Explain the concept of validity to a friend

Assignment Help HR Management
Reference no: EM13985912

1. Imagine a hypothetical scenario in which you are trying to explain the concept of validity to a friend. You present the following as an example of a valid argument:

All dogs are fish

 Fido is a dog 

Fido is a fish

Your friend responds: "How can this argument be valid when it obviously just plain crazy? The conclusion as well as the premises are false. You said that if an argument is valid then it is based on good reasoning. But clearly the reasoning in this argument is horrendously bad. If this argument is valid then the concept of validity is useless. I don't need to learn anything more about it. I would rather just use common sense to evaluate arguments."

How would you explain to your friend that the reasoning at the basis of this argument is actually good and that the concept of validity is critical for the evaluation of arguments? Include your explanation a definition of validity.

Reference no: EM13985912

Questions Cloud

Define willpower and explain what it means : Using your own words, define willpower and explain what it means to you in a complete paragraph of at least three sentences. Think about a situation that you are currently facing as a college student that requires willpower
An increase in the wage rate of labor : Explain why the following statement is either true or false. An increase in the wage rate of labor (with no change in the rental rate of capital) shifts the long-run cost curve upward (at each level of output), no matter what the elasticity of substi..
Problem regarding the consequences of choices : By what methods are commodities produced and the consequences of choices about ________ and the consequences of choice about production methods are topics in Theory of Production.
Firms evaluate the extent to which labor force is unionized : McDonald's and its major competitors compete based: In terms of location decisions, firms evaluate the extent to which the labor force is unionized.
Explain the concept of validity to a friend : Imagine a hypothetical scenario in which you are trying to explain the concept of validity to a friend. You present the following as an example of a valid argument:
How might the presence of dark matter impacted the clocks : How might the presence of dark matter (presumably all over the place) impacted the clocks if say the dark matter is stationary relative to the earth's rotation?
Profits were declining from selling the discounted items : In 2002 - 2003, some McDonalds' franchise owners reported that profits were declining from selling the discounted items from the Dollar Menu. This suggests that: McDonalds kept its U.S.-based menu when entering the Chinese market.
Problem regarding the law and ethics in health care : Laws and ethical principles safeguard society as a whole and are crucial in guiding the practice of health care. The important role that these disciplines play can be seen clearly in cases involving highly charged issues such as organ donation
What is the value of the charge q : The 2 conducting spheres are charged to -Q and +5Q and are placed as shown in the figure. The potential at point P is 1.44 x 104 V. what is the value of the charge "Q"?

Reviews

Write a Review

HR Management Questions & Answers

  Much of the oral communication that goes on in business is

much of the oral communication that goes on in business is the informal person-to-person communication that occurs

  Explain the differences between convergent and divergent

what are the differences between convergent and divergent thinking? what factors stimulate divergent thinking and why?

  What is candidates legal right to privacy with social media

What is your recommended action regarding Mary Jane's candidacy for the Field Sales Manager position, in light of this new information and what is the candidate's legal right to privacy with social media such as Facebook? Submit response of no more..

  Evaluate the criteria employees

Question: Describe and evaluate the criteria employees use to evaluate the fairness of a pay structure.

  Effects of substance abuse on the family

Substance-abuse problems not only affect the user but also his or her family and relationships. Write a report that addresses the effects of substance abuse on the family and relationships of the user, covering the following issues.

  Metaphysical account of reality

Present an account of at least one metaphysical account of reality from the assigned readings with support from the course texts and online lectures. For example, you might discuss Plato, Aristotle, or the Cartesian method.

  Create an implementation proposal for a hris

Create an implementation proposal for a HRIS that will manage employee information and Payroll. You will be acting as the HR Director who will be presenting to the executive team of the company

  Show the value of understanding job analysis information

Value of understanding job analysis information - What is the value of understanding job analysis information as an operating manager?

  Job description-job analysis and basic pay structure

Now that you have your job description, job analysis, and basic pay structure created for your new position, start to take a look at the benefits you will offer this employee.

  Human resource enterprisesthis discussion posting should

human resource enterprisesthis discussion posting should come to around 200-300 words.consider the following statement

  Human resources recruitment and selectionshow the

human resources recruitment and selectionshow the importance of recruitment and selection and analyse the different

  How can you enhance effective global leadership

How can you enhance effective global leadership? What are the four "Ts" for personal development strategies that increase global business savvy?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd