Identify the premise and conclusion for each argument

Assignment Help Business Management

Reference no: EM133485159

Problem

Evaluate and explain if the2 arguments have:

1) Truthfulness
2) Logical strength
3) Relevance
4) Non-circularity

Argument:

Ella (18 years old) lives with her older sister Ashley (22 years old). Both of them got into an argument and Ella is angry with her older sister because her older sister is not letting her hang out with her friends after 9pm at night.

Ella's argument is that; she is over 18 years are legally an adult so her sister should stop treating her like a child. Ashley's argument is that Ella does not understand boundaries and if she lets her stay out over 9pm, Ella will take advantage of it and stay out till morning hours because this happened once.

Question 1) Evaluate both Ella and Ahsley's argument and see if they both have: Truthfulness, logical strength, relevance, and non-circularity.

Question 2) Identify the premise (claim) and conclusion for each argument and start evaluation from there.

Reference no: EM133485159

Questions Cloud

Law for the sake of liberty and justice for all : Do you think that breaking the law for the sake of "liberty and justice for all" is ever justified? How can you tell that yours is a just cause?

Explaining the premise of the case that led to the ruling : Explaining the premise of the case that led to the ruling, what the Supreme Court decided, and how the ruling impacts interactions with juvenile offenders

Quantitative and qualitative risk assessment : Difference between a quantitative and qualitative risk assessment? What are the benefits of conducting a SVA?

Explain how initiatives and referendums support the idea : Explain how initiatives and referendums support the idea of direct democracy as outlined in the Arizona Constitution.

Identify the premise and conclusion for each argument : Ella's argument is that; she is over 18 years are legally. Identify the premise (claim) and conclusion for each argument and start evaluation from there.

What are the presumed benefits and problems : what are the presumed benefits and problems of transferring youths from the juvenile justice system to the adult system?

Explain the nature of this distinction : Stoicism is based on the distinction between what is in our control, and what is not in our control. Explain the nature of this distinction,

What are the benefits of conducting a sva : What are the benefits of conducting a SVA? Consider and discuss key terms from the readings when evaluating the benefits

Why individuals might choose not to report a crime : Being a victim of crime can be very traumatic. In a minimum of 200 words, discuss at least three reasons why individuals might choose not to report a crime

User Account

All Pages