What does robert mcnamara see as the major mistakes

Assignment Help History
Reference no: EM13743685

*In Robert McNamara's memoir In Retrospect, he acknowledges that the Johnson Administration, in which he was a leading actor, made several serious mistakes in its handling of the Vietnam War. What does he see as the major mistakes? And how does he explain them?

*In the Appendix of the paperback edition McNamara has included many articles both pro and con, which address the content of his book. Pick two and briefly summarize them, including your initial reaction to these commentaries.

*Drawing upon any three of the following documents, indicate whether you think they support or undermine McNamara's analysis:

McGeorge Bundy Recommends Sustained Reprisals, February 7, 1965.

Robert McNamara Recommends Escalation, 1965

George Ball Dissents, 1965

Johnson Recalls His decision to Commit Troops in 1965

Meeting on Westmoreland's Request for Additional Troops, June 1965

*Drawing upon any three of the following transcripts, indicate whether you think they support or undermine McNamara's presentation:

Johnson/Dirksen, February 17, 1965

Johnson/Bundy February 18, 1965

Johnson/Russell, March 6, 1965.

Johnson/ NcNamara, April 20, 1965

Johnson/Mansfield, June 8, 1965

Johnson/ McNamara, June 10, 1965

Johnson/Eisenhower, July 2, 1965.

*Drawing upon Caputo's Rumor of War and the Introduction, plus Chapter 1 in Bilton and Sim's book on My Lai, briefly discuss some of the disturbing features of the Vietnam War on the ground. From what you have read of McNamara's memoir, do you think that he and/or his colleagues were aware of these things? And if not, do you see this as a problem?

*Historian Fred Logevoll has written one of the most important available books on the subject of the Johnson Administration's escalation of the war in 1964-65. He undoubtedly wrote it -as a partial rebuttal to McNamara. His concluding chapter, "Choosing War" will be distributed. Try to summarize what Logevoll is saying. And indicate whether you find his point of view more persuasive than McNamara's. If you find neither explanation convincing, explain why.

Reference no: EM13743685

Questions Cloud

Why is the money multiplier in the united states : Why is the money multiplier in the United States smaller than the inverse of the required reserve ratio and explain why depositing cash into a checking account does not change the money supply.
Testing the car loan calculator : When we think about testing the Car Loan Calculator, should there be a test for each requirement? If so, what test types would you use?
Global management and organizational systems : Indicate three (3) organizational changes that the global market impacts overall, such as technology, virtual teams, outsourcing, strategy development, trading laws, regulations, etc.
Leading and managing communication : From the e-Activity, choose two (2) of your favorite leaders, and discuss whether you believe each of the chosen people were born or made leaders. Justify your response.
What does robert mcnamara see as the major mistakes : In Robert McNamara's memoir In Retrospect, he acknowledges that the Johnson Administration, made several serious mistakes in its handling of the Vietnam War. What does he see as the major mistakes?
Cell organelles : Cell Organelles Worksheet- Complete the following table by writing the name of the cell part or organelle in the right hand column that matches the structure/function in the left hand column.
Financing-valuation and rating agencies : Suppose you were given an opportunity to own a business of your choosing. First, briefly describe your business; then explain the most efficient way to raise capital to either start or expand your business. Provide support for your response.
Mechanism of futures markets : A company enters into a long futures contract to buy 1,000 units of a commodity for $60 per unit. The initial margin is $6,000 and the maintenance margin is $4,000. What futures price will allow $2,000 to be withdrawn from the margin account?
Dysfunctional aspects of the organization''s culture : Examine the most functional and dysfunctional aspects of the organization's culture. Describe the methods used to socialize new employees or members into the organizational culture.

Reviews

Write a Review

History Questions & Answers

  Create a strong thesis for your essay

Create a strong thesis for your essay. A thesis states your main idea in a sentence. A sample thesis might be: The concepts of the mestiza consciousness, borderlands, and cross-culture challenges influence the writings of Latino writers.

  Is ronald reagan overrated or underrated as a president

Is Reagan overrated or underrated as a president? Choose three topics from the list below to make your case whether Reagan is overrated or underrated.

  There were many empires that rose and fell between 2300 bc

there were many empires that rose and fell between 2300 b.c. and 334 b.c. write a brief essay that compares and

  Explain the pacification approaches employed by cords and

explain the pacification approaches employed by cords and evaluate their successes and failures. what other approaches

  Write an essay on the globalising the australian economy

Please write an essay on the following 4 related topics are: Australia: Culture, history and politics, Globalising the Australian economy, The Australian envirnoment and Health, education and social inequality in Australia.

  This course has covered american history from the

this course has covered american history from the presidency of andrew johnson to george w. bush. in this period 26 men

  Explain this outburst of witchcraft hysteria

Witchcraft hysteria seemed to have peaked during the 16th and 17th centuries coinciding with the Reformation and Counter-Reformation. What might explain this outburst of Witchcraft Hysteria?

  How is the judicial branch composed in each plan

How is the judicial branch composed in each plan? Discuss the following issues: The supreme court composed and chosen how; The design and selection of any additional courts.

  Compare and contrast the religious ideas of buddhism

Compare and contrast the religious ideas of Buddhism that led to monasteries in Asia with the monastic ideal of Christianity in the Middle Ages.

  Write an essay on girl with red hat

Write an essay on Girl with Red Hat. I need a well written response. No plagiarized work. Can you work in the time frame needed?

  Social and political structures and europe and review

the german chancellor otto von bismarck in the latter part of the 1800s likened the worlds new era of political and

  Write an essay on abbasids and charlemagne

Identification terms (long answer) the following terms: Abbasids, Charlemagne, Constantine, Constitution of Medina, Dar al-Islam and Gregory the Great.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd