Assessing heuristic searches-artificial intelligence, Computer Engineering

Assessing Heuristic Searches

Given a specific problem you want to create an agent to solve, there can be more than one way of specifying it as a search problem, more than one option for the search strategy and different possibilities for heuristic measures. To a large extent, it is hard to predict what the best option will be, and it will require some experimentation to find out them. In some kind of cases, - if we calculate the effective branching rate, as described below - we may tell for sure if one heuristic measure is always being out-performed by another.

The Effective Branching Rate

Assessing heuristic functions is an essential part of Artificial Intelligence research: a specific heuristic function can sound like a good idea, but in practice give no discernible increase in the quality of the search. Search quality may be determined experimentally  in  terms  of  the  output  from  the  search,  and  by  using  sevral measures likewise  the effective branching rate. Imagine  a specific  problem P has been solved by search strategy S by expanding N nodes, and the solution lay at depth D in the space. Then the effective branching value of S for P is calculated by comparing S to a uniform search U. An example of a uniform search is a breadth first search where many branches from any node are always the same (as in our baby naming example). We then suppose the (uniform) branching rate of U is like  that, on exhausting its search to depth D, it too would have expanded defiantly N nodes. This imagined branching rate, written b*, is the effective branching rate of S and is calculated thus:

N = 1 + b* + (b*)2 + ... + (b*)D.

Rearranging this equation will give a value for b*. For an example (taken from  Norvig and Russell )imagine S finds a solution at depth 5 having expanded 52 nodes. In this type of case:

 52 = 1 + b* + (b*)2 + ... + (b*)5.

and it turns out that b*=1.91. To calculate its value , we use the well known mathematical identity:


This make us enables to write a polynomial for which b* is a 0, and we may solve this using numerical techniques such as Newton's method.

581_Assessing Heuristic Searches.png 
It is typically the case that the effective branching rate of a search strategy is same  over all the problems it is used for, because of this it is suitable to average b* over a small set of problems to give a valid account. If a heuristic search has a branching rate near to 1, then it is a good sign.  We say that 1 heuristic function  h1 dominates another h2 if the search using h1 always has a lower effective branching rate than h2. Having a lower effective branching rate is obviously desirable because it means a quicker search.

Posted Date: 10/2/2012 3:01:37 AM | Location : United States

Related Discussions:- Assessing heuristic searches-artificial intelligence, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Assessing heuristic searches-artificial intelligence, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Assessing heuristic searches-artificial intelligence Discussions

Write discussion on Assessing heuristic searches-artificial intelligence
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Q. Explain Fixed Point Representation? The fixed-point numbers in binary has a sign bit. A positive number has a sign bit 0 whereas negative number has a sign bit 1. In fixed-p

Local minima - sigmoid units: Alternatively in addition to getting over some local minima where the gradient is constant in one direction or adding momentum will increase the

Q. Explain about of Unicode? This is a newer International standard for character representation. Unicode offers a unique code for each character irrespective of Program, platf

Classification according to part of instruction and data: According to the parts of instruction and data, following parts are identified under this classification: Scal

You were offered bonus marks for separating the user interface code from the main logic of your program. This design choice makes it very easy to replace the user interface without

What are the advantages and disadvantages of packet switching over circuit switching? The comparison of packet switching and circuit switching demonstrating advantages and disa

Telex is a (A)  Telephone Service between various subscribers (B)  Tele printer Service between various subscribers (C)  Television Service between various subscri

raster scan display system

Construct a shift register from S-R flip-flops. Explain its working. Ans: S-R Flip-Flop Shift Register: Shift registers can be built through using SR flip-flops. Fig.(a)

Give the solutions for critical section problem? A solution to the critical section problem must specify the subsequent requirements. (a) Mutual exclusion (b) Progress (c)