What are the drawbacks from using payback as a method

Assignment Help Finance Basics
Reference no: EM131184162

1. The cash flows from two capital expenditure projects follow. The discount rate is 10%. Project A Initial cost: $(10,000) Project B Initial cost: $(10,000);

Year 1- Project A: 6,000 Project B: 2,000;

Year 2- Project A: 5,000 Project B: 4,000;

Year 3- Project A: 1,000 Project B: 8,000;

Year 4-Project A: 0 Project B: 6,000;

a) What are the payback periods for both projects?

b) What is the NPV for both projects?

c) What are the drawbacks from using payback as a method for selecting projects?

2. Community Drycleaning would like to purchase a new machine for cleaning large quilts and comforters. The current cleaning operation on quilts and comforters is done by hand. The new machine would cost $12,500. The estimated service life is 12 years, at which time it is estimated that the machine could be sold for $500.

The company estimates that it would cost $700 per year to operate the machine. The current cost of manual cleaning is $3,000 per year. In addition to reducing costs, the new machine would increase the drycleaner's ability to clean quilts and comforters by 600 per year. The company realizes a net contribution margin after tax effects of $1.50 per quilt or comforter. A 10% rate of return is required on all investments. Community expects its tax rate to be 30%.

A. What are the annual net cash inflows that would be realized from the new machine?

B. Compute the net present value of the investment (round to the nearest dollar). Use straight-line depreciation based on the machine's estimated service life. Would you recommend that the machine be purchased? Explain your answer.

3. Smith Electronics manufactures portable CD players. Lillian Perez, the VP of operations at Smith Electronics, is considering a major capital investment decision. It would cost $2,500,000 to put new, highly automated machines in the factory. The equipment would last about 15 years and would have no salvage value at the end of that period. The equipment will replace 10 workers, saving Smith $300,000 per year in direct labor. Operation and maintenance costs on the machines are expected to cost $100,000 per year. The automated equipment is expected to improve quality. Smith's main competitors are installing similar equipment. If Smith installs the equipment, its revenues are expected to remain steady. If Smith chooses not to install new equipment, its contribution margins expected to fall by $200,000 per year as a result of lower quality compared to its competitors. Smith's discount rate is 10% and its tax rate is 30%.

A. How much is Smith expected to save each year if it installs the equipment (including tax effects)?

B. How much will Smith lose each year if it does not install the equipment (including tax effects)?

C. Explain how you would analyze this problem in order to determine if Smith should purchase the new machines.

D. Should Smith purchase the new machines?

E. Assume that programming and maintenance costs turn out to be much higher than Lillian's estimates. However, despite the fact that the automation equipment increased costs, Lillian still wants to continue with the project. Explain why Lillian might not want to scrap the equipment.

4. A phone company with a discount rate of 8% is considering two investments.

Residential Service Commercial Service

Initial Cost $(50,000) $(100,000)

Year 1 20,000 50,000

Year 2 20,000 50,000

Year 3 20,000 50,000

A. Calculate the NPV for both services.

B. If the phone company can provide only one service currently, which project should it choose?

C. If this is a regulated service industry, explain why the phone company may have to invest in the residential service."

Reference no: EM131184162

Questions Cloud

Describe the components of democracy : Describe the components of democracy. What are Plato's views on democracy
What is the field outside the sphere : Point charge in a conducting shell. A point charge +q is located inside a very thin conducting spherical shell halfway between the center and the shell shown in Figure 5.46. Assume the conducting shell is at zero potential.
Identify a problem with the actions of a person : Research a topic which interests you where you can identify a problem with the actions of a person, company or government that negatively impacts on a target group of people, economy, ecosystem or society
Assess the external threats affecting this corporatio : Assess the external threats affecting this corporation and the opportunities available to the corporation. Give your opinions on how the corporation should deal with the most serious threat and the greatest opportunity
What are the drawbacks from using payback as a method : What are the drawbacks from using payback as a method for selecting projects? What are the annual net cash inflows that would be realized from the new machine?
Find electric field intensity on the surface of the sphere : Point charge outside charged conducting sphere. Solve Problem 5.25 if the shell has a positive surface charge density Ps. The potential on the shell need not be zero.
Evaluate the reliability and validity of your job analysis : Evaluate different performance appraisal methods that might be applied to your chosen job. Explain the various benefits and vulnerabilities of each performance appraisal method.
Describe the responsibilities of governing bodies : Explain the difference between express, implied and corporate authority. What was on effect on corporate ethics or compliance of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002? Describe the responsibilities of governing bodies
What are the pros and cons of using this particular test : Select a psychological test and explain how it is used in the workplace. What are the pros and cons of using this particular test? What ethical issues arise when using psychological testing?

Reviews

Write a Review

Finance Basics Questions & Answers

  Financial reporting and analysis

Finance is about Gunns Ltd, a company in dealing with forestry products in Australia. The company has also been listed in Australian Stock Exchange. As many companies producing forestry products, even Gunns Ltd is facing various problems. Due to the ..

  A report on financial accounting

This report is specific for a core understanding for Financial Accounting and its relevant factors.

  Describe the types of financial ratios

Describe the types of financial ratios and other financial performance measures that are used during venture's successful life cycle.

  Differences between sole proprietorship and corporation

Briefly describe the major differences between a sole proprietorship and a corporation

  Prepare a cash budget statement

Calculate the expected value of the apartment in 20 years' time. What is the mortgage loan repayment at the beginning of each month

  What are the implied interest rates

What are the implied interest rates in Europe and the U.S.?

  State pricing theory and no-arbitrage pricing theory

State pricing theory and no-arbitrage pricing theory

  Small business administration

Identify the likely stage for each venture and describe the type of financing each venture is likely to be seeking and identify potential sources for that financing.

  Effect of financial leverage

The Effect of Financial Leverage and working capital management

  Evaluate the basis for the payment to the lender

Evaluate the basis for the payment to the lender and basis for the payment to the company-counterparty.

  Importance of opps, ipps, mpfs and dmepos

Research and discuss the differences and importance of : OPPS, IPPS, MPFS and DMEPOS.

  Time value of money

Time Value of Money project

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd