine what its purpose is. Also, determine what problems have been encountered when different companies in different industries have implemented this kind of system.
Determine prosecute zenith for unfair practices restraint : Apex Manufacturing charges Zenith Manufacturing with predatory pricing (that is, selling below cost). What do you think the antitrust authorities will want to consider before they determine whether to prosecute Zenith for unfair practices in rest..
What are the potential consequences : What should Electrocorp do? If Electrocorp moves operations overseas, what are the potential consequences?  If Electrocorp moves operations overseas, should it adopt a lagging, matching, or leading pay policy
What is the right thing to do : Does he have an ethical dilemma? What's the right thing to do? If he disagrees with the CEO, how does he protect his own career and the interests of his own family
Was georges decision to be open about the impending layoff : Should George tell anyone except his immediate staff about the impending layoff before the details have been worked out? What about the board of directors? The union? The employees? Was George's decision to be open about the impending layoff the et..
Find parametric equations for the given curve : Find parametric equations for the curve that consists of all possible positions of the point P in the figure, using the angle θ as the parameter. The line segment AB is tangent to the larger circle.
What are important ethical qualities to look for in a boss : What's the impact of Rosie and Conor's decisions on Ms. Fitz, the customer? Is it best to be honest with customers, even if it shows your weakness? What are three important ethical qualities to look for in a boss

Reviews

Write a Review

Management Theories Questions & Answers

  Explain how the piece will represent developments

Explain how the piece will represent developments in world events and cultural patterns past and present in Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, or Christianity, and explain why it is appropriate for the proposed location

  Importance to organizational development

Define diversity and describe its importance to organizational development, including the legal entities associated with diversity. 200 words

  How is commercial paper used to raise short-term funds

Briefly describe each of the following techniques for managing inventory:ABC system, economic order quantity (EOQ) model, just-in-time (JIT) system, and computerized systems for resource control?MRP, MRP II, and ERP.

  International business managememt

Identify and explain any two key players in the international business . How do such an organization affect the business across national boundaries?

  An effective decision maker

Reflect on someone you know, perhaps a manager or a leader, who you believe is an effective decision maker. What are some of the characteristics this person displays? What is the specific decision-making model this person appears to use? What have yo..

  The relationship between management and labor

Paper on howsocial media affected the relationship between management and labor.

  Write essay detailing your interpretation of all the data

Submit a three page essay detailing your interpretation of ALL the data you have collected so far, rendering tentative conclusion as to your strengths and weaknesses. Be sure to draw on insight in Kellerman and Quinn et al. text

  Why were all three initial methodologies based on policies

Why were all three initial methodologies based on policies and procedures?

  What is your opinion of the points made in the wsj article

1.      What is your opinion of the points made in the WSJ article, Wall Street Journal article, and “More firms bow to generation Y’s demands”?2.      From ABC’s 7 Ways the Generation Gap Divides the Office, have you observed any of the types of dif..

  Develop a five-year strategic plan with cost estimates

Develop a five-year strategic plan with cost estimates and a time line. It should be 5-7 double-spaced, typed (12 point) pages plus exhibits. Your plan should include/address the following points:Develop a five-year strategic plan with cost estimates..

  Discuss economic endowments of japan

Discuss economic endowments of japan.

  How effectively they are responded to and managed

To what extent does your organization do surveys and polling exercises? What sorts of results do you get? How often is your employee survey, and how well is this communicated? Regarding the issues raised by surveys and polls, assess how effectively t..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd