Explain william stern vs mary beth whitehead

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM1340439

Explain William Stern vs Mary Beth Whitehead

Case Study:

William Stern vs. Mary Beth Whitehead
New Jersey Supreme Court
109 NJ 396, 537A. 2d 1227
Decision: February 2, 1988

Facts: William and Elizabeth Stern placed an advertisement looking for a surrogate mother. Mary Beth Whitehead responded and entered into a contract with William Stern. Elizabeth Stern, Williams wife, was not considered infertile, but due to her multiple sclerosis, there were concerns that a pregnancy would be too difficult for her physically. The contract stated that Ms. Whitehead would be inseminated with Mr. Stern's sperm. Ms Whitehead would carry the baby to term and at the baby's birth relinquish all her parental rights. She also agreed to relinquish all rights for her to make a decision about an abortion. William Stern agreed to pay Ms. Whitehead $10,000. This amount was considered as "compensation for services and expenses" and was not to be considered as a fee for buying/purchasing of a baby.

It is important to note that Mrs. Stern was not part of the contract and the contract was only between Ms. Whitehead, Richard Whitehead and Mr. Stern.

As part of the contract, Mr. Stern also agreed to pay Ms. Whitehead $1000, in the event that the child was miscarried, or stillborn. In a separate agreement Mr. Stern agreed to pay the infertility center doing the artificial insemination $10,000 (although some reports state $7500). The contract also stated that in the event of Mr. Stern's death prior to the birth of the child, custody would be transferred to Stern's wife, Elizabeth. The child was born on March 27, 1986 and was named by Ms. Whitehead as "Sara Elizabeth Whitehead." Ms. Whitehead transferred custody to the Sterns but requested to see the baby again. In most reports, it stated that Ms Whitehead was suicidal and felt that seeing the new baby would help. The Sterns complied but when they went to retrieve the baby, Ms. Whitehead refused and fled with the baby to Florida. She did make known her intent to not surrender the child. The Sterns then began legal proceedings to enforce the contract. The trial began in January 1987. The judge rendered his decision on March 31, 1987, it was determined the contract was valid. All parental rights of Ms. Whitehead were terminated and Mr. Stern was granted custody. On the same day as the decision Elizabeth Stern adopted the baby and they named her Elizabeth Stern. The judge stated "The parental rights of the defendant, Mary Beth Whitehead, are terminated. Mr. Stern is formally judged the father of Melissa Stern."

Ms. Whitehead appealed to the New Jersey Supreme Court and a ruling was made on February 2, 1988.

Questions:

- Was the contract between Mr. William Stern and Ms. Mary Beth Whitehead valid?
- What evidence?
- How did the court decide?
- Do you agree, why?

Reference no: EM1340439

Questions Cloud

Explain contract- landscaping : Explain Contract- Landscaping and I need to legally draft an agreement to be used solely by the two of us (me and my partner for our own business). If you can substantiate it with at least one Nebraska state case which provides authority for the a..
Explain discussing employment law : Explain Discussing Employment Law and Pretend you are the HR Manager of a large retail department store
Explain employment law - disability : Explain Employment Law - Disability
Explain and employment law - disability and accommodation : Explain and Employment Law - Disability and Accommodation and Based on the Overton versus Reilly case--Do you really think it was "reasonable" for the employer to accommodate Overton by allowing him to nap whenever he needed to
Explain william stern vs mary beth whitehead : Explain William Stern vs Mary Beth Whitehead and is important to note that Mrs. Stern was not part of the contract and the contract was only between Ms. Whitehead, Richard Whitehead and Mr. Stern
Explain partnership corporation and limited liability : Explain Partnership corporation and limited liability and Which is better option of organization if you are opening an small business with a partner and both are investing the same amount of money
Explain children''s advertising law : Explain Children's Advertising Law and What is the problem with Children's advertising? Trace the sequence of events that led to the new law on consumer protection.
Explain legal protection for a business buyer : Explain Legal Protection for a Business Buyer and A man entered into a contract to buy a small business from the entrepreneur who had started it
Explain employment and age discrimination : Explain Employment and Age Discrimination and Carter brings a claim of age discrimination against Warren

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Evaluation of software development

Prepare a report and present an evaluation of the subsequent methodologies for software development in terms of cost, resources and time.

  Explain business ethics and maximizing profits

Explain Business ethics and maximizing profits and Which of the ethical theories discussed in chapter 1 are you most sympathetic to?

  Explain contract types and implications

Explain Contract Types and Implications and A trademark must be registered to support a trademark infringement action

  Explain free speech and duties of public employees

Explain Free Speech and Duties of Public Employees and Determine the appropriate balance between unfettered free speech and the duties of public employee

  Explain covenant not to compete

Explain Covenant not to compete and Explain the way the pre-nuptial agreement (contract consideration of marriage) and why they might enforceable

  Explain business law case study- burg-go

Explain Business Law Case Study- Burg-Go and The police report confirmed that the intruder had not deactivated the burglar system.

  Study on tort reform

Write a research paper on STUDY ON TORT REFORM

  Explain ownership of the engagement ring in divorce

Explain Ownership of the engagement ring in divorce and Where do you stand on this issue

  Explain business law

Explain Business Law and Which is the most expensive form of discovery and If a defendant does not answer the complaint and what is the result?

  Explain employment law case

Explain Employment Law Case and Should an employer be allowed to terminate an employee for working during her lunch break even though the employer mandated that she take a lunch break

  Explain thunderbird and night train express

Explain Thunderbird and Night Train Express- A Role Playing Exercise and This group thinks it is a terrible idea to take the wine off the shelves because it will hurt their businesses and families

  Explain research and analyze a white collar crime

Explain Research and analyze a white collar crime and Discuss the facts of the case and the application of criminal law

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd