Pruning - artificial intelligence, Computer Engineering

Pruning - Artificial intelligence

Remember that pruning a search space means deciding that particular branches should not be explored. If an agent  surly  knows that exploring a certain branch will not affect its selection for a particular move, then that branch may be pruned with no concern at all (for example : no effect on the outcome of the search for a move), and the speed up in search may be mean that additional depths may  be searched.

When  minimax approach is using  either for an entire search tree or in a cut off search, there are often many branches which may be pruned because we find out speedy that the best value down a entire  branch is not as good as the best value from a branch we have already explored. Such type of pruning is called alpha-beta pruning.

For an example, imagine that there are four choices for player one, called moves M1, M2, M3 and M4, and we are looking only 2 moves ahead  (1 for player one and 1 for player two). If we do a depth first search for player one's move, we may work out the score they are guaranteed for M1 previous to even considering move M2. Imagine that it turns out that player 1 is guaranteed to score 10 with move M1. We may use this information to reject move M2 without checking all the possibilities for player two's move. For example, suppose that the first option possible for player 2 after M2 from player one means that player 1 will score overall  5 only. We know, In this case, that the maximum player one can score with M2 is 5 or less. Player one, Of course won't select this, because M1 will score 10 for them. We see that there is no point checking all other possibilities for M2. This can be seen in the following diagram (ignore the X's and N's for the time being)

 

1591_Pruning.png

We see that we could reject M2 straight away ,thus in the search space save ourselves 3 nodes. We could reject M3 after we came across the 9, and in the end of the game M4 turns out to be better than M1 for player one. Totally , by using alpha-beta pruning, we avoided looking at 5 end nodes out of 16 - around 30%. If the calculation to assess the scores at end-game states (or estimate them with an evaluation function) is computationally expensive, then this saving could enable a much high search. Moreover, this kind of pruning can arise anywhere on the tree. The general principles are that:

1.   Given a node N which can be selected by player 1, then if along any path, there is another node X, such that (a) X can be selected by player two (b) X is on a higher level than N and (c) X has been shown to guarantee a bad score for player 1 than N, then all the nodes with the same parent as N may be pruned.

2.   Given a node N that can be selected by player two, then if there is a node X along any path such that (a) player one can select X (b) X is on a greater level than N and (c) X has been shown to guarantee a better score for player one than N, then all the nodes contain same parent as N can be pruned.

For an  exercise: which of the principles from these did we use in the M1 - M4 pruning example above? (To make it easy, I've written on the N's and X's).

Because we may prune using the alpha-beta method, it makes sense to carry out a depth-first search using the minimax principle.  In the Comparison to a breadth first search, a depth first search will get to aim states quicker, and this information may be used to determine the scores guaranteed for a player at specific board states, which in turn used to perform alpha-beta pruning. If a game-playing agent used a breadth first search instead of then only right at the end of the search would it reach the goal states and begin to perform minimax calculations. Hence, the agent would miss much potential to peform pruning.

 By using a depth first search and alpha-beta pruning is quite sensitive to the order in which we try operators in our search. For an example in above, if we had selected to look at move M4 first, then we would have been able to do more pruning because of  the higher minimum value (11) from that branch. Often, it is worth to spending some time in  working out how best to order a set of operators, as this will highly  increase the amount of pruning that may occur.

It is clear that a depth-first minimax search with alpha-beta pruning search dominates minimax search alone.  In fact if the effective branching rate of a general minima search was b, then by using alpha-beta pruning will reduce this rate to b. This means, In chess, that the effective branching rate reduces from 35 to around 6, meaning that alpha-beta search can look further moves ahead than a normal minimax search with cutoff.

Posted Date: 10/2/2012 3:45:44 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Pruning - artificial intelligence, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Pruning - artificial intelligence, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Pruning - artificial intelligence Discussions

Write discussion on Pruning - artificial intelligence
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Explain Yet another Compiler-Compiler. YACC uses for "Yet another Compiler-Compiler": Computer program input usually has some structure; actually, all computer programs which

Q. Why Timing Signal Distributor required? What do you mean by Memory Cycle? How many Memory Cycles required for following instructions: 1. ADD 2. CLEAR and ADD 3. DC

The address bus is unidirectional due to the address information is always given by the Micro Processor to address a memory location of an input or output devices.

Q. Write a program to find 1's and 2's complement of a Binary number. Perform necessary checking that if entered number is not a valid number, ask user to enter valid Binary n

What are the different tones used in strowger telephony? Explain with the help of waveforms and the timings. Dial Tone: it is used to indicate that the exchange is ready to r

Elucidate the purpose of GDTR. If the microprocessor sends linear address 00200000H to paging mechanism, which paging directory entry and which page table entry is accessed? GD

What is the  disadvantage of strobe  method. The drawbacks of strobe method are that the source unit that show the transfer has no way of knowing whether the destination unit h

Although there are no compulsory "c" compiler for this subject, but the compiler we are going to use for this example is the Mingw32 compiler. Download the source code files fro

Public Key Infrastructure solutions The use of public-key based security systems requires great attention and due care in design and management of security features. The secur

Write a program to find the area under the curve y = f(x) between x = a and x = b, integrate y = f(x) between the limits of a and b. The area under a curve between two points can b