Compare ralphs and jacks responses to the boy

Assignment Help English

Reference no: EM133922129

Assignment:

Chapter 2 Lord of the flies by William Golding during a community meeting, a younger boy shares his fears about a snake-like beast. Compare Ralph's and Jack's responses to the boy. What is the difference between Ralph's and Jack's approaches to problem-solving in this scene?

Topic: In the community meeting scene, Ralph approaches the boy's fears with rational reassurance and a focus on maintaining order, while Jack exploits the fear to manipulate and assert his authority, topping off their contrasting approaches to problem-solving.

Evidence 1: Ralph's Rational Reassurance Ralph tries to calm the boys by providing logical explanations. He insists there is no beast on the island, saying it's just part of the boys' imaginations. He emphasizes the importance of maintaining a signal fire and focusing on rescue: "We want to be rescued; and of course we shall be." Ralph tries to reassure the younger boys by focusing on practical concerns and maintaining order.

Explanation 1: Ralph's response to the younger boy's fear reflects his rational and orderly approach to leadership. By denying the existence of the beast and emphasizing rescue, Ralph aims to quell the boys' fears through reason. His focus on the importance of the signal fire as a means for eventual rescue represents his commitment to maintaining civility and prioritizing long-term goals over immediate emotional responses.

Evidence 2: Jack's Exploitation of Fear In contrast, Jack uses the mention of the beast to excite and manipulate the boys. He dismisses it initially but then seizes on the fear to assert his dominance, saying if there is a beast, "we'll hunt it and kill it." This approach caters to the boys' fear and offers a sense of protection in allegiance to him.

Explanation 2: Jack's reaction underscores a more authoritarian and instinct-driven response compared to Ralph. By suggesting the possibility of hunting the beast, he channels the group's fear into an opportunity to establish himself as a protector and leader of action. Jack manipulates the boys' fear to undermine Ralph's authority and to foster loyalty through promises of power and security, demonstrating his preference for dominance and control over rational discourse.

Now give me a 5 sentences conclusion

Reference no: EM133922129

Questions Cloud

New antibiotic prescription with an adolescent : A nurse is reinforcing teaching for a new antibiotic prescription with an adolescent what are three teaching points the nurse should reinforce .

Compare practice-based evidence : Compare practice-based evidence, research, and evidence-based practice and discuss how all three complement and support one another.

Consider opportunity for tracking care improvement : Consider an opportunity for tracking care improvement. What key information would be needed in the database?

What was involvement of team members in change process : What was the involvement of team members in the change process? Did rank and file members of the team participate on the team planning for change?

Compare ralphs and jacks responses to the boy : Compare Ralph's and Jack's responses to the boy. What is the difference between Ralph's and Jack's approaches to problem-solving in this scene?

Performance appraisals be abolished : Some management experts have recommended that performance appraisals be abolished.

Diagnosed with dementia : List 6 documents used in healthcare facilities to assess, monitor and document the physical effects that occur to someone who is diagnosed with dementia.

Describe the qualities of effective communication : Describe the qualities of effective communication. Discuss how communication styles can be applied to facilitate productive communication.

Explore world war i and the utilization of military aircraft : For this activity, explore World War I and the utilization of military aircraft.

User Account

All Pages