Kohlbergs model of moral development

Assignment Help Management Theories

Reference no: EM131379792

On October 4, 2012, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) paid a $2 million reward to a whistleblower that exposed an alleged tax avoidance scheme by Illinois Tool Works Inc. (ITW) that cost the U.S. Treasury hundreds of millions of dollars. The scheme involved ITW enlisting a Swiss bank to fabricate unauthorized tax deductions by duplicating its own tax deductions in order for ITW, as a client and unrelated taxpayer, to claim the same deductions as an offset to ITW's otherwise taxable income.

As a result of tax audits, ITW wrote down its deferred tax asset by $383 million. Whether motivated by a sense of justice or the pursuit of a seven-figure reward, the Wall Street insider known only as "Mr. ABC" has demonstrated the huge return on investment available to IRS whistleblowers that provide information under a program that pays out between 15 percent to 30 percent of any recovery, without any monetary cap on the amount of the reward. It was the third time that Mr. ABC had received an IRS whistleblowing award, including $1.1 million in 2004, when he provided information about abusive tax shelters that helped Enron avoid taxes on more than $600 million of taxable income, and $1.24 million in another case.

In testimony before the 2004 U.S. Senate Finance Committee, Mr. ABC proceeded to explain his motivation to blow the whistle by criticizing the government's ability to identify and investigate sophisticated tax shelters. "When I looked through all the financial engineering and big words, I believed it was just a fake deduction scheme," he testified. The IRS refused to comment, noting confidentiality issues

Questions
1. Should we regard Mr. ABC as a new "caped crusader" or an opportunist? Explain the reasons for your response.

2. Is it ethical for a Wall Street insider to analyze financial data of an unrelated company in order to identify corporate wrongdoing, report it to the appropriate authorities, and then receive a whistleblowing reward?

3. Consider Mr. ABC's motivation for blowing the whistle in the ITW case and the fact that it was the third time he had engaged in whistleblowing to the IRS. Using Kohlberg's model of moral development, at what stage of ethical reasoning would you say Mr. ABC was at? Why?

Reference no: EM131379792

Questions Cloud

Why are government programs seldom terminated : Why are government programs seldom terminated? Provide at least three reasons in your response. Please present an example of a government program that should have been terminated and explain how it may have survived

On what do the weights in this weighted average depend : The boosting algorithm uses a weighted average of a series of classifiers. On what do the weights in this weighted average depend?

Prepare an outline of your paper using the thesis generator : Your company's vice president of human resources has approached your team for assistance in recruiting and developing your organization's future leaders. The vice president has asked your team to brainstorm, research, and prepare a written profile..

Create a global function called updatebucket : Create a global function called "updatebucket(TetrisShape localTetrisShape)" to populate the bucket with values of the "shapeArray". Here, you will use two nested for loops to go over the shapeArray of 4x4.

Kohlbergs model of moral development : Using Kohlberg's model of moral development, at what stage of ethical reasoning would you say Mr. ABC was at? Why?

Describe the relationship between discretion and fairness : Describe the relationship between discretion and fairness. Why are the two terms similar or different in the context of agency actions

What kind of variable is the researcher studying : Stress. A medical researcher measures the increase in heart rate of patients under a stress test. What kind of variable is the researcher studying?

Discuss about the employment tests and hiring : Using the e-Activity, choose two (2) of the following employment tests: drug tests, medical examinations, polygraphs or honesty tests, and scored test of ability. Next, analyze the manner in which the testing itself could be considered illegal whe..

What steps should bennie gordon take : What steps should Bennie Gordon take to ensure that the accounting matter is adequately addressed by the company?

User Account

All Pages