User Account

All Pages

You are the secretary for a large church you have a

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13351148

You are the secretary for a large church. You have a database with over 5000 names, addresses and telephone numbers.

A local merchant approaches you with a request for accessing the database. A very substantial donation is offered at a time when the church is facing cash flow problems.

Make two ethical arguments to support each of two major options: sharing or not sharing the data with the merchant.

Four Step Case Analysis Process

 Step I. Understanding the situation.

A) What are the relevant facts?

B) Which of these facts raises an ethical issue?  Why?  What is the potential or resulting harm?

C) List the stakeholders involved

Step II. Isolating the major ethical dilemma.

What is the ethical dilemma to be resolved NOW?  State it using the form: Should someone do or not do something?  Note: Just state the dilemma here; leave the reasoning for Step III

Step III. Analyzing the ethicality of both alternatives in Step II

Consequentialism

A.  If action in Step II is done, who, if anyone, will be harmed?

B.  If action in Step II is not done, who, if anyone, will be harmed?

C.  Which alternative results in the least harm, A or B?

D.  If action in Step II is done, who, if anyone, will benefit?

E.  If action in Step II is not done, who, if anyone, will benefit?

F.  Which alternative results in the maximum benefit, D or E?

Rights and Duties

G.  What rights have been or may be abridged?  What duties have been or may be neglected?  Identify the stakeholder and the right or duty.  When listing a right, show its corresponding duty and vice versa.

Kant's Categorical Imperative

H. If action in Step II is done, who, if anyone, will be treated with disrespect?

I. If action in Step II is not done, who, if anyone, will be treated with disrespect?

J. Which alternative is preferable, H or I? ?

K. If action in Step II is done, who, if anyone, will be treated unlike others?

L. If action in Step II is not done, who, if anyone will be treated unlike others?

M. Which alternative is preferable, K or L?

N. Are there benefits if everyone did action in Step II?

O. Are there benefits if nobody did action in Step II?

P. Which alternative is preferable, N or O?

Step IV. Making a decision and planning the Implementation

A. Make a defensible ethical decision

Based on the analysis in Step III, answer the question in Step II. Indicate the letters of the categories that best support your response. Add any arguments justifying your choice of these ethical principles to support your decision. Where there are conflicting rights and duties, choose and defend those that take precedence. (Note: Just make and justify your choice here; leave any action steps for parts B and D)

B. List the specific steps needed to implement your defensible ethical decision.

C. Show how the major stakeholders are affected by these actions.

D. What other longer-term changes (political, legal, technical, societal, organizational) would help prevent such problems in the future?

E. What should have been done or not done in the first place (at the pivot point) to avoid this dilemma?

Reference no: EM13351148

Questions Cloud

Problem 1 modify the state diagram branching conditions in : problem 1. modify the state diagram branching conditions in the diagrams below as needed to ensure the sum and
From the it distribution point of view how do you believe : from the it distribution point of view how do you believe that information sharing could lead to a reduction of lead
1 introductionthe groundwater level has risen and now is : 1. introductionthe groundwater level has risen and now is present in the cut. answer the following questions. show
Address the following scenario providing two distinct : address the following scenario providing two distinct options and arguing the benefits and costs of each. you are the
You are the secretary for a large church you have a : you are the secretary for a large church. you have a database with over 5000 names addresses and telephone numbers.a
Supporting mobile health clinics the childrens health fund : supporting mobile health clinics the childrens health fund of new york city. see case study below.bull examine the case
Part-1you have spent a lot of time developing your : part-1you have spent a lot of time developing your application and released it to the field. now you are starting to
Risk management has become ever more important in planning : risk management has become ever more important in planning organizing and managing projects events and continuous
In this assignment you will be asked to implement a card : in this assignment you will be asked to implement a card game. you will need to make several design decisions for your

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Important to the international state of affairs in 1450

How did human history in North America during the period described in the Prologue differ from the events of Asia, Eurasia, and Europe? Be specific. How were these differences important to the international state of affairs in 1450?

  Benefits of using quantitative tools and techniques

In baseball, where the traditional approach to assessing player potential and performance has involved watching the individual play in different settings (scouting the player) and where most of the team management would not have a business background..

  Relationship between nutrition-obesity-fitness

How does the disease affect the body? What are the signs and symptoms that aid in detection of the disease? Does it have a retionship between NUTRITION, OBESITY AND FITNESS?

  Original moral condition

Original moral condition: Is the child born moral, immoral, or amoral? What is the original or genetically determined condition of the child? Can the newborn be a mix of the three, depending on which aspect of development is under consideration?

  Effectiveness of hipaa

Do you feel enough has been done to ensure the confidentiality of patient information and records? Or, do you feel the legislation has gone too far?

  Wide disparity in victimization

Older citizens report less victimization than teens. What reasons could help account for such a wide disparity in victimization? Explain.

  What measures should the project manager take

What measures should the project manager take to bring the project back on schedule and within budget? There is also a request from customers to make a few changes to the layout and finishing of rooms.

  What distinguishes sale on approval-sale on consignment

What are the UCC principles of good faith and reasonableness to sales contracts? What are the different ways that title transfers under UCC Article 2? Which party bears the risk? What distinguishes a sale on approval, sale on consignment, and sale or..

  Text segment in user structure-singals-disk device strive

When a system can perform many functions simultaneously, this is called: In windows, the group of services and subsystems that support the kernel are called: The text segment in a user structure contains:

  One by-product of the development of the railroads was

One by-product of the development of the railroads was

  Managing stress

As an adult student, you may be challenged to satisfy multiple demands on your time and resources. How would you describe your current level of stress? What impact has stress had on your ability to perform in school and in life?

  Quality initiatives result in immediate profit improvement

Do quality initiatives result in an immediate profit improvement? How would an organization determine if the quality initiative results need to be measured? How would the organization determine when to measure the improvement?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

Submit Assignment

Academics

Major Subjects

Majors

Get In Touch

whatsapp: +1-415-670-9521

Phone: +1-415-670-9521

Email: [email protected]

TERMS & POLICIES

HELP & SUPPORT

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd