Should the federal court have had jurisdiction over the case

Assignment Help Marketing Management

Reference no: EM131272744

In 2009, several freelance writers filed a class action lawsuit against publishers, claiming that the publishers had, without permission, reproduced certain works. In other words, the publishers had committed copyright infringement. With the first court's approval, a settlement was reached between the two parties.

However, the writers subsequently decided that they were unhappy with the settlement and appealed. The second court considered whether the federal court had actually had jurisdiction over the case. The second court ultimately determined that federal law (14 USC § 411(a)) takes away federal jurisdiction if a copyright holder has not registered a work prior to suing for copyright infringement.

Thus, the second court reversed the original decision and the settlement did not stand. The case was then brought to the U.S. Supreme Court. The Supreme Court tried to determine whether the failure of a copyright holder was enough to actually take jurisdiction over the case away from a federal court. How do you think the Supreme Court ruled? Should the federal court have had jurisdiction over the case even if the copyright holders failed to register a work prior to the case?

Elsevier, Inc., et al., v. Muchnick et al., 130 S. Ct. 1237, 176 L. Ed. 2d 18; 2010 U.S. LEXIS 2202 (2010).

Reference no: EM131272744

Questions Cloud

Should the federal court have had jurisdiction over the case : Should the federal court have had jurisdiction over the case even if the copyright holders failed to register a work prior to the case?

What are some priority risk factors in your project : What are some priority risk factors in your project? How do these priorities enable overall project accomplishment? Why is it important to prioritize risks in a project?

Was the case moved to a state court or did the federal court : Was the case moved to a state court, or did the federal court want to hear the case because the firing could be loosely tied to federal statutes?

Develop an action plan for the final presentation : Identify the audience, for example a board of directors or a new management team following an acquisition or a merger, for your final presentation due in Week Five. Provide a rationale for your audience selection.

Should the federal court have had jurisdiction over the case : Should the federal court have had jurisdiction over the case even if the copyright holders failed to register a work prior to the case?

Consideration of these measures reveals : Consideration of these measures reveals that it can be difficult to quantify these factors. For your first posting in this Discussion, identify one specific example of a measure of learning an

How does your company encourage their employees : How does your company encourage their employees to do volunteer work? Is there a specific organization such as Habitat for Humanity that your company of choice supports or encourages their employees to volunteer or become involved in.

Did the court of appeals overturn holloways conviction : Arnold Holloway was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death.- Did the court of appeals overturn Holloway's conviction? Why or why not?

User Account

All Pages