Is the city of cary liable under disparate treatment theory

Assignment Help Project Management

Reference no: EM131432982

Among those who took the Civil Service Exam, Mr. Imelda received the highest score on the written portion. Feeling confident, he applied for a position with the city of Cary. The position required the preparation of written reports and the handling of complaints from the public, either by telephone or face to face. Mr. Imelda is a native of the Philippines, and English is his second language. When he was interviewed for the position, the interviewers had difficulty understanding him because of his thick Filipino accent. The city of Cary decided not to hire Mr. Imelda because the interviewers believed that his heavy accent would impede his verbal capability to respond to complaints, which was an integral part of the position. Upon learning that he did not receive the job, Mr. Imelda appealed through a number of channels. When these appeals proved unsuccessful, he filed an action under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. He claimed he was discriminated against because of his accent and, thus, his national origin. Question:

1. Is the city of Cary liable under the disparate treatment theory?

2. What could the city of Cary have done to mitigate the risk of this claim?

3. What defenses are available to the city of Cary?

Reference no: EM131432982

Questions Cloud

Reliability of such computer-driven measurement strategy : Suppose that a researcher wanted to create a measure of media coverage of a candidate for office, and therefore created a set of coding rules to code words in newspaper articles as either “pro” or “con” toward the candidate. Instead of hiring student..

Male privilege is a sociological term : “Male privilege is a sociological term that refers quite generally to the special rights or status granted to men in a society, on the basis of their sex or gender, but usually denied to women and/or transsexuals.” from Wikipedia. Women usually know ..

Cerner corporation-stinging office memo boomerangs : Cerner Corporation: Stinging Office Memo Boomerangs: You are to assume the role of a communication consultant who has been attained to analyze the business problem, identify the stakeholders and shareholders issues/interests, and recommend to manag..

International jurisdictional issues : A Louisiana resident, Daniel Crummey, purchased a used recreational vehicle (RV) from sellers in Texas after viewing photos of it on eBay. The sellers’ statements on eBay claimed that “Everything works great on this RV and will provide comfort and de..

Is the city of cary liable under disparate treatment theory : Among those who took the Civil Service Exam, Mr. Imelda received the highest score on the written portion. Feeling confident, he applied for a position with the city of Cary. The position required the preparation of written reports and the handling o..

Strategic planning of talent management : Following this week’s reading on talent management, how have your personal views on your own individual talent changed/remained the same? What are your recommendations to leadership in the strategic planning of talent management in today’s global env..

About direct role for interest groups in administration : Some public administrators feel uncomfortable about a direct role for interest groups in administration. Should administration be insulated from the direct demands of external groups? Why or why not?

Events of each component of the registration system : In terms of modeling and simulation. Consider an online registration system for a university or membership registration of some kind. What are the main components of the system and its transactions? How do you define the state and events of each comp..

Blending mild cheddar cheese with extra sharp cheddar cheese : The Whitewave dairy company produces two cheese spreads by blending mild cheddar cheese with extra sharp cheddar cheese. The cheese spreads are packaged in 1.5 pound containers, which are then sold to distributors throughout the Northeast. The Regula..

User Account

All Pages