Monetary performance and the financial position, Cost Accounting

Assignment Help:

 

The question required consideration of both the monetary performance and the financial position, from the perception of a potential lender. As with previous questions, candidates were required to identify ratios that would be related to the scenario, correctly calculate them and then form an opinion of the entity's position from a precise perspective.

Recommended Approach

The question was typical of what candidates have seen in preceding diets - reviewing monetary performance and position but within the bounds of a specific situation - in this case a lending application. The candidates should have considered which ratios would have been of interest to an impending lender and focussed on them - ensuring they had adequate coverage for financial performance and position. Staying focussed on the situation was essential - no requirement for further information, or commendation of improvements.

(a) Report to lending department

Re QW - application for $50 million

 Review of financial performance and position of QW

 Date - 1 March 2013

The annual report highlights a 44% increase in revenue as a result of the entity's expansion, which is indeed the case; however this has been accomplish at the expenditure of profitability. The unpleasant margin has fallen from 29.8% to 27.6%, a drop in the margin of 2.2% in the year, suggesting lower selling prices have been used to be a focus for new customers.

At first glance it appears that on the whole profitability has recovered slightly from the drop in the gross margin, as the profit for the year margin has fallen from 7.5% to 5.9% (a drop in margin of 1.6%). though much of the profit for the year is attributable to the share of profits from the correlate. Excluding the associate's revenue results in the profit for the year margin falling to 4.1%, in general drop of 5.4% in the margin, which is worrying. This significant drop in profit is due mainly to an increase in distribution expenses, which have increased 77% in the period. It looks like the increase has been geographical with either goods been shipped further or new distribution centres being set up. Inventories at the year-end have increased considerably, suggesting it is more likely to be the latter. The additional economics costs have also contributed to inferior profit, with interest on both new long-term borrowings and the introduction of an overdraft in the period.

The revenue on capital employed (excluding the associate) has also fallen, although this could be partially affected by the revaluation in the year. There is no doubt, however that the comments from the CEO are overly positive, as the extension has had a negative impact on the financial performance of the operating business of QW. In addition, receivables have improved, likely to be the extension of credit offered to attract new custom. This is suitable when an entity has the working capital to allow it, but this is not the case for QW.

The gearing has increased considerably from 41.7% to 68.0% resulting from the improved loans and short-term borrowings. This is in spite of a revaluation in the year and gains recorded through reserves which has boosted equity in the period. QW has used up its cash resource and moved to overdraft which is common throughout periods of expansion, however to invest $22 million ($27 million - $5 million of profit during the year) in another entity during this period shown to be rather a naive move by the management, as it is clear the cash is needed for an increasing working capital necessity. A closer relationship with AB may make safe distribution channels or more competitive material costs, which could improve future profitability, although there is no evidence of this so far.

The interest cover would be a apprehension if the loan was granted, as the majority of the cover is produces by the associate, an entity for which we have no monetary details. This creates an additional risk. It is surprising that the entity has not taken the opportunity to produces cash by selling its investments, which are clearly performing well and would therefore be sold relatively easily.

The CEO also stated on future profitability being produces by the investment in non-current assets that take place in the year. However the PPE balance has not increased considerably and much of the movement could be due to the revaluation in the year. The other investments, the associate and AFS investment, could generate gains but not income and activity. The comments by the CEO are not necessarily a balanced show of the performance and position in the year and therefore a level of professional uncertainty is required. The results of this examined questions whether QW is under competent and careful stewardship and as a result the recommendation would be not to proceed with the application.

(b) (i) QW has altered its accounting policy in the year in respect of PPE. The move to revaluation impacts on both monetary position (in terms of gearing) and monetary performance (in terms of ROCE, depreciation and profitability). This results in the two years of monetary information not being directly comparable. In addition, the entity has changed its structure with the introduction of an associate. This influence the comparison of the profitability ratios and asset turnover ratios - as this is a non-current asset that does not generate income.

(ii) The narrative elements are not particularly audited although they should be reliable with what is reported in the monetary statements. The problem is the focus of the comments - QW revenue is up 44% - what is implicit, is that performance and profitability have been adversely affected. The statements can be exactly correct but not necessarily balanced which is naturally designed to draw the readers' attention away from negative features and therefore cannot necessarily be relied ahead.

Appendix 2012

2011

(Workings in $000)

Gross profit

GP/revenue x 100%

80/290 x 100 = 27.6%

60/201 x 100 = 29.8%

Operating profit

Operating profit/revenue x 100%

32 (ie: 80-16-32)/290 x 100 = 11.0%

28 (ie: 60-14-18)/201 x 100 = 13.9%

Profit for year

PFY/revenue x 100%

17/290 x 100 = 5.9%

15/201 x 100 = 7.5%

PFY without associate

(17 - 5)/290 x 100 = 4.1%

Return on capital employed

Profit before finance costs/capital employed x 100% (all exc assoc)

(32/ (122 +70 + 13 -27) x 100 = 18.0%

28/(96 + 40) x 100 = 20.6%

Gearing

Debt/equity

70+13/122 x 100 = 68.0%

40/96 x 100 = 41.7%

Gearing

Debt/debt + equity

83/(83 + 122) x 100 = 40.5%

40/(40 + 96) x 100 = 29.4%

Interest cover

Profit before finance costs and associate/finance costs

(24 + 13 -5)/13 = 2.5 times

(21 + 7)/7 = 4.0 times

Receivables days

Receivables/revenue x 365 days

49/290 x 365 days =

62 days

27/201 x 365 days =

49 days

Inventories days

Inventories/cost of sales x 365

29/210 x 365 days=

50 days

13/141 x 365 days =

34 days

Payables days

Payables/cost of sales x 365

20/210 x 365 days=

35 days

15/141 x 365 days=

39 days

Quick ratio

78 - 29/33 = 1.5

45 - 13/15 = 2.1






Related Discussions:- Monetary performance and the financial position

Cost book-keeping, Cost Book-Keeping In cost account accounts, extensi...

Cost Book-Keeping In cost account accounts, extensive employ is made of control accounts that are based in the similar principles as those utilized in financial accounts.  Two

#investment appraisal techniques, #what is the formula for calculating payb...

#what is the formula for calculating payback period and what are its limitations ?

Occurrence of overhead variances, Occurrence of Overhead Variances Ove...

Occurrence of Overhead Variances Overhead variances arise mainly because of the conventions of the overheads absorption process. The overhead absorption rates employed in this

Product costing methods, What are the strengths and weaknesses of the vario...

What are the strengths and weaknesses of the various costing methods and which would you recommend for a manufacturing enterpris? 2000word assay plus appendix

Piece wage rate, what is Taylor''s differential piece rate plan

what is Taylor''s differential piece rate plan

Materials mix variance, M aterials mix variance :  It can be described a...

M aterials mix variance :  It can be described as that portion of direct material usage variance which is the variation between the actual quantities of ingredients used in a mi

Compute the cost of good sold and the ending inventory value, Beginning inv...

Beginning inventory on March 1 consisted of 2,000 units each costing $11.20. During March, the following was purchased for inventory: Date Purchase

Fixed overheads variance, Fixed Overheads Variance This is defined lik...

Fixed Overheads Variance This is defined like the difference between the fixed overheads attributed and the standard cost of fixed overheads absorbed in the production achieve

Manufacturing concern to organization, Manufacturing Concern to Organizatio...

Manufacturing Concern to Organization There are three manufacturing centres as Making, Packing and Finishing.  These are supported through five support departments, namely Mai

Weighted average method, Weighted Average Method This way is a perpet...

Weighted Average Method This way is a perpetual weighted average system whereas the issue price is recalculated after one of receipt of stocks taking into accounts both money

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd