Flaws in conventional system - inconsistent treatment, Public Economics

Assignment Help:

Flaws in Conventional System -  Inconsistent Treatment

There is inconsistent treatment of man-made and natural assets. As mentioned earlier, while computing sustainable income measures like net national product or net domestic product, the man-made machinery is depreciated so as to allow for replacement of losses in the capital stock. Man-made assets such as buildings and equipment are valued as productive capital, and are written off against the value of production as they depreciate. The inherent assumption behind this is that a consumption level maintained by drawing down the stock of capital exceeds the sustainable level of income. However, natural resource assets are not so valued and the losses in the natural resources are not similarly depreciated. Their loss entails no debit charge against current income that would account for the decrease in potential future production. For example, when forests are transferred for non-forest purposes, the national accounts record only the expenditure incurred in clearing the forests, and do not account for the loss to society as a result of this transfer. Moreover, the reduction in the forest area is shown in other volume changes, which do not have any effect on GDP.

Another misunderstanding underlies the contention that natural resources are "free gifts of nature," so that there are no investment costs to be "written off." The value of an asset is not its investment cost, but the present value of its income potential. Common formulas for calculating depreciation (e.g., straight line depreciation) by 'writing off investment costs are just convenient rules of thumb. The true measure of depreciation, which statisticians have tried to adopt for fixed capital in the national accounts, is the capitalized value of the decline in the future income stream because of an asset's decay or obsolescence. Thus, in the same sense that a machine depreciates, soils depreciate as their fertility is diminished.

A country could exhaust its mineral resources, cut down its forests, erode its soils, pollute its aquifers, and hunt its wildlife and fisheries to extinction, but measured income would not be affected as these assets disappeared. Ironically, low-income countries, which are m9ly most dependent on natural resources for employment, revenues, and foreign exchange earnings, use a system for national accounting and macroeconomic analysis that almost completely ignores their principal assets (i.e., natural assets). Underlying this anomaly is the implicit and inappropriate assumption that natural resources are so abundant that they have no marginal value. This is a misconception. Whether they enter the marketplace directly or not, natural resources make important contributions to long-term economic productivity and so are, strictly speaking, economic assets. Many are under increasing pressure from human activities and are deteriorating in quantity or quality.


Related Discussions:- Flaws in conventional system - inconsistent treatment

Introduction of performance-related pay, Question: Awards for excellent...

Question: Awards for excellent performance are increasingly employed within the public service in many countries. These will or will not have a financial value. Performance-rel

Provide individuals with various ways of controlling , Basic floor plan: T...

Basic floor plan: There are no security guards on duty at any given time. There are three ATM's on site but none of them can see who comes and goes through the building. Cameras a

What problems are faced by developing economies, Question: Describe the...

Question: Describe the main measures of size and/or cutoff point below which economies are classed as small? In 1982 the Development Committee of the World Bank and the Int

Welfare and subsidies, what are the costs and consequences of providing the...

what are the costs and consequences of providing the subsidies and welfare?

Requisite modifications to national income accounts, Requisite Modification...

Requisite Modifications to National Income Accounts Normal 0 false false false EN-IN X-NONE X-NONE MicrosoftInternetE

National boundaries as institutions in policy processes, The essence of a n...

The essence of a national boundary is separate the ‘self' from the ‘other'. Thus natural boundaries, like all institutions have their own set of internal rules which govern their

Affirmative action and anticorruption programme, A change in the legal stat...

A change in the legal statute may be able to force an equilibrium if it leads to a new equilibrium which implies some revised belief which sustains the equilibrium. Tirole (1996)

Long run demand and factor substitutability, Suppose there are two inputs i...

Suppose there are two inputs in the production function, labor (L) and capital (K), which can be combined to produce Y units of output according to the following production functio

Perfect Complements, An economy has two agents and two goods. Utilities are...

An economy has two agents and two goods. Utilities are given by UA=min{xA,0.5yA} and UB=min{xB,0.5yB}. The total amount of X in the economy is 10. The total amount of Y is also 10.

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd