Reference no: EM133195110
Question 1: What are Chick-Fil-A's central issues?
Question 2: What recommendations do you have for Dan Cathy? Consider Cathy's options and the benefits and potential issues with each option.
In class Discussion
Chick-Fil-A case
The Chicken Has Issues
Question 1. Are Chick-Fil-A's "Christian values" becoming a potential problem for the company? Why or why not?
a. What are some issues that Chick-Fil-A is facing?
b. What are customers critiquing them about?
Question 2. What is the central issue in this case?
What Should Chick-Fil-A Do?
Question 3. Maintain status quo: Continue to demonstrate Chick-Fil-A's strong, Christian values despite the negative publicity.
a. What are the benefits of maintaining the status quo?
b. Why would maintaining the status quo be detrimental?
Question 4. Change to reflect current trends: Adopt values that are more neutral to attempt to appeal to a wider population (this means giving up the values that it has been following for decades).
a. What are the benefits of adopting a neutral/new values stance?
b. What are the drawbacks of taking on a more neutral stance?
Question 5. Adopt a balanced solution: Continue to follow conservative values but be less public about it. Find ways to demonstrate your faith that are not as public or separate the Cathy's religiosity from the business.
a. What are the benefits of adopting a balanced solution?
b. What are the issues with adopting a balanced solution
Question 6. What companies have remained true to their values, but attracted a wider audience? What have these companies done to espouse their values and still retain a wider audience?
Question 7. How should Chick-Fil-A implement a balanced solution?
Question 8. What would you do if you were Dan Cathy when presented with these different potential strategic options and why?
Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission
Question 9. Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act prevents discrimination by business entities on the basis of sexual orientation. 1st Amendment Freedom of Religion-free exercise clause-prevents the government from interfering in individuals' freely practicing their faith. 1st Amendment protects all forms of speech or expression-including artistic expression. Baking a cake may be considered a form of artistic expression/speech. Government cannot compel any form of speech. Charles Craig and David Mullens requested a cake from Masterpiece Cakeshop for their wedding. Baker Jack Phillips refused to make the wedding cake because making a cake for a same-sex couple's wedding violated his religious belief. Phillips was found to be in violation of the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act for refusing to bake a cake for Craig and Mullens. Phillips appealed the decision to the U.S Supreme Court alleging that the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act violates his First Amendment Right to Freedom of Religion and Free Speech
a. Can the government compel Phillips to bake a cake for Craig and Mullens or does this violate his 1st amendment right to free speech?
b. Does a business owner have the right to refuse service to a same-sex couple because of his religious beliefs?
c. What are the broader implications if the court rules that in fact Phillips does have a right to refuse service to gay couples because of his religious beliefs?