Should the court allow the case to proceed

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM13783089

In the scenario below explain the best solution. Include comments related to any ethical issues that arise. You should try to locate at least one case that has been decided on the issue or one that is currently pending to support your answer.

Please cite in APA

Dr. Arthur Ritus obtained his degree in chiropractic medicine by taking out $100,000 in Health Education Assistance Loans from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services during the period from 1995 through 1997 and from other government sources from 1998 to 2002. Loan repayment was not scheduled to start until 2005. In 2005, Dr. Ritus became one of the ordained ministers of the Millcreek Life Academy (MLA) in Millcreek, Utah. As a minister, Ritus was required to take a vow of poverty, which required him to renounce any interest in real or personal property and any income and grant all interests in those assets to MLA. In 2005, Dr. Ritus accepted a position as a full-time employee to perform medical services to inmates at the Department of Corrections in Salt Lake City, Utah. Instead of using his own social security number, Ritus provided the Department of Corrections with a number issued by MLA. Checks were deposited to one of the MLA bank accounts and then MLA transferred approximately $12,000 a month to another account set up by Dr. Ritus. In August 2010, Dr. Ritus filed a voluntary bankruptcy petition under Chapter 7 to obtain a discharge of his debts. Dr. Ritus made the following claims to his attorney.

  • The $12,000 received each month consisted of gifts from which no taxes or deductions were taken.
  • The home purchased by Dr. Ritus was deeded to his estranged wife in 2007.
  • Dr. Ritus voluntarily paid alimony and child support for his estranged wife and children.
  • Dr. Ritus claimed that he was only left with $1500 a month to pay his own expenses; therefore, he could not repay the student loans.
  • Dr. Ritus drives a 2010 Mercedes Benz S-Class Sedan, titled to the MLA and valued at approximately $75,000.

Should the court allow the case to proceed?

Should the loans be discharged?

Identify any other potential issues; provide responses to all questions supporting your answer with legal reasoning, examples, and other scholarly materials.

Reference no: EM13783089

Questions Cloud

Determine the optimal quantity to order each time manager : Mobius Designs is a construction company that must carry inventory of cement to fulfill their work orders. They expect the annual demand to be 10,000 tanks of cement. Assume that they operate 52 weeks a year. Each time they place an order it costs $3..
Use of social media and the internet : Create a multimedia presentation (8-12 slides) that depicts the use of social media and the Internet in popular American culture.
Write a creative essay on a story that happened to me : Write a ten pages creative essay about a story that happened to me.
Level of fund flows between household savers : Discuss this concept: "In an economy without FIs, the level of fund flows between household savers and the corporate sectors is likely to be quite low."
Should the court allow the case to proceed : Dr. Arthur Ritus obtained his degree in chiropractic medicine by taking out $100,000 in Health Education Assistance Loans from the U.S. Should the court allow the case to proceed? Should the loans be discharged
Select a health care policy that interests you : Refer to the HHS website Regulations, and select a health care policy that interests you. Use this policy to fulfill the following scenario:
Consumer attributes-market research firm : Imagine you work for a well-known market research firm. Your supervisor has asked you to calculate numerical values for consumer attitudes using the Fishbein expectancy-value model, A = ?be. In your preliminary research for a client that manufacturer..
Case study on current financial situation : Reputation in the community is excellent; however, there have been some recent complaints about the downturn in quality in the community clinics.
Impact of credibility-physical attractiveness : What - Discuss the Characteristics of the Message: What attributes are inherent in persuasive messages? How are we influenced by the emotion, framing, narratives, and rational appeals in the messaging we receive? What is the significance of the sl..

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Discuss the topics you are comfortable with the topics you

discuss the differences between substantive law procedural law criminal law civil law common law and statutory law.

  What security management can do to minimize the potential

Analyze and discuss the vulnerabilities and recommend what security management can do to minimize the potential of a government or private organization being at risk for cybersecurity damage

  Case law and statute law

Refer to the relevant case law and statute law in your answer. you must read the presentation guidelines in the subject outline. Your answer must NOT 3 A4 pages, excluding the biblography

  What the hypothesis will suggest about criminal justice

Explain what the hypothesis will suggest about criminal justice theory if confirmed. Explain what the hypothesis will suggest about criminal justice theory if not confirmed

  What is the bias young is exploring and what are its effects

What is the bias Young is exploring and what are its effects, How might Young's analysis relate to forms of discrimination other than race-based

  Assume you are a high-ranking official in a law enforcement

as you learned in your readings before interrogating a suspect in police custody the police need to inform the suspect

  Advise both parties about their legal position

Edward is outraged at Jane's declaration and his first response has been to sue her for the $30,000 that he claims is outstanding from his refitting the coffee shop -Advise both parties about their legal position in respect to this dispute between ..

  Explain osha regulations- proving a violation

Explain OSHA Regulations- Proving a violation and An employee gets injured on the job and believes that the injury was a result of the employer not abiding by Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) regulations

  What legal concepts are implicated in these facts

Ray Johnson sued NAC for wrongful death and for his physical injuries. Is NAC liable for Mark Wilson's actions? Why or why not? What legal concepts are implicated in these facts

  A description of jails place in corrections and its role

write a 1050 word paper using the information found in the cji interactive multimedia and this weeks readings. include

  Provide at least two examples of cases where the doctrine

1.introduction that includes the thesis statement .2.describe the meaning of the legal doctrine respondeat

  What are the methods of treatment for heroin addiction

What are the methods of treatment for heroin addiction? What is the difference between heroin detoxification and heroin addiction treatment

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd