Issues with standardization of products

Assignment Help Science
Reference no: EM132664393

Case Study 1: Issues with Standardization of Products

You are the OR Director at Metropolitan Suburban Hospital. You've come to realize that there are two major companies that manufacture sutures for the operating room. At this time, your operating room is using the most popular sutures on the market. The leading competitor gives you a proposal for switching sutures. By using their comparable sutures your hospital could potentially save almost $2 million next year.

In order to see if the sutures are acceptable, you begin a clinical trial. The trial consists of new sutures being offered to the surgeons, with a representative explaining the similarities and differences. After using the suture, the surgeon is to fill out an evaluation, assessing how he/she perceived the suture to handle and whether or not it was truly equivalent to the old suture.

The company supplied a representative to be in charge of this evaluation. The representative was an extremely attractive young lady, who not only explained the sutures, but was also quite flirtatious toward the surgeons. She wore loosely fitting scrub suits and made a habit of bending over and picking up product from her cases that were always on the floor. The surgeons, for the most part, found her attractive and pleasant. After they were done with the surgery, she would hand them the evaluation form. Not surprisingly, most of the surgeons gave the new suture very high ratings.

The data were compiled and showed that the new suture was not only comparable, but may be even preferred over the old suture. The results of the survey were presented at a meeting of the Surgical Executive Council, a group comprised of the leadership of surgeons in the hospital. Interestingly enough, the presentation was done in the absence of any representatives from the company. After the presentation was completed it was suggested that, since the two-suture product line were equivalent, there did not seem to be any reason why the hospital should not go with the product that would have save the $1.8 million.

At that point, there was a lot of dissension among the surgeons, who stated that they would not use the new suture. Furthermore, if they were forced to use a new suture, they would consider taking their work to a nearby hospital. Being perplexed by this, you asked them how they could have evaluated the suture so highly even they thought so poorly of it. To a person they all stated they did not wish to offend the representative and they falsely evaluated the sutures.

The repercussions of switching the sutures became so great that the hospital was forced to return the original suture, despite several of the senior surgeons indicating that it probably made no difference in terms of outcome as to what suture was used. This was definitely a minority opinion.

Case Questions

1. What are the pertinent issues in this case?

2. What were the problems with the way evaluation of the product was designed and carried out?

3. What are the supply-side and demand-side implications of this scenario?

4. Design a method for product evaluation that would eliminate bias and assure the collection of accurate data.

5. Knowing surgeons are creatures of habit, how might one design a clinical trial that could make surgeons more comfortable with using a new product?

 

Reference no: EM132664393

Questions Cloud

FNSFMK505 Comply with financial services regulation : FNSFMK505 Comply with financial services regulation and industry codes of practice - Identify and explain 2 duty of care considerations the FSP
Compute the weights for disney equity : Walt Disney Company's corporate finance, Compute the weights for Disney's equity and debt based on the market value of equity and Disney's market value of debt
Discuss the use of narcotic medication in the united states : Discuss the use of narcotic/opioid/barbiturate/sleep medication in the United States, including the change in patterns over the past 15 years.
Calculate disney net debt by subtracting cash from debt : Calculate Disney's net debt by subtracting its cash from its debt. Recalculate the weights for the WACC using the market value of equity, net debt
Issues with standardization of products : What are the pertinent issues in this case? What are the supply-side and demand-side implications of this scenario?
Discuss practice patterns for controlling type 2 diabetes : Discuss the practice patterns for controlling type 2 diabetes, the expected health outcomes, and the outcomes for different populations.
Make the necessary adjusting entry in general journal form : Make the necessary adjusting entry in general journal form Supplies account has a balance of $4,290. Supplies on hand at the end of the period totaled $2,400.
Describe the common side-effects profile : The purpose of this assignment is to draft and submit a comprehensive and complete rough draft of your medication paper in APA format. Your rough draft should.
Truth about the definition of homeland security : What is your assessment of the "truth" about the definition of homeland security? In other words, what do you believe homeland security really is?

Reviews

Write a Review

Science Questions & Answers

  Journal of pharmaceutical sciences

This journal is a scientific publication of Indian Pharmaceutical Association and highlights various bright points of it.

  Optical fibres

This document discuss about the main attributes and characteristics of optical fibres.

  Micro organisms

This project report reveals the fact and proves a specific objective mentioned to be studied upon.

  Describing histology of an organ

The discussion of the technique should include a literature review on the evolution of the technique.

  Interpret the sensitivity of mammography

Calculate and interpret the sensitivity of mammography. Diagnostic test with Sensitivity 50%, Specificity 50% and prevalence 50%. Crude mortality rate. Damage caused by motor vehicle accidents.

  Discuss the role that science plays in your daily life

Role that science plays in your daily life and Integrity, Intensity, Innovation, and involvement in scientific field

  Prepare a flexible budget gator divers

Prepare a Flexible Budget Gator Divers is a company that provides diving services such as underwater ship repairs to clients in the Tampa Bay area.

  Neurological disorders

Designing a neuroprosthesis for the neurological disorders

  Complexity of cell surfaces

Lipid rafts provide another example of the complexity of cell surfaces in both their structural character and biologic functionality. Please explain the nature of these structures and their functionality.

  Exploratory activity on bird beaks

Describe how natural selection and evolution are demonstrated by this activity

  Spatial and temporal variation of heat content in the upper

In this study the temporal and spatial variation of heat content in the upper 70m layer of the Arabian Sea was for a period of 1991 to 2008 have been attempted.

  Earthquake databases

Earthquake Databases

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd