Job evaluation at smith upholstery

Assignment Help Business Management

Reference no: EM133875923

Question

1. What problems may occur by following Robert's approach?

2. What do you recommend Marco do first? Why?

Case 1: Job Evaluation at Smith Upholstery

Smith Upholstery has been in business since 1970. The company started out hand upholstering the seats for luxury automakers. It built a reputation of excellence. In recent years, however, many luxury automobile companies established in-house upholstering shops, leading to a reduction in business. The company's founder, Robert Smith, anticipated these changes and actively sought contracts to upholster seats for the high-volume economy car market, using automated technology. Robert staffed the manufacturing line to oversee the operation of automated systems and troubleshoot problems that threatened to slow down the line.

Robert recognized that he needed help crafting job descriptions and job evaluation plans to help set pay rates. He hired Marco Colella following the completion of a master's degree in human resources. Robert met Marco shortly after he began his first day of work. He reviewed priorities with Marco and Robert asked him to lead the job description and job evaluation projects. They agreed to meet at the end of the week to discuss a plan for getting this work done.

Marco met with managers to understand current staffing and job structures. Also, he discussed anticipated staffing needs. Marco used the information that he gathered and what he learned about job descriptions and job evaluation in his degree program to develop a proposal for completing this project. He crafted alternatives for conducting job evaluation, including simple ranking, alternate ranking, and point method plans; and he estimated the time it would take to complete job evaluation with each method. Finally, Marco analyzed the pros and cons of each approach. Altogether, it would take two weeks to complete job evaluation with either simple or alternate ranking techniques and two months for the point method. Taking everything into account, Marco decided that the point method would provide the best information for building internally consistent job structures. Marco submitted his plan to Robert in anticipation of their upcoming meeting.

At the start of the meeting, Robert thanked Marco for his excellent plan and for the detailed rationale and timeline for each option. Although Marco recommended using the point method, Robert instructed him to conduct the job evaluations with the simple ranking method. He also asked Marco to conduct the ratings himself rather than involving multiple raters, indicating his desire to reduce the completion time from two weeks to one week. Marco respectfully asked Robert to reconsider his decision, but he would not. Instead, Robert also assigned Marco the task of completing the company's first affirmative action plan, which was already two weeks overdue.

Reference no: EM133875923

Questions Cloud

How does aquinas propose to balance faith and reason : How does Aquinas propose to balance faith and reason? How is his demonstration of the existence of God similar to that of philosophy, especially Aristotle?

Potential recruitment platforms : Developing a comprehensive list of potential recruitment platforms and venues is another strategy that can aid a researcher.

Several problems for dim lighting company : There are several problems for the Dim Lighting Company. Identify which problems are Macro problems (involving the whole company) and Micro problems

Distinguishes between knowledge of experience and art : Aristotle distinguishes between the knowledge of experience and the knowledge of art (980.15). What is the distinction, and why are they important?

Job evaluation at smith upholstery : Smith Upholstery has been in business since 1970. The company started out hand upholstering the seats for luxury automakers.

What is the most appropriate initial treatment : A 16-year-old girl presents with a 6-month history of small skin lesions on her face. What is the most appropriate initial treatment?

Role of Management Information Systems : The Role of Management Information Systems in CSR Reporting. Develop a research paper explaining this example.

Which can be used to determine the cause : This was followed by poor attention span and learning difficulties. There is a blue-purplish line on the gums. Which can be used to determine the cause?

Do you feel that healthcare facilities able to address issue : Medical resource allocation became of high priority for all facilities. Class, do you feel that healthcare facilities were able to address this issue?

User Account

All Pages