Energy Efficient MAC Protocol with Fair-Scheduling Technique

Assignment Help Computer Networking

Reference no: EM133539021 , Length: word count:600

Advanced Computer Networks

Energy Efficient MAC Protocol with Fair-Scheduling Technique in Multi-hop MANETs

Consider and address when reviewing papers. Also be sure to read the paper by A. Smith that was distributed in class.

GENERAL

1. Are key terms defined? If not, which definitions are omitted or inadequate?
2. Is the paper well written? Is the use of English correct, clear and concise? What about spelling?
3. What are the principal claims made by the author? Is the claim justified by the contents of the paper?
4. What the main result(s) of the paper?
5. Is the main result new and important and, if so, why? Or is it either an incremental improvement on earlier work or a rehash of earlier work?
6. What techniques are used to support the author's claims (Analysis, Simulation, Experiment)?
7. What are the best features of the paper? What are the worst features of the paper? What is missing? How can the paper be improved?
8. What future work does the paper suggest or imply?

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

1. Are theorems/lemmas clearly stated?
2. Are proofs correct and complete?
3. Do the theorems and proofs justify the author's claims?

SIMULATION RESULTS

1. Is the system being simulated adequately described?
2. Are simulations described in such a way that it would be possible to repeat the experiment? In particular, are the parameters, their range of values and their relationships to each other clearly described? Are any key (to evaluating the correctness and impact of the simulation) parameters, their values or relationships to other parameters not clearly specified?
3. Are simulation results presented clearly and is this done for a useful range of values?
4. Do you believe that the simulation adequately support the author's claims? If not, why?

EXPERIMENTATION

1. Did the author implement all or part of the system discussed?
2. Is the implementation interesting in its own right and, if so, why?
3. Are performance results of experiments reported and, if so, do the results provide evidence for the author's claims?

REVIEW FORMAT

1. Paper title, reviewer name on separate lines (centered, font: times new roman bold, size 12)
2. One page, single space, margin 1 inch (top, bottom, left, right), font (times new roman, size 10)
3. Reviews must conform to this format. Points will be taken off for non-conformant reviews.

Reference no: EM133539021

Questions Cloud

Identify and define the remaining systems of stratification : Identify and define the remaining systems of stratification. Next, discuss the major components of Karl Marx's view of social stratification.

What circumstances contributed to its implementation : Why did lawmakers increase cigarette purchasing age to 21? What circumstances contributed to its implementation?

Prepare a report for comprehensive case study in textbook : Your homework is to read, analyze, and prepare a report for Comprehensive Case Study in your textbook, Managing Motivation in a Difficult Economy.

Is the Act constitutional under Spending Clause : Is the Act constitutional under the Spending Clause? Explain.

Energy Efficient MAC Protocol with Fair-Scheduling Technique : CEG 7450 Advanced Computer Networks, Wright State University - Energy Efficient MAC Protocol with Fair-Scheduling Technique in Multi-hop MANETs

The role they play in creating caring community of learners : The role they play in creating a caring community of learners? Different methods and strategies that could be used to support them,

What is the cyber policy of United Kingdom : What is the cyber policy of United Kingdom? What are some key terms that have been defined by your nation - including cybersecurity,

Identify at least one strength of the article : The next paragraph should be to identify at least one strength of the article and at least one weakness of the article.

Explain how third parties are adversely affected : Explain how third parties are adversely affected from the pollution and how the negative externality can be internalized.

User Account

All Pages