Analysis of aspects of design for excellence, Electrical Engineering

We commissioned a 'bad practice exemplar' by asking Plexus to modify a good design (provided by Valor) to demonstrate the most likely kinds of faults in each of the areas Design for Fabrication, Design for Assembly and Design for Test. The board is a 'fairly busy' real design, and is representative of a typical board of the 2000 vintage, so it deliberately does not operate at the state-of-the-art boundaries. It has been screened by the CAD system, so there are no gross errors, but the check was done against an minimal set of rules such as those that might be applied by an uninformed user, leaving a number of issues for you to spot.

Your task is to identify and evaluate the problems, and suggest ways in which they might be put right. In doing this you will have to apply the course material to this deliberately incorrect design, using the many sets of guidelines found in it and during your own research. Where necessary, you will need to create a solution that will be the 'least worst' compromise between competing objectives.

You will also have to meet the demands of your partners: preferences vary between different fabricators and assembly shops, which is why every company publishes these, often on their web site. To provide a level playing field for everyone, we have provided sets of model rules for both fabrication and assembly. However, you may well find from your own research that some aspects of these rules are unduly restrictive, and wish to suggest negotiation with (or even changing) your company's suppliers.

Preliminaries

You first need to examine

  • the Gerber files for the Bad practice exemplar
  • our Model rules for fabrication and assembly

Requirement

Compile a report summarising:

  • your explanation of the areas of poor practice
  • your suggestions for improving each of these three elements separately and the design as a whole
  • your recommendations as to how the company should approach the design improvement task
  • the other aspects of "design for excellence" that apply to this product.

You should assume that the members of your audience are designers, who have some knowledge of the basic processes but do not have detailed understanding of the manufacturing requirements.

As a guide, you are unlikely to include all the points we expect to find if your main report has fewer than 1,000 words..

As always, you are strongly recommended to re-examine your draft report and conclusions to check that you have covered all the elements required in the report.

Posted Date: 3/16/2013 2:35:04 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Analysis of aspects of design for excellence, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Analysis of aspects of design for excellence, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Analysis of aspects of design for excellence Discussions

Write discussion on Analysis of aspects of design for excellence
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
(a) Consider a 5-µH inductor to which a current source i(t) is attached, as shown in Figure (b). Sketch the inductor voltage and stored energy as a function of time. (b) Let a v

The free electron theory of metals was first proposed by Drude and later improved by Lorentz. The main postulates of this theory are 1.       All metal contain, adequate number

Q. Explain working of Presentation Layer? This is concerned with format of the data represented, in order to overcome difference in representation of information as supplied to

Q. What is Discrete signals? Discrete signals, on the other hand, exist only at specific instances of time, and as such, their functional description is valid only for discrete

What do these 8086 instructions do? STD-Set  Direction Flag. when the instruction is implemented ,the direction flag of 8086 is set to 1. IRET-Interrupt Return. This instruc

Give the applications of steel. Steel : It contains iron with a small percentage of carbon added to this. Iron itself is not extremely strong but while carbon is added this as

dis advantage of series clippers?

Find the core radius necessary for a single mode operation at 1320nm of a step index fibre with n 1 =1.48 and n 2 =1.478. What are the N.A and maximum acceptance angle for this fib

What are the modes of operations used in 8253? Each of the three counters of 8253 can be operated in one of the following six modes of operation. 1. Mode 0 (Interrupt on ter

Hexadecimal  to Binary Conversion Conversion from  hexadecimal  to binary  is the  reverse  of this  process. Express each  hexadecimal  digit  in four bit  binary  equivalent