What would the major ethical perspectives say

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM13785690

Question 1: "In the book's final quote, why do you believe he says it takes "strength and grace" to make choices in life, rather than simply making ethical decisions?"

Question 2: "Minority Report Steven Spielberg, Director (2002)

Minority Report is set in the year 2054, and John Anderton (Tom Cruise) is chief of the Department of Pre-Crime in Washington, D.C. There has not been a murder there in 6 years, because of an operation Anderton supervises where three pre-cognitive humans ("pre-cogs") drift in a flotation tank and have their brain waves tapped by computers. These brain waves can pick up thoughts of premeditated murders, so the police can be warned and arrest the would-be perpetrators before they can kill (hence the "Department of Pre-Crime"). Of course, it is not as easy as this, because the pre-cogs can provide only the time and date of the murder, the murderer's name, and the victim's name-the other facts can be learned only by clues derived from the various images generated by the pre-cogs around the time of murder. The film is based on a short story by Philip K. Dick.

The pre-crime police strategy is going to expand nationwide, and there is personal and bureaucratic jealousy toward Anderton and the pre-crime unit. The movie focuses on a rare disagreement among the "pre-cogs" over a pending murder, and one of the pre- cogs apparently files a minority report disagreeing with the others. Normally, the minority report is disregarded, but the twist is that Anderton himself becomes a target for arrest as a predicted killer, and he is apparently warned of this by one of the pre- cogs. Anderton then is chased by police, assisted by one of the pre-cogs named Agatha (Samatha Morton), and the futuristic police pursuit and search is interesting and compelling. For example, everyone is subject to retina scans, so Anderton has to get an eye transplant to hide his identity while being pursued. The story has several twists, and it raises important issues about the certainty of knowledge and how knowledge should be used.

QUESTIONS

1. If we were able to predict premeditated murders in the future by somehow scanning the minds of citizens, is this enough evidence to apprehend and take legal action against them? What would the major ethical perspectives say?

2. The accurate prediction of criminal behavior is not yet possible, but profiles are sometimes used by police for targeting suspects. Under what circumstances is the use of a profile to take police action morally permissible?

Reference no: EM13785690

Questions Cloud

Distinctive physiological pattern : Women are expected to be kind and attentive to other people's feelings. In North America, when a woman in the workplace doesn't smile when others expect her to, she is likely to:

Cyber law and internet law : The director of your department has requested that you conduct some research on the topic of cyber law or Internet law. He has asked you to draft a memo including the following information: Research, identify, and discuss at least 2 emerging trends o..

Is there a way for northwest brands to avoid : Ordinarily, corporate income is taxed at the corporate and shareholder levels. Is there a way for Northwest Brands to avoid this double-income taxation? Explain your answer

The migrant and seasonal agricultural worker protection act : Which of the following is true regarding compensatory comp time - generally compensable time under the FLSA?

What would the major ethical perspectives say : If we were able to predict premeditated murders in the future by somehow scanning the minds of citizens, is this enough evidence to apprehend and take legal action against them? What would the major ethical perspectives say

The risk management tools : Discuss the relationship between risk and this type of insurance.

Assignment on the mozart effect : The Mozart Effect.

What ethical issues are raised in this case if any : Using the internet, research a contract issue. This can be a breach of contract case or some other contract dispute. Use some of the terminology from the textbook to help you search. Briefly describe the case and the legal issue. What ethical issu..

Benefits of insurance to society issues : In addition to marketing life insurance, life insurers typically sell which of the following products?

User Account

All Pages