User Account

All Pages

How should engineer weigh political and consequences of work

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131708329

Assignment

THREAD 1

We are looking at Langdon Winner's classic essay "Do Artifacts Have Politics?"

What does it mean to say that certain technologies can be designed to embody political and social consequences? These consequences can either be consciously or unconsciously designed in. What is the difference?

Can you give some examples of technologies with designed political consequences? Are these political consequences conscious or unconscious? Are these consequences good or bad? Explain.

Thread 2: Technologies with Inherent Political Consequences

What does it mean to say that certain technologies can have inherent political and social consequences? How do inherent political consequences differ from designed political consequences? What is the difference between a technology that is strongly compatible with certain political arrangements and those that require certain political arraignments? What is the difference between technologies that have consequences that are internal to the technical system and those that have external political consequences?

Can you give some examples of technologies with inherent political consequences? Does this technology require or is it merely strongly compatible with certain political arrangements? Are these political consequences internal to or external to the technology? Are these consequences good or bad? Explain.

THREAD3: Moral vs. Instrumental Reasoning

When designing new technologies engineers are primarily engaged with designing a system that works, that is efficient, and that is practical. As Langdon Winner argues on page 36, however, these practical or technical considerations often eclipse moral or political considerations. This could lead to the creation, for example, of more efficient technologies that have undemocratic consequences at the expense of less efficient technologies that are more friendly to democratic governance. But why should we sacrifice democracy for the sake of efficiency?

How should the engineer weigh the political and moral consequences of their work when compared to the more traditional considerations of engineers?

Do you think engineers are good at foreseeing these supposedly extra-technical consequences of their work? Why or why not?

Winner says that it is characteristic of societies like ours, that rely on large and complex technological systems, to view moral reasoning as "obsolete, ‘idealistic,' and irrelevant." Do you agree with Winner's characterization of our society? Is this a problem? Why or why not? If you see it as a problem, what should be done, and in particular what is the role of the engineer in making moral reasoning more central to our thinking about technology?

Reference no: EM131708329

Questions Cloud

Derive an expression for the time : Derive an expression for the time tc for complete conversion of ZnS in a particle of radius R. Sketch the radial profile of the concentration of O2
What guidelines exist for determining proper transfer price : Correct Pricing. Section 482 of the U.S. Internal Revenue Code specifies use of a "correct" transfer price, and the burden of proof that the transfer price.
Discuss history of the south from the photographs : What do you think Mann is trying to say about the history of the South from the photographs she takes
What is meant by the term tax haven : Tax-Haven Subsidiary. Answer the following questions: What are the desired characteristics for a country if it expects to be used as a tax haven?
How should engineer weigh political and consequences of work : How should the engineer weigh the political and moral consequences of their work when compared to the more traditional considerations of engineers?
What legislative requirements may apply to the systems : Describe the information or knowledge management systems and What measures might be used to assess effectiveness of each of these systems
The fundamental differences in investigating a death case : Select an article concerning a type of death of your choice and summarize the key factors that the police used to classify the type of death.
Define how does photography affect how we see history : Define How does photography affect how we see history, use other examples to explain your views
Hypothetical subsidiary earnings-distribution analysis : Avon's Foreign-Source Income. Avon is a U.S.-based direct seller of a wide array of products. Avon markets leading beauty, fashion, and home products.

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Wxplain why not this is an acceptable solution for michael

This placement will cost over $5,000 per year, but the school has stated they can only pay $3,000 for an out of district therapeutic day placement. Based on what you have learned about FAPE, explain why or why not this is an acceptable solution for..

  Importance of digital marketing

Explain the importance of digital marketing and its business analytics in decision making. Use scholarly articles to support your arguments

  Compare performance of islamic banks with conventional banks

Compare the performance of Islamic banks with that of the conventional banks. Develops ideas cogently, organizes them logically with paragraphs and connects them with effective transitions.

  Describe importance of organizational climate and motivation

Describe the importance of organizational climate and motivation. Describe Kelley's model of effective followership (moving between roles).

  Discuss about the sexual orientation and sexual abuse

Imagine that you are working as a counselor in an elementary school. A teacher has come to you, concerned that a student in her class might have been sexually abused. She explains that she became concerned when two of her 5-year old male students ..

  Assignment-developing a strategic approach

Create a mission and vision statement for your organization. Determine three (3) specific strategic goals that align with the ideals in those two (2) statements.

  Research study for obesity

Utilizing descriptive research methods, design a research study for Obesity as it relates to Teenage Depression the Research Project: Literature Review. As a part of the research study be sure to address the following items:

  Organization''s integrated marketing communications

What is the role of public relations within an organization's integrated marketing communications (IMC) plan?

  Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome

hoose 2 diseases or disorders to complete the table.Be sure to properly cite references and sources for any information or facts used.

  Explain the chosen management and leadership style

Describe and explain the chosen management and leadership style. Discuss the Manager roles and Leader roles in healthcare organization.

  Radio transponder and landing guidance system

Several years ago, a multilateral treaty came into effect among some 45 countries, including most of the major developed countries of the world. the treaty, known as the Outer Space Treaty, forbids any member state from claiming " any planet, satelli..

  What are the key points that the author is making

What are the key points that the author is making? What's the relevant history around the topic being discussed? What is prompting the author to write the article?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

Submit Assignment

Academics

Major Subjects

Majors

Get In Touch

whatsapp: +1-415-670-9521

Phone: +1-415-670-9521

Email: [email protected]

TERMS & POLICIES

HELP & SUPPORT

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd