The appellate court first looked at the uccs provisions

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM13470275

The appellate court first looked at the UCC's provisions concerning auctions, but noted that the UCC did not apply in this case because the UCC applies only to "goods," and domain names are not goods. The court then looked at common law principles as codified in the Restatement (Second) of Contracts. The rules under the Restatement are similar to those of the UCC: a bid in an auction is an offer that is accepted when the "hammer falls," and an auction is with reserve unless otherwise speci-fied by the seller.

The court also pointed out, however, that DotTV's charging of the bid price to Lim's credit card was inconsistent with DotTV's claim that it could withdraw the domain name from the bidding be¬cause the auction was with reserve. Furthermore, stated the court, even if it concluded that Lim's bid was an offer and not an acceptance, DotTV had accepted the offer by its e-mail to Lim stating that he had won the auction. In all, held the court, there was no evidence that a contract between DotTV and Lim had not been formed, and Lim had stated a valid claim against DotTV for breach of contract. The court thus reversed the lower court's decision and remanded the case for further delib¬eration consistent with the appellate court's opinion.

Reference no: EM13470275

Questions Cloud

You will be assessed on the nature and scope of your : research whether your state allows the death penalty. write an essay with information on whether your state has the

How can government officials use the crime statistics data : how can government officials use the crime statistics data from the 1970s to predict crime twenty years later? how

Test claim that there is difference in proportion of : does the interval found in part a contain numbers that are all positive? all negative? mixed? comment on the meaning

Compare and contrast the object-oriented approach to design : compare and contrast the object-oriented approach to design and the traditional approach.do you believe that there are

The appellate court first looked at the uccs provisions : the appellate court first looked at the uccs provisions concerning auctions but noted that the ucc did not apply in

What are the two major less than lethal weapons developed : less-than-lethal-weapons have proven a huge asset for law enforcement. due to this technology injuries of both law

The case involved an online auction conducted by thetv : the case involved an online auction conducted by the.tv corporation international dottv on its web site. dottv posted

American manufacturing company obtains an insurance policy : 1.the person who owes the payment of a secured obligation is the secured party.a trueb false2.a financing statement

Identifying and explaining the key components of a : identifying and describing the key components of a comprehensive disaster recovery plan for any incident that could

User Account

All Pages