Calculate benefit cost ratio of most cost effective device, Civil Engineering

Assignment Help:

A city is trying to decide which of two traffic devices to install. Device A costs $1000 and has useful life of five years.  Device A can be expected to result in $300 savings annually. Device B costs $2000 and has useful life of eight years.  Device B can be expected to result in $400 savings annually.Both devices have no salvage value at the end of their lives.With interest at 7%, the benefit cost ratio of the most cost effective device is most nearly:

Solution:  

Device A:

  PW of cost   = $1000

  PW of benefits = $300 (P/A, 7%, 5) = $1230    

B/C =   1230/1000   = 1.23

Device B:

  PW of cost   = $2000

  PW of benefits = $400 (P/A, 7%, 8) = $2388    

B/C =   2388/2000   = 1.19

In order to maximize the benefit-cost ratio, select Device A; 1.23


Related Discussions:- Calculate benefit cost ratio of most cost effective device

Determine the grade rod reading at station, A section view of a proposed ro...

A section view of a proposed roadway is shown in Figure 1 with an existing grade point elevation of 100-ft. The proposed roadbed finish grade elevation at station 50+00 is 95.00-ft

Mechanism of formation of soil plugs, Question What is main mechanism o...

Question What is main mechanism of formation of soil plugs in marine driven steel piles with reinforced concrete infill? Answer Throughout initial driving process, ope

Determine the principle of darcy law, Determine the principle of Darcy's la...

Determine the principle of Darcy's law for laminar flow of water through saturated soil. Illustrate that the coefficient of permeability has the dimension of velocity. The d

Calculate the horizontal distance, Calculate the Horizontal Distance A ...

Calculate the Horizontal Distance A surveyor's total station measured slope distance near station 3245+26.35 is recorded as 437.380-m with a zenith angle of 118º 48' 07" and a

Sieve analysis, size of sieve to analysis the grading of 10 mm size stone g...

size of sieve to analysis the grading of 10 mm size stone grit

Arches, what is arches ? what are the classification of arches

what is arches ? what are the classification of arches

Compute interior or intersection angle, Compute Interior or Intersection An...

Compute Interior or Intersection Angle for the following circular curve:   Answer- I = 180° - 60° - 60°= 60

Classification of timber based on grading, Classification Based on Grading:...

Classification Based on Grading: IS 883-1970 classifies the structural timber into 3 grades-select grade, grade I and grade II. The classification is depend on, defects, permi

Digit of cells for concrete box girder bridges, Question How does an engine...

Question How does an engineer determine digit of cells for concrete box girder bridges ? Answer If depth of a box girder bridge exceeds 1/6 or 1/5 of bridge width, then it is o

Analyse the state of stress at the critical section, Analyse the state of s...

Analyse the state of stress at the critical section: A prismatic bar of circular section with 80 mm diameter is subjected to bending moment of 5 kN-m and a torque of 7 kN-m. A

Write Your Message!

Captcha
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd