Reference no: EM134050161
Question
Read: Why Not Limit Neil Gorsuch - and All Supreme Court Justices - to 18 year Terms?, by Lori Ringhand and Paul Collins, Jr., The Washington Post, March 23, 2017.
Also refencing: Norton Illumine Ebook Chapter 15
The Framers thought that the Court's legitimacy rested on its "judgment," its orientation toward protecting individual rights, and its propensity for enforcing the limits of the Constitution. However, to exercise that judgment, the Framers believed that the judges, in their individual capacity, needed independence. Hamilton in Federalist 78 argued that lifetime appointments were necessary for the judicial branch if the justices were "to be considered as the bulwarks of a limited constitution against legislative encroachments." Early in the Convention debates, it was decided that judges would serve life terms. Life tenure would allow judges to develop the knowledge needed for the job, and it would insulate judges from legislative pressure. But there might be a downside to lifetime appointments, which is a rare arrangement among democracies.
In "Why Not Limit Neil Gorsuch-and All Supreme Court Justices-to 18-Year Terms?," Lori Ringhand and Paul Collins focus on limiting the judicial terms to increase democratic accountability and to reduce partisanship on the bench. In making all terms 18 years, Ringhand and Collins argue the Court would be more dependent on the elected branches and therefore more tied to the people, partisanship could be reduced, more qualified justices would be appointed, and we could still maintain the Court's independence. Do you think limiting judicial terms to 18 years would help prevent judicial supremacy or would it overly constrain the courts?
According to Ringhand and Collins, what are the benefits to instituting 18-year terms for Supreme Court justices? What do they see as potential drawbacks?
Explain the authors' argument for why term limits for justices would make the appointment process less politically fraught.
As noted in the introduction to this article, Hamilton offered justification for the need for lifetime appointments for judges in Federalist 78.
Given the changes that have occurred in the last 230 years, do you think Hamilton would still advocate for lifetime appointments today? Why?