How does the sterilization of individuals like carrie buck

Assignment Help History

Reference no: EM133311112

Case: The American eugenics movement in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries sought to rid society of genetic and social ills by weeding out "degenerate" genes from the American gene pool. By 1920, several states had passed laws which gave them the authority to forcibly sterilize individuals they classified as unfit to breed (often called "feebleminded" or "imbeciles"), all in the name of civic responsibility.

In 1924, American eugenicists decided to test the constitutionality of eugenic laws in an effort to placate critics. A Virginia case involving Carrie Buck, an unmarried, pregnant seventeen-year old, was selected to be heard by the Supreme Court

For this assignment, please watch/read the video and my notes on Buck vs. Bell (1927) and Eugenics in America (Video 2) AND the excerpt of Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes' majority opinion.

Then in a minimum of 250 words (approximately two paragraphs), please respond to the following questions:

According to Justice Holmes, how does the sterilization of individuals like Carrie Buck "help" society? Provide at least one example from the ruling to support your answer.
If Carrie Buck's illegitimate pregnancy was "proof" of her feeble-mindedness, why wasn't there a similar effort to sterilize the baby's father, who was also unmarried?
Should state governments have a say in which of its citizens can procreate? Why or why not?

Reference no: EM133311112

Questions Cloud

Are these requirements consistent with goss v lopez : Are these requirements consistent with Goss v. Lopez? Support your position with examples from case law, the U.S. Constitution, or other readings

How does art young portray the silk manufacturers : How does Art Young portray the silk manufacturers? Describe the image that represents them and How does the cartoonist portray Uncle Sam?

Describe the main routes of disease transmission : Disease transmission is of utmost importance in the medical fields. Describe the 3 main routes of disease transmission (contact, vehicle, and vector).

Identify which of the epidemiological factors of the disease : What is the most relevant nursing role? What is the action that puts the general population and the nursing professional at greater risk of contagion?

How does the sterilization of individuals like carrie buck : How does the sterilization of individuals like Carrie Buck "help" society? Provide at least one example from the ruling to support your answer

Does she build a successful case for the incompatibility : "The Church and Slavery," Linda explores the moral conflict between slavery and Christianity. Does she build a successful case for the incompatibility of these

What would be a good summary of the messaging : What would be a good summary of the messaging from the cigarette and car commercials in the 1950s sitcom Make room for Daddy, Season2, Episode 1, "Family

What are ways that you can be decolonial and anti-racist : What are 3 ways that you can be decolonial and anti-racist in your approach to working with people as a social worker/helping professional?

What were economic and political conditions : What were economic and political conditions like for Tejanos (Mexican Texans) during the era of the Republic of Texas

User Account

All Pages