Fudge the facts-what measurement system dilemmas are present

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131034973

Read the following case and answer the questions below

Fudge the Facts?

In an attempt to improve quality, the shop superintendent at FWM Inc. has instructed all work cell supervisors to keep records of waste, scrap, and rework items. These records will be reviewed periodically at irregular intervals to identify which work cells are performing best and to make adjustments as necessary. The superintendent has stressed that the records will be used for making continual improvements to machining processes and to the performance of individual machinists. But John Simpson, supervisor of Work Cells B and C, is concerned. He was passed over for a promotion the last time he was eligible because his work cells were at the bottom of the company’s performance ratings.

John Simpson is a new father of a child suffering from a rare and debilitating disease that requires the baby to have constant medical attention. Most of the medical costs are covered by FMW’s health insurance policy. So, Simpson cannot risk losing his job and, in turn, his health insurance because his work cells fail to measure up to company quality standards. Simpson’s problem is complicated by the fact that his Work Cells B and C have the least experienced machinists in the company. He knows how competitive the machining business has become. FWM needs the absolute best work from its machinists – no waste, no scrap, and no rework – so the pressure to perform is intense.

Simpson is considering doctoring his waste, scrap, and rework records to make things look better. He knows this is only a temporary tactic. The truth will eventually come out. But he hopes before that happens he will be able to improve the performance of his machining teams to acceptable, competitive levels.

1. What ethical dilemmas are present in this case? Explain.

2. What measurement system dilemmas are present in this case? Explain.

3. Are the shop superintendent’s actions appropriate? Explain. Assume you are the shop superintendent and assume that you are not aware of John Simpson’s dilemma. What, if anything, would you do differently?

4. Assume you are a machinist working in Cell B or C. What advice would you give John Simpson?

5. Assume you are John Simpson’s personal friend. What advice would you give him?

Reference no: EM131034973

Questions Cloud

Delta neutral portfolio of call options and stock : Consider an option on a non-dividend-paying stock when the stock price is $45, the strike price is $42, the risk-free interest rate is 5% per annum, the volatility is 25% per annum, and the time to maturity is five months. It can be shown that d1=..
Desired during the reorder interval-what is reorder point : Annual demand for an item is 18,000 units with the cost per unit at $440. The holding rate is 8% and the order cost is $21.00 per order. The standard deviation of daily demand is 2 units. Assume 263 days in the year and a lead-time of 7 days. If a se..
The hearst and minds of people in a society : How does one win the hearst and minds of people in a society?
Install and maintain a computerized record system : Halifax Ciorp. contracted with the city of Richmond to create, install, and maintain a computerized record system. The contract stated that BIS would be hired as a subcontractore. The work was to be done n two phases. After the first phase, the city ..
Fudge the facts-what measurement system dilemmas are present : In an attempt to improve quality, the shop superintendent at FWM Inc. has instructed all work cell supervisors to keep records of waste, scrap, and rework items. These records will be reviewed periodically at irregular intervals to identify which wor..
Estimated times interest earned ratio : Manufacturer's Inc. estimates that its interest charges for this year will be $700 and that its net income will be $3,000. Assuming its average tax rate is 30%, what is the company's estimated times interest earned ratio?
A monopolist is producing a quantity : If a monopolist is producing a quantity where marginal revenue is equal to $125 and the marginal cost is equal to $125, the monopolist should
Determine the smallest magnitude of the force p : The drum has a weight of 100 lb and rests on the floor for which the coefficient of static friction is µs = 0.5. If a = 3 ft and b = 4 FT
Metrics on the financial statements : Construct this organization's June financials. Once financials are translated, elaborate upon why this information is important for managers to assess. Finally, how to changes in key metrics on the financial statements firm value? In your answer, ..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Research a company that operates in two countries

Accurately applied assigned readings and research literature in the explanation of adjustments made when operating in each country. Accurately applied assigned readings and research literature in the explanation and comparison of how products/ ser..

  Area of organizational development

Select an area of organizational development that interests you and can be applied to your work experiences. Locate five articles on your selected area written by different management theorists and published within the past five years in academic ..

  Explain what role international expansion plays

Recommend what Donahoe should do with Skype. Explain what role international expansion plays in meeting eBay's goals.

  Calculate firms operating breakeven point in sales dollars

American Apparel, Inc. has fixed annual operating costs of $75,000. The average selling price per unit is $14.99 and the variable cost per unit is $4.99. Based on this information, calculate the breakeven sales level in units. Green Grocers Wholesale..

  What is emotional intelligence

What is emotional intelligence? Why is it important particularly for management to have emotional intelligence? How does emotional intelligence improve a manager's work performance?

  Cultivating relationships with customers and vendor partners

Describing Dell's approach to cultivating relationships with customers and vendor partners, Malhotra noted that it was through its alliances with partners such as EMC that Dell was able to leverage their research on product innovation while using its..

  What is annual cost of ordering and carrying cloth

A service garage uses 120 boxes of cleaning cloths per year. Boxes cost $6 each. Ordering cost is $3 and holding cost is 10 percent of purchase cost per unit on annual basis. What is annual cost of ordering and carrying cloth.

  Several companies use their brand as a competitive advantage

Several companies use their brand as a competitive advantage. Given your knowledge about the global economy, identify three brands you believe have the strongest likelihood of remaining a source of advantage in the 21st Century and explain why.

  We change in order to improve his chances of recovery

On November 7, 2010, Edward Nicholson issued a check in the amount of $21,000 payable to the order of Michael Kittinger based upon Kittinger's fraudulent representations concerning a real-estate transaction. Does Nicholson have any chance of recoveri..

  Case study on classic knitwear

Prepare a case study on classic knitwear

  Recognize two companies in unrelated industries that use

identify two companies in unrelated industries that use tpm approaches to ensure reliability in the products or

  Calculate the takt time for the scenario in a system

Calculate the takt time for the scenario in a system where the total time per shift is 460 minutes, there is two shift, and workers are given one 15-minute break and 30 minutes for lunch

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd