How does your analysis compare to lonergan-baird analysis

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133566920

Assignment:

Topic: Case Study: Ethical Decision-Making Formats

Case Study (Johnson, 2021) is below.

Before you do an analysis, explain your "gut" reaction, paying careful attention to your emotions. What is your initial emotional reaction?

Now, analyze the case using the Lonergan/Baird Method (see Baird, 2015). How does your initial reaction (emotional) compare to your logical analysis using the Lonergan/Baird method?

Next, analyze the same scenario using one of the other remaining ethical decision-making formats (Four-Way, Five Timeless Questions, or Foursquare Protocol). How does your analysis compare to the Lonergan/Baird analysis?

Which method do you prefer and why? What are the advantages and disadvantages of Lonergan/Baird method vs. the other method you selected? Did your logical analysis change your initial "gut" (emotional) reaction to the scenario?

Baird, 2015 resource

Scenario

You are the chair of the tenure and promotion committee at your small university. Your committee, made up of senior faculty, evaluates the teaching and scholarship of professors and then makes recommendations to the university provost. Committee members take their responsibilities seriously, knowing that peer review-where faculty members evaluate the work of other faculty-plays a critical role in higher education. They feel an obligation to maintain high teaching and research standards. No professor can be tenured (given guaranteed employment) or promoted to a higher rank (associate professor, full professor) without a positive recommendation from your group. Those denied tenure must leave the school at the end of the current school year.

Your closest departmental colleague is being reviewed for tenure. (Your families sometimes celebrate holidays together and your children are friends.) He expects that you will offer a positive review and encourage the committee to recommend tenure. Unfortunately, your coworker's teaching evaluations are below average. His scholarship is not strong enough to make up for these shortcomings. You know that your colleague will be devastated by a negative evaluation and will be forced to move to another city to take a new position. He will feel betrayed and blame you for the committee's decision, though you are only one voice in the group. Will you support your colleague's application for tenure?

Reference no: EM133566920

Questions Cloud

Identify management with other research in the field : Compare the comments regarding the barriers to identify management with other research in the field.

Explain your thoughts about demonstrating consistency : Explain your thoughts about demonstrating consistency, self discipline and commitment as a manager/leader?

The nurse is analyzing the clients symptoms : The nurse is analyzing the client's symptoms. For each assessment finding, click to specify if it indicates myocardial infarction or gastroenteritis.

Complications of dysphagia : What are 2 complications of dysphagia (do not include death) that could develop and how are you as a nurse could prevent it.

How does your analysis compare to lonergan-baird analysis : Which method do you prefer and why? What are the advantages and disadvantages of Lonergan/Baird method vs. the other method you selected?

Pain free periods lasting month or longer : 28 year old male reports orbital headaches that occur consistently for weeks. these are following by pain free periods lasting a month or longer.

What is the level of measurement for movement : Implications for Evidence-Based Practice, one of the variables mentioned in the study is movement. What is the level of measurement for movement?

Client is admitted to the hospital after being found : A client is admitted to the hospital after being found in a parking lot, kicking cars and yelling at passersby.

How can yum china change its organizational structure : How can Yum China change its organizational structure and culture to better suit the Chinese market's specific problems and opportunities?

User Account

All Pages