Efficient medical care or disaster in the making

Assignment Help Operation Management

Reference no: EM132280637

The Electronic Medical Record: Efficient Medical Care or Disaster in the Making?

Dale Buchbinder

You are the Chief Information Officer (CIO) of a large health care system. Medicare has mandated that all medical practices seeking Medicare compensation must begin using electronic medical records (EMR). Medicare has incentivized medical practices to place electronic medical records in their offices by giving financial bonuses to medical practices that achieve certain goals. These EMR systems are supposed to allow communication between practitioners and hospitals, so medical information can be rapidly transferred to provide more efficient medical care. The EMR will enable physicians to allow access to the records of their patients by other providers. Eventually these records are supposed to be easily accessed so any physician or hospital will have complete medical information on a patient.

The physician practices in your health care system have been mandated to use the Unified Medical Record System (UMRS). The UMRS was designed by a central committee; all hospital-owned physician practices have been mandated to use the system. As part of the incentives, Medicare will add dollars back to each practice when they meet goals for reaching meaningful use (MU). MU has been defined by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (n.d.) as “using certified electronic health record (EHR) technology to:

• Improve quality, safety, efficiency, and reduce health disparities

• Engage patients and family

• Improve care coordination, and population and public health

• Maintain privacy and security of patient health information.”

It is a step-by-step system requiring “electronic functions to support the care of a certain percentage of patients” (Jha, Burke, DesRoches, Joshi, Kralovec, Campbell, & Buntin, 2011, p. SP118).

One of the hospitals in your system has many primary care and specialty practices; however, the UMRS system was designed primarily for the primary care practices. The committee that developed UMRS did not take into account the needs of the specialty practices, which are significantly different from the primary care practices. This issue has been brought to the forefront by several medical specialists who have stated UMRS is not only cumbersome, but also extremely difficult to use. UMRS also does not give the specialist the information he needs. Specialists noted that after UMRS was implemented, it took them approximately 10 to 15 minutes longer to see each patient. Since an average day for a specialist consists of seeing between 20 and 25 patients, adding 10 to 15 minutes per patient adds 200 to 250 additional minutes, or 3 to 4 hours more each day. And, the physician cannot see the same number of patients each day. In reality, this represents a 30% decrease in productivity because of the amount of time it takes to use UMRS. Now the specialist office schedules constantly run significantly later than they should, and patients become unhappy and impatient. Several of the specialists reported that a number of patients have gotten up and left without being seen. In short, the mandate to use UMRS has impacted the efficiency and productivity of the subspecialists and specialists, further decreasing revenues for the system.

In addition, all of the physicians have complained the UMRS does not communicate well with other electronic medical record systems, or even the hospital’s own patient information systems. There is no real integration of the medical databases as intended, levels of meaningful use are unclear, and in some areas, difficult to achieve, again because the UMRS was tailored to primary care practices’ prescribing patterns. Specialists, particularly surgeons, do not write a large number of prescriptions. Surgeons have been mandated to write electronic prescriptions to reach meaningful use; however, in many cases this is not appropriate for surgical patients.

All of these issues and concerns were reported to the central committee that created UMRS in response to federal mandates and financial incentives. The committee responded it cannot modify the system to make it more friendly to specialists and subspecialists, despite the fact that procedures performed by the subspecialists account for substantial revenues. Revenues are down and the morale of the specialists and subspecialists has plummeted to the point that many are talking about taking early retirement or leaving the system. Still, the committee refuses to fix the problems. Since you are the CIO of the entire health care system, the situation is now in your hands.

1. Specifically identify the major and secondary problems, what are the real issues and what are the differences?

Reference no: EM132280637

Questions Cloud

Four types of processes used to produce goods and services : Describe the four types of processes used to produce goods and services. Explain how you would develop layout of an office.

Advantages or disadvantages of first-mover strategies : Please name one or two advantages or disadvantages of first-mover strategies.

Satisfied with the dining experience as older customers : Company leadership has concerns younger diners are not as satisfied with the “dining experience” as older customers.

What is the plant best operating level : What is the plant's best operating level? How many units must be assembled before operation makes a profit? At what volume is the plant's total profit maximized

Efficient medical care or disaster in the making : You are the Chief Information Officer (CIO) of a large health care system. Medicare has mandated that all medical practices seeking Medicare compensation

Milton friedman concept that obeying the law : Traditionally, business adopted Milton Friedman’s concept that obeying the law is the only legitimate constraint to the pursuit of profit.

Are organizations that use triple bottom line : Are organizations that use a triple bottom line or institute a CSR model at a financial disadvantage compared to firms that concentrate on profit within the law

Contrast the terms strategies and tactics : Contrast the terms strategies and tactics. Contrast organization strategy and operations strategy.

What has been apple major competitive advantage to date : What has been Apple’s major competitive advantage to date? Is this competitive advantage “sustainable” going forward?

User Account

All Pages