What is the scope of the project that janet will be managing

Assignment Help Project Management
Reference no: EM131357678

Review the "Kemko Manufacturing" case study on page 257 of your case study text and respond to the following questions:

What is the scope of the project that Janet will be managing? How would you have handled managing the potential issues around "scope creep"? Would you support Janet's approach-why or why not?

Case Study: Kemko Manufacturing

Background

Kemko Manufacturing was a 50-year-old company that had a reputation for the manufacturing of high quality household appliances. Kemko's growth was rapid during the 1990s. The company grew by acquiring other companies. Kemko now had more than 25 manufacturing plants throughout the United States, Europe, and Asia.

Originally, each manufacturing plant that was acquired wanted to maintain its own culture and quite often was allowed to remain autonomous from corporate at Kemko provided that work was progressing as planned. But as Kemko began acquiring more companies, growing pains made it almost impossible to allow each plant to remain autonomous.

Each company had its own way of handling raw material procurement and inventory control. All purchase requests above a certain dollar value had to be approved by corporate. At corporate, there was often confusion over the information in all of the forms since each plant had its own documentation for procurement. Corporate was afraid of that, unless it established a standardized procurement and inventory control system across the all of the plants, cash flow problems and loss of corporate control over inventory could take its toll in the near future.

Project is Initiated

Because of the importance of the project, senior management asked Janet Adams, director of information technology (IT), to take control of the project personally. Janet had more than 30 years of experience in IT and fully understood how scope creep can create havoc on a large project.

Janet selected her team from IT and set up an initial kickoff date for the project. In addition to the mandatory presence of all of her team members, she also demanded that each manufacturing plants assign at least one representative and that all of the plant representatives must be in attendance as well at the kickoff meeting. At the kickoff meeting, Janet spoke:

I asked all of you here because I want you to have a clear understanding of how I intend to manage this project. Our executives have given us a timetable for this project and my greatest fear is "scope creep." Scope creep is the growth of or enhancements to the projects scope as the project is being developed. On many of our other projects, scope creep has elongated the project and driven up the cost. I know that scope creep isn't always evil, and that it can happen in any lifecycle phase.

The reason I have asked all of the plant representatives to attend this meeting is because of the dangers of scope creep. Scope creep has many causes, but it is generally the failure of effective upfront planning. When scope creep exists, people generally argue that it is a natural occurrence and we must accept the fact that it will happen. That's unacceptable to me!

There will be no scope changes on this project, and I really mean it when I say this. The plant representatives must meet on their own and provide us with the detailed requirements package. I will not allow the project to officially begin until we have a detailed listing of the requirements. My team will provide you with some guidance, as needed, to prepare the requirements.

No scope changes will be allowed once the project begins. I know that there may be some requests for scope changes, but all requests will be bundled together and worked upon later as an enhancement project. This project will be implemented according to the original set of requirements. If I were to allow scope changes to occur, this project would run forever. You know some of you do not like this, but this is the way will be on this project.

There was dead silence in the room. Janet could tell from the expressions on the faces of the plant representatives that they were displeased with her comments. Some of the plants were under the impression that the IT group was supposed to prepare the requirements package. Now, Janet had transferred the responsibility to them, the user group, and they were not happy. Janet made it clear that her involvement would be essential for the preparation of the requirements.

After a few minutes of silence, the plant representatives said that they were willing to do this and it would be done correctly. Many of the representatives understood user requirements documentation. They would work together and come to an agreement on the requirements. Janet again stated that her team would support the plant representatives but that the burden of responsibility would rest solely upon the plants. The plants will get what they ask for and nothing more. Therefore, they must be quite clear up front in the requirements.

While Janet was lecturing to the plant representatives, the IT portion of the team was just sitting back and smiling. The job was about to become easier, or at least they thought so. Janet then addressed the IT portion of the team:

Now I want to address the IT personnel. The reason why we are all in attendance at this meeting is because I want the plant representatives to hear what I have to say to the IT team. In the past, the IT teams have not been without them blame for scope creep and schedule elongation. So, here are my comments for the IT personnel:

- It is the IT team's responsibility to make sure they understand the requirement as prepared by the plant representatives. Do not come back to me later telling me that you did not understand the requirements because they were poorly defined. I am going to ask every IT team member to sign a document stating that they have read over the requirements and fully understand them.
- Perfectionism is not necessary. All I want you to do is get the job done.
- In the past we have been plagued with "featuritis" were many of you have added in your own "bells and whistles" unnecessarily. If that happens on this project, I will personally view this as a failure by you and it will reflect in your next performance review.
- Sometimes, people believe that a project like this will advance their career especially if they look for perfectionism and bells and whistles. Trust me when I tell you this can have a positive effect.
- Backdoor politics will not be allowed. If any of the plant representatives come looking for ways to sneak in scope changes, I want to know about it. And if you make the changes without my permission, you may not be working for me much longer.
- I, and only I, have signature authority for scope changes.
- This project will be executed using detailed planning rather than rolling wave or progress of planning. We should be able to do this once we have clearly defined requirements.
"Now, are there any questions from anyone?:

The battle lines were drawn out. Some believe that it was Janet against the team, but most understood Janet's need to do this. However, whether or not it could work this way was still questionable.

Questions

1. Was Janet correct in the comments you made to the plant representatives?

2. Was Janet correct and the comments she made to the IT team members?

3. Is it always better on IT projects to make changes using enhancement projects or should we allow changes to be made as we go along?

4. What is your best guess on what happened?

Case study from:Kerzner, H. (2013). Project management: Case studies. New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

user requirements documentation

Requirements package

Performance review
backdoor politics

Reference no: EM131357678

Questions Cloud

The owner of the option behaves rationally tomorrow : Joe sold a put option on YYY Corp. with an exercise price of $30. The option expires tomorrow and YYY is currently trading at $26.49 per share. The option premium was $4.38 per share. What is Joe's profit or loss per share if the owner of the option ..
Family socioeconomic status contribute : 1. How might a family's socioeconomic status contribute to teenagers becoming parents? 2. What influence might previous child sexual abuse and/or placement in foster care have on teenagers who become parents?
Construct a decision tree that includes one decision node : Construct a decision tree that includes one decision node or maintain the status quo.- There are the two EHR systems under consideration by Bright Road Health Care System, eMed and Patient Data System (PDS).
Explain factor that will affect demand and prices of product : ECO365- Analyze any comparative advantages and international trade opportunities. Explain the factors that will affect demand, supply, and prices of that product.
What is the scope of the project that janet will be managing : Was Janet correct in the comments you made to the plant representatives - Was Janet correct and the comments she made to the IT team members - Is it always better on IT projects to make changes using enhancement projects or should we allow changes t..
Calculate lissas total dividends : In 2013, the Lissa Company paid dividends of $10,000,000 on after-tax income (cash flow) of $25,000,000. Capital budget projects totaled $15,000,000 in 2013. 2013 was a normal year for earnings, dividends, and capital budgets. Calculate Lissa's total..
Depreciating in the foreign exchange market : Suppose there are two countries in the world, U.S. and Japan. If the Fed wants to fix the exchange rate, the Fed can buy U.S. dollar/sell Japanese yen to prevent dollar from depreciating in the foreign exchange market. Therefore, if the Fed wants ..
How can technology help domestic companies compete : How has global competition affected the domestic manufacturing environment? How can technology help domestic companies compete?
Unwilling to listen to employees suggestions : Why do you think that supervisors are often unwilling to listen to employees' suggestions? Of all the topics discussed in this class, the only one that some students object to is unions.

Reviews

len1357678

1/18/2017 12:43:52 AM

Question :Review the "Kemko Manufacturing" case study What is the scope of the project that Janet will be managing? How would you have handled managing the potential issues around "scope creep"? Would you support Janet's approach-why or why not?

Write a Review

 

Project Management Questions & Answers

  Near which map coordinates should the hub be located

Near which map coordinates should the hub be located?  -  If the shipments from city A triple, how does this change the coordinates.

  Project management schedule budget cost estimationriordan

project management schedule budget cost estimationriordan manufacturing project management plan preparation1 prepare a

  Describe which facilitation techniques you will use

Describe which facilitation techniques you will use to have the project team input to the motivation plan and which team-building activities that you plan to implement. Provide a visual example.

  What types of information can we learn about the project

MGMT 404- What types of information can we learn about the project by reviewing the project schedule and all the information used to generate it?

  Write a profile about how nestl''e companyworks

Write a profile about how Nestl'e companyworks

  Discuss pros of a matrix organization for project management

Discuss the pros and cons of a matrix organization for project management. As a project manager, what types of things would you need to do well in order for your project to work within a matrix organization? Justify your responses.

  Positive or negative culture-related experience

Briefly share with your classmates your most positive or negative culture-related experience in a project situation.

  Show that digital vsb is indeed equivalent in performance

A digital VSB transmission system may be viewed as a time-varying onedimensional system operating at a rate of 2/T dimensions per second, where T is the symbol period. Justify the validity of this statement.

  Software and hardware that protect computer and home network

Go to the Web and find out about software and hardware that protect your computer and home network, respectively.- How many different hardware firewalls can you find on the Web site of your favorite electronics retailer?

  Generate box plots of mortality and water hardness

Generate box plots of mortality and water hardness by location (use proc boxplot).- Use proc univariate to compare the distribution of water hardness with the log normal and exponential distributions.

  What is an unsought product

What is an unsought product? How do marketers make such products attractive to consumers?- What types of products are bought and sold in businessto-business markets?

  New software corresponds with the company

When convincing his team to adopt a new software, Gauge describes how adopting the new software corresponds with the company's mission to deliver products as efficiently as possible. Gauge is using which of the following influence tactics?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd