Polygraph request and termination

Assignment Help Management Theories
Reference no: EM131006969

An employee worked for a military contractor, performing mailroom services at a naval station. One day after work when the mailroom was closed, she returned to retrieve something from the refrigerator. In the process, she discovered fourteen opened and undelivered Christmas cards in the wastebasket. She immediately re- ported the situation to her supervisor. When the supervisor investigated, she found a pay stub among the pieces of undelivered mail. The stub was from the paycheck of another employee who had been working at the front desk for most of that day. All the mailroom employees were sub- sequently asked to submit to a polygraph exam. They were told that the exam was voluntary, and they were asked to sign general release forms. These forms were not signed by any official of the company and did not specifically mention the mail incident or provide the basis for testing each employee. All the employees signed the form. The prime suspect was polygraphed first, and the exam suggested deception in his responses. The contractor still wanted to polygraph the other employees. By this time, the employee who had discovered the undelivered mail refused to take the exam. Less than a week later, she was fired on the grounds that she had accepted package deliveries through the mailroom's back door in violation of naval security procedures. The em- ployee sued, challenging both the polygraph request and her termination. What should the court decide? Why? (Polkey v. Transtecs Corp., 404 F.3d 1264 (11th Cir. 2005))

Reference no: EM131006969

Questions Cloud

Illegal arrangements between the company : The employee believed that he had been terminated at the behest of union officials, who wanted him fired because he had objected to certain potentially illegal arrangements between the company and union. What should the court decide? Why? (Pugh v...
Gaining different perspectives allow organizations : Likewise, gaining different perspectives allow organizations to reevaluate organizational norms on a more consistent basis. Brown (2011) stated only the more healthy organizations allow their members to challenge their norms. Shifts in paradigms o..
Privacy protection for e-mail : 1. Is the current privacy protection for e-mail and Internet use sufficient?
Hipaa from releasing the medical file : A nurse was terminated from her job at a hospital for improperly medicating a patient. When she sought to obtain information from the hospital for a hearing on her termination, she was told that the hospital was prohibited by HIPAA from releasing ..
Polygraph request and termination : Less than a week later, she was fired on the grounds that she had accepted package deliveries through the mailroom's back door in violation of naval security procedures. The em- ployee sued, challenging both the polygraph request and her terminati..
What is the minimum value of the directional derivative : What is the minimum value of the directional derivative of f at the point (1,-2). Find a vector u so that D f ( 1 , - 2 ) = 0.
Why might ineffective leaders get promoted : Why do so many managers seem ineffective? Why might ineffective leaders get promoted? What organizational design characteristics are at work in these situations, and how might they be improved? Provide examples from your own or your organization'..
Hiv-positive status and marijuana : In the course of a meeting regarding an employee's absences from work, a doctor at a veteran's hospital divulged the HIV-positive status and marijuana use of the employee to the employee's union representatives.
Electronic communications privacy act : When word got back to the pilot who had created the Web site that a manager had accessed it and was threatening to sue him for defamation, the pilot sued. Did the airline violate the Electronic Communications Privacy Act? (Konop v. Hawaiian Airlin..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Management Theories Questions & Answers

  A home-builder to build homes

Research the construction industry to learn what the inputs are that are used by such a homebuilder to build homes (the homes are obviously the output that is being produced by the homebuilder). Be sure to include some inputs that are not strictly la..

  Classical organizational theory deals

Classical Organizational Theory deals with the "systematic processes necessary to make bureaucracy more efficient and effective." Name three scholars that are credited with the development of classical organization thought that most correctly fit int..

  Vietnamese catfish importers to step

Was it fair for the Vietnamese catfish importers to step in and capture market share while the market has been expanded due to the significant efforts and investments of the domestic industry?

  What are the three generations of knowledge management

What are the three generations of knowledge management to date? What was the primary focus of each? What are the different types of roles required for each of the above three generations

  Should develop a procedure for audit in my company

The question comes like this''' I should develop a procedure for audit in my company or organization,what are the procedures i will use for my audit,Using standard ISO-Documentation,Process of audit,access by persons in the department.Consider ..

  Provide therapy for patients in hospitals

He also contracts with other organizations to provide therapy for patients in hospitals and members of churches and other nonprofit organizations. He anticipates that he will need two offices and will need to hire staff to help with phone calls, a..

  Four cs that are determinants of high performing teams

Discuss the four Cs that are determinants of high performing teams, and explain how they contribute to superior performance of teams. Your response should be at least 200 words in length. You are required to use at least your textbook as source mater..

  Are the company business functions integrated

What has made the company you have chosen successful today? Discuss value chain activities/improvements. Are they customer focused, quality focused, low-price leader focused?

  Current technology in health care delivery

As a member of ABC Consultants, you have been hired by a large organization to develop an innovated approach using current technology in health care delivery. This can be a product, a service, or an application.

  Explain the advantages of single sourcing and sole sourcing

Explain the advantages and disadvantages of "single sourcing," "sole sourcing," "dual sourcing," and "multiple sourcing"! Give the main characteristics of "modular sourcing" and "system sourcing"!

  Defines the the importance of brand

Defines the The Importance of Brand

  Contemporary management practice of google

Critically discuss how one or more of the classical management theories discussed in week 1 are relevant to the contemporary management practice of an organisation/company of your choice(Google Inc).

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd