Judicial control - subsidiary legislation, Business Law and Ethics

Assignment Help:

Judicial Control:

Conversely the courts can declare any law made as subsidiary legislation to be invalid or unacceptable under the ultra vires doctrine. Thus the law may be declared either procedurally or substantively ultra vires.

(a)   Substantive Ultra Vires

However a law may be declared substantively ultra vires whether as the maker had no powers to make it.  So now this may occur in a number of ways.  As like a case, the Minister or Authority may have:as;

(i) exceeded the powers given through the Act;

(ii) exercised the power for another purpose rather than the particular rationale  to that it was given, or

(i) Is acted unreasonably there in the sense explained through Greene, M.R. in Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation

(b)   Procedural Ultra Vires

Further a law will be declared procedurally ultra vires  where the mandatory procedures prescribed in the enabling Act to its enactment are not tracks same like failure to publish it in the Gazette.  So now look at a case of Mwangi V.R. in that Mwangi and another person were prosecuted and convicted with the Special Magistrate's Court, to charging one shilling instead of fifty cents to a haircut, Nairobi, contrary to Price Controller's Order No.20 of 1948 that should be made pursuant to Regulation 11(1) of the Defence as Control of Prices Regulations, 1945.

Now therefore further on appeal the convictions were set aside when the court's attention was drawn to the fact that the Order had not been published in the Gazette as should have been done.  Since the order was now void and nobody could be charged for allegedly violating its provisions.


Related Discussions:- Judicial control - subsidiary legislation

State article 3 of air and outer space law, State Article 3 of air and oute...

State Article 3 of air and outer space law Article 3 refers to the fact that the Convention would be applicable to the civil aircraft only and not to the state aircraft. Also,

Article 1 - state responsibility, Article 1 - State Responsibility The ...

Article 1 - State Responsibility The laws on state responsibility are derived from state practices and various other customs and practices. However the main text on the law of

Right to sell - terms used in contract, Right to sell - Terms used in Contr...

Right to sell - Terms used in Contract With S.14 (a) provides that there is an implied condition such seller has a right for sell the goods and, like in the case of an agreeme

Legislative options for addressing phoenix activity, Q. Legislative options...

Q. Legislative options for addressing phoenix activity? There are a range of legislative options for addressing phoenix activity and the following legislative options were expl

Advantages of stare decisis - flexibility, Advantages of Stare Decisis - ...

Advantages of Stare Decisis - Flexibility Since of the freedom that final Court of Appeal always has to depart from a previous decision of its own whether the social condi

Condition for liquidation - winding up, Condition for liquidation: The...

Condition for liquidation: The liquidation itself may render a charge over the company's assets void in any of the following circumstances: (a)     the charge was not reg

Negligence - statutory provisions, NEGLIGENCE: It is still uncertain w...

NEGLIGENCE: It is still uncertain whether damage caused by negligence can be brought under the heading of "fraud" for the purpose of the exception of "fraud on the minority."

Advantages of alternative dispute resolution, Question 1: (a) Elaborat...

Question 1: (a) Elaborate on the sources of Law in Mauritius. (b) Explain what you understand by the following legal terms: (i) Obiter Dictum

Unsecured trade creditors, Unsecured trade creditors: It refers to a "...

Unsecured trade creditors: It refers to a "class" of members or of creditors. Obviously if two or more companies are involved or if one company has two classes of shares, eg.

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd