Relationship between job characteristics and job satisfactio

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131034617 , Length:

Job Satisfaction in the Banking Industry

Job characteristics are believed to have an impact on stress and well-being at work (Karasek & Theorell, 1990). The demands of the job on the one hand and the extent to which you have control over your own activities (decision latitude) on the other, are two factors which together define how stressful a job is. Those jobs which are high demand, but offer limited control, are considered to be high-strain and carry an increased risk of job dissatisfaction, stress and burnout.

Based on this theoretical framework, the Union of Belgian Banks sent out a research call to several institutions, with a bidding process based on criteria such as quality of the proposal, timing, and - above all - budget. The aim of the research was to carry out quantitative research to measure the relationship between job characteristics and job satisfaction in all Belgian banks at individual level. But in order to do this effectively, several methodological issues needed to be resolved during the research process.

First of all, a research consortium was selected to conduct the research, or more precisely, the two highest ranked bidders were asked to jointly undertake the research. This was the outcome of a political decision by the banks (see also p. 142, ‘Affiliation and conflicts of interest'), since the employers preferred one partner and the unions (employee representatives) preferred the other. The two competing research institutes, a private company specialising in stress at work and the Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (Belgium), were required to co-operate and develop a level of trust in order to conduct the research. For example, both research institutes had different ideas as to which scale should be used in the questionnaire. They could not just combine the scales or include both scales, simply because they are supposed to measure the same concept. Furthermore, this would also make the questionnaire too complex. Therefore, the research institutes had to combine their knowledge, look for compromises and jointly work on a shared vision, which is, to say the least, rather time consuming.

A second obstacle that needed to be overcome was the sample (see Chapter 7). In total, 69,000 employees work for Belgian banks and it was decided that questioning all employees would be too complicated and too expensive. Therefore the research committee, consisting of representatives of the banks, the unions and the research consortium, opted for a cross-sectional design (p. 45) with a fixed sample of 15,000 employees (roughly 21%; see p. 187 ‘Absolute and relative sample size').

In this sample, the small banks were over-represented. Within each bank, the respondents were selected at random with no particular quota for gender, age or employee level. In the postal survey (see p.231 ‘Self-completion questionnaire or postal questionnaire') several steps were taken to improve the response rate (see p. 234 ‘Steps to improve response rates to postal questionnaire'; see also suggestions by Dillman, 1983). The survey was based on addresses which had been provided by the banks (name, language, address) and each employee randomly selected in the sample received a personalized envelope through regular mail, sent to him/her by the employer. The completed questionnaire needed to be returned (free of charge) through the internal post within each bank.

There are various logistical problems. The researchers had to travel to each bank to collect the completed questionnaires and due to the fact that in Belgium, part of the population speak Flemish (Dutch) and part speak French, two versions of the questionnaire needed to be available and then carefully translated and tested for the accuracy of their translation (see also Tips and skills, p.488: ‘Translating interview data'). The questionnaires were sent to the respondents' home addresses, a French version if the respondent lived in the French part of Belgium, a Flemish version when living in Flanders. This prompted a series of angry calls when Flemish people, living in the French part, or vice versa, received a questionnaire that was not in their native language. Furthermore, Brussels is officially bi-lingual and, to complicate matters even more, contains many headquarters in which the main language spoken is ... English! In order to minimise attrition, it was important that these respondents received a questionnaire in their preferred language. Another logistical issue was the co-ordination and control of the distributed information. The Belgian banks, who were the research financers, chose a decentralised way of working, hence organizing a ‘sensibilization campaign' within each bank whereby the researchers had to visit all the banks to explain the theoretical framework and the outline of the research to representatives of both employers and employees.

Additional initiatives to prompt a higher response rate were taken up by individual banks, or, more precisely, by some of the banks. The researchers were required to carefully follow-up on those initiatives implemented by the banks, to ensure that these initiatives remained both neutral and valid for the research. Some of these initiatives proved difficult to deal with due to the selective use of information that had been employed (e.g. letters forcing the employees to participate; or union campaigns to guide certain answers). Hence, the researchers had to be sensitive for the respective organisational cultures, while making sure they kept a neutral position towards all partners involved in the research.

Once the data collection was completed (response rate of 47.6%), the data handling needed much attention. A comprehensive check and double-check was conducted on wrong entries, filters, missing cells ... just to increase the reliability. One issue was the major difference in response rate between the banks. Due to a strong campaign, some banks reached a response rate of over 60%, whilst others barely reached 20% because they did nothing to increase the response rate.

A final issue occurred when presenting the results. As mentioned above, the language issue is particularly important in Belgium to the extent that one even has to be concerned with the order of reporting and presenting (in terms of which language first).

A discussion arose concerning the graphs used in the report: using different axes can result in different perspectives, despite the fact that, statistically, the results obviously remain the same. In both figures below, the amount of people with stress is 5, whereas 10 have no stress. So the appearances can be deceptive.

Instructions for answering the questions

Use at least four academic sources in English (a minimum of three must be peer reviewed journal articles and the fourth may be another journal article, a text book or a report published by the relevant government bodies) to support your answers of the questions. The analysis of the case study will include around 2000 words in total, around 400 words for each question. This includes utilised academic sources as well as responding to the questions.

Q1: Research consortium and involvement of the financers (banks) in research: What are the problems of using two research institutions to do the research jointly? What are the problems of the involvement of the banks in the research design and sampling?

Q2: Sample size: Is this sample size of 15,000 (roughly 21% of the employees) necessary? Discuss its relative and absolute size. What do you suggest the sample size.

Q3: Data collection in a real social context. Since this is data collection in a real social context, issues such as time, budget and politics are important. How would you deal with them? Discuss some of the decisions the researchers have made.

Q4: Sampling method. The goal of the research is to find the relationship between job characteristics and job satisfaction. Every bank was surveyed. The small banks were over-represented in the sample. Is the sampling method for answering the research questions a good one?

Q5: Bias in data collection. The purpose of this study is to find the relationship between job characteristics and job satisfaction. What are the biases in data collection? How can you reduce the bias in the data collection?

Reference no: EM131034617

Questions Cloud

Discussion about federal reserve increased federal fund rate : The topic of discussion paper: Recently, the Federal Reserve increased the federal funds rate. Not all economists thought that the Fed did the right thing-they were of the opinion that it was still early for that kind of move by the Fed.
New product for its trophy division : Icon Industries is considering a new product for its Trophy Division. The product, which would feature an alligator, is expected to have global market appeal and to become the mascot for many high school and university athletic teams.
List the key ideas you have extracted : Watch the video on the following link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TD7WSLeQtVw (8:47). Paragraph 1: list the key ideas you have extracted from the prescribed e-learning activity
What is the name for the inflation rate that people forecast : What is the name for the inflation rate that people forecast and use to set the money wage rate and other money prices? What is the proposition that when the inflation rate changes?
Relationship between job characteristics and job satisfactio : The goal of the research is to find the relationship between job characteristics and job satisfaction. Every bank was surveyed. The small banks were over-represented in the sample. Is the sampling method for answering the research questions a good..
Compare ethical behaviors and societal responsibilities : Compare ethical behaviors and societal responsibilities of companies that operate only in the US and those that operate globally. Explain the concept of cultural difference in business behavior. Explain how globalization is changing business/behavior..
Identify some of recent issues in labelling and packaging : Labelling and packaging has been becoming a very important aspect of marketing. Identify some of the recent issues in labelling, packaging and country of origin in Australia. Students need to go through the current news and media to get the inform..
Would your advice be different if eve has asked adam : Advise Eve of her rights, if any, against Adam and any remedies available for her under common law and Would your advice be different if Eve has asked Adam the exact turnover of the business
What is the area under the standard normal curve : A company's Human Resources department administers a test of "Executive Aptitude". Test scores are known to be normally distributed with a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15. What score do you need to be in the top 12% of the applicant pool..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Who the members are in the walden learning community

Reflect on who the members are in the Walden learning community. What makes it a learning community? What are the roles of the various members of the community? How do they relate to one another? Include yourself in your thinking

  The british economist and philosopher adam smith

The British economist and philosopher Adam Smith would best say that:

  Evangelistic outreach across cultural lines

If you do not believe in cross-cultural evangelism, describe why you do not believe in evangelistic outreach across cultural lines. Feel free to reference and cite examples of cross-cultural evangelism strategies that you find ineffective.

  What if danger is condition of the workplace building itself

The range of dangerous conditions in which employees have been forced to work has been well documented, at least since Upton Sinclair's the Jungle. But, what if the danger is the condition of the workplace building itself? Do the OSH Act protections ..

  Assignment on contingency planning in action

Create a hypothetical organization with details including geographic location(s), number of employees in each location, primary business functions, operational and technology details, potential threats to the business and its technology, and anyth..

  Is the Sarbanes-Oxley Act too restrictive

Is the Sarbanes-Oxley Act too restrictive? Is it too burdensome on mid-sized companies? Explain your answer.

  How do people greet each other in australia india and japan

How do people greet each other in Australia, India, Japan, Korea, Netherlands, and Spain? In what countries is it important to keep a certain distance from the person you are greeting?

  Conservative position regarding abortion

What does Judith Jarvis Thomson find to be mistaken in the conservative position regarding abortion? describe thoroughly the analogies she uses to make her case.

  Design a health promotion program and arget population

Design a health promotion program for individuals in the workplace or in school that results in increased physical or psychological well-being. Define the following characteristics of your target population:

  Demonstrate your understanding of the complexities

Demonstrate your understanding of the complexities of how we learn by evaluating the potential correlations between symbolic interactionism and constructivism.

  Identify the aacn bsn essential that you have selected

Identify the AACN BSN Essential that you have selected by name and number. Clearly and thoroughly explain why you selected this Essential

  Web and human services organizations

Resource: Web and Human Services Organizations Identify at least 5 Human Services organizations that have websites.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd