Study demonstrates ethical dilemma

Assignment Help Science

Reference no: EM134016234

Assignment.

In healthcare, we are faced with ethical decisions every day. This case study demonstrates an ethical dilemma.

Bob is a 48-year-old man and up until now, he has been in good shape and healthy. Bob is brought to the emergency department of Mares Medical Center, arriving incapacitated, elevated temperature, and hypotensive, with abnormal labs, showing evidence of renal failure. Bob has meningitis and his condition is grave without intensive care treatment. Treatment in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) will offer Bob the opportunity to make a full recovery but without it he is almost certain to die.

Unfortunately, the ICU at Mares Medical is full, with some of the patients being critically ill and some being in relatively stable condition but still requiring intensive care treatment for optimal care. As healthcare providers, it is recognized that evidence shows if a patient is moved too early from intensive care treatment there is a potential increase in patient complications and mortality.

The ED provider is told that there is an available bed in an ICU at a neighboring hospital, which is fifty miles away. The ED provider knows that Bob may not make the 50-mile transport, and therefore is faced with the decision, should Bob be moved to the neighboring hospital, or should a patient, who is already in Mares ICU, be transferred to the step-down unit to allow Bob admission to the Mares ICU floor.

Keeping in mind that it is not possible to provide the best care to both patients, answer the following questions. (be sure to support your answers with at least 2 EB resources).

1. As the decision maker, how should this case be approached?

2. What are at least 2 (or more) ethical principles that are used in the decision-making process as a healthcare professional?

3. Is patient autonomy relevant in this situation?

4. Does the healthcare team owe an equal duty of care to both patients?

5. If each patient is owed the same duty of care, should the goal be to maximize the chance that both patients live, or minimize the chance that both patients die?

6. In contrast, should the sickest patient be given any greater priority in receiving the best possible care?

7. If the current patient in Mares Medical ICU is owed a greater duty of care, is this sufficient to justify the decision not to admit Bob, given the foreseeable probable outcome?

8. In state Healthcare Laws does the right to 'Access of Care' mean 'Best Care'?

Reference no: EM134016234

Questions Cloud

Intranasal lesion procedure-biopsy of intranasal lesion : Code the following outpatient hospital case (for the surgeon/physician): Diagnosis: Intranasal lesion Procedure: Biopsy of an intranasal lesion.

Participating in cardiac rehabilitation program : An older adult woman is participating in a cardiac rehabilitation program following an acute myocardial infarction (MI) that occurred one month ago.

Abdominal pain and back pain by her kidneys : A 35 year old woman came into the clinic with abdominal pain and back pain by her kidneys.

Discharged with prescription for metformin : The nurse is teaching a client being discharged with a prescription for metformin [Glucophage] twice a day.

Study demonstrates ethical dilemma : In healthcare, we are faced with ethical decisions every day. This case study demonstrates an ethical dilemma.

Healthcare provider tells practical nurse : A healthcare provider tells the practical nurse (P) that a neighbor is a client on the unit and asks to review their medical record.

Low anterior bowel resection for adenocarcinoma : A 75-year-old male patient from a skilled nursing facility is admitted to hospital for a low anterior bowel resection for an adenocarcinoma of the sigmoid colon

Describe alternative care settings in which respiratory care : Describe alternative care settings in which respiratory care is often performed. State how to ensure safety and infection control in alternative settings.

User Account

All Pages