What would the major ethical perspectives say

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM13783453

"Minority Report Steven Spielberg, Director (2002)

Minority Report is set in the year 2054, and John Anderton (Tom Cruise) is chief of the Department of Pre-Crime in Washington, D.C. There has not been a murder there in 6 years, because of an operation Anderton supervises where three pre-cognitive humans ("pre-cogs") drift in a flotation tank and have their brain waves tapped by computers. These brain waves can pick up thoughts of premeditated murders, so the police can be warned and arrest the would-be perpetrators before they can kill (hence the "Department of Pre-Crime"). Of course, it is not as easy as this, because the pre-cogs can provide only the time and date of the murder, the murderer's name, and the victim's name-the other facts can be learned only by clues derived from the various images generated by the pre-cogs around the time of murder. The film is based on a short story by Philip K. Dick.

The pre-crime police strategy is going to expand nationwide, and there is personal and bureaucratic jealousy toward Anderton and the pre-crime unit. The movie focuses on a rare disagreement among the "pre-cogs" over a pending murder, and one of the pre- cogs apparently files a minority report disagreeing with the others. Normally, the minority report is disregarded, but the twist is that Anderton himself becomes a target for arrest as a predicted killer, and he is apparently warned of this by one of the pre- cogs. Anderton then is chased by police, assisted by one of the pre-cogs named Agatha (Samatha Morton), and the futuristic police pursuit and search is interesting and compelling. For example, everyone is subject to retina scans, so Anderton has to get an eye transplant to hide his identity while being pursued. The story has several twists, and it raises important issues about the certainty of knowledge and how knowledge should be used.

QUESTIONS

1. If we were able to predict premeditated murders in the future by somehow scanning the minds of citizens, is this enough evidence to apprehend and take legal action against them? What would the major ethical perspectives say?

2. The accurate prediction of criminal behavior is not yet possible, but profiles are sometimes used by police for targeting suspects. Under what circumstances is the use of a profile to take police action morally permissible?

Reference no: EM13783453

Questions Cloud

Calculate required output by a single excavator : Calculate required output by a single excavator appropriate to this production and select an appropriate machine - calculate cycle times for trucks.
The impact of workplace bullying : Provide a review of the article. Describe the impact of workplace bullying on both the victims and the organization.
Ascribed social class position : Explain how an individual's ascribed social class position at birth may affect what Max Weber called life chances, or the ability of an individual to attain the following "good things" that a society values:
Strengths and weaknesses of each piece : Is there another possible explanation you can think of? Based on what you have read, what is your hypothesis? In other words, what is your explanation for the findings?
What would the major ethical perspectives say : If we were able to predict premeditated murders in the future by somehow scanning the minds of citizens, is this enough evidence to apprehend and take legal action against them? What would the major ethical perspectives say
New capability change the list of stakeholders the team : Discuss the implications that such a change would have on the scope of the project. How might this new capability change the list of stakeholders the team would involve when collecting information and defining the requirements? Would the change have ..
Managing a product-harm crisis product recalls have become i : Managing a Product-Harm Crisis Product-recalls have become increasingly commonplace in American media reports. Everything from food products to toys and cars have been recalled with increasing frequency in recent years. Some researchers predict the n..
Role of the us court system in influencing society : Discuss the general role of the U.S. Court System in influencing society. Give your opinion on whether or not you believe that mass media influences court decisions. Provide a rationale for your response
Interpersonal communications in today''s global businesses : Analyze various approaches for engaging an audience during a presentation and encouraging active listening.

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  How corporations and individuals in positions of power

Using the Internet and library, provide at least 2 examples of how corporations and individuals in positions of power and authority have acted unethically either by their actions or inactions

  Identify the four goals of criminal law

Identify the four goals of criminal law, and discuss the manner in which these four goals effectuable the purpose of protecting the public and preventing the conviction of innocent persons

  Discuss how deterrence relates to humiliation this is a

discuss how deterrence relates to humiliation. this is a form of deterrence gaining popularity among law makers. ohio

  Which group had the best arguments support your argument

federalism is the structure where two or more levels of government operate alongside each other with some autonomy

  The american ship building company

32.8 Ethics The American Ship Building Company (American) operated a shipyard in Chicago, Illinois, where it repaired Great Lakes ships during the winter months, when freezing on the Great Lakes rendered shipping impossible. The workers at the shipya..

  Studies on death penalty costs

Assignment: First, read the following study summaries and watch the following short video. Studies on Death Penalty Costs and Cost of Death Penalty

  Do you think mcdonald''s breached its implied warranty

The questions to be discussed this week are as follows:  Do you think McDonald's breached it's implied warranty when it sold Ms Liebeck her coffee

  Some trees were cut down and made into lumber and the

1 what federal statute governs the legal use of electronic contracts? federal enforcement act federal banking act

  Justification for excluding independent contractors

Legally, it makes a great deal of difference whether someone performing work is an employee or an independent contractor. But should it make a difference? What is the justification for excluding independent contractors from protection of antidisc..

  How the legal concepts in the selected case can be applied

Write an explanation for each brief of no more than 300 words. about how the legal concepts in the selected case can be applied within a business managerial setting

  What services goods or activities does organization provide

What services, goods, or activities does the organization provide? Explain. Specifically, in terms of organizational structure, how are the two organizations different? Explain in detail. Specifically, in terms of organizational structure, how are th..

  Open a competing company against the original company?

10 new shareholders purchase their shares when the company was in a financial difficulty. What kind of equitable remedies could be used by those 2 new shareholders? If one of these 2 new shareholders has started a competing company, is that ok? Is a ..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd