Ethics morality and leadership the awb scandalthe series of

Assignment Help Business Management
Reference no: EM13371633 , Length: 2000 words

Ethics, morality and leadership: The AWB scandal

The series of corporate scandals and transgressions that have emerged over the last decade, including those associated with Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Alcoa, Enron, HIH, Merck, Lehman Brothers, Parmalat, Union Carbide and WorldCom, have not only contributed to global ?nancial crises. They have also raised questions about the quality of corporate leadership and ethics, and damaged the psychological relationships between such companies and their multiple stakeholders. Studies of such scandals and transgressions in Australia suggest that fraud, including corporate scandals and institutional corruption, has cost the Australian economy dearly.

This is supported by extensive research on corruption carried out by Transparency International, which targets particular countries in Asia and Africa and their governments for special attention. In response, many governments and enlightened corporations have established tighter corporate governance (CG) and personal accountability regulations and mechanisms, together with a wide range of corporate social responsibility (CSR) programs. While the former are aimed speci?cally at preventing fraud and other unethical practices, CSR is primarily intended to enhance corporate reputations through undertaking socially responsible community activities.

In the case of the Australian Wheat Board (AWB), the government-owned monopoly wheat exporter, a combination of incompetence, pragmatism and clear deception led to the scandal that engulfed AWB in 2006. Together with other competitors, AWB was found to have been involved in the provision of large amounts of kickbacks to government representatives in Iraq in order to ensure the continuing supply of their wheat, in contravention of explicit Australian government legislation. It was revealed that AWB had participated in such illegal activity, including the startling revelations that of the US$1.8 billion that had ?owed to Iraq during Saddam Hussein's regime through bribes and the rorting of the United Nations Oil-for-Food program, a large proportion (US$300 million) came from just one company, AWB. Of the more than 3000 companies that had contracts with Iraq, 2253 paid kickbacks, but none more so than Iraq's biggest wheat supplier, AWB.

The local and global media went on a rampage, with one commentator describing the events unfolding at the time as ‘Deceit by the Truckload'. Finally, in response to overwhelming publicity, the Australian government established the Cole Inquiry to investigate the scandal.
Corporate deception and incompetence, and the Australian government's apparent predisposition not to initially accept the claims of AWB's accusers, were the consistent themes throughout the 12-week inquiry into the so-called ‘oil-for-food' scandal. Among other ill effects, this affected Australia's reputation internationally; for example, its ranking on the Transparency International Corruption Index fell from 9 to 11
The Cole Inquiry raised a number of speci?c issues about AWB's values and operating procedures, as well as broader issues about corporate ethics, morality and leadership. It questioned how such illegal and immoral activities had been allowed to occur; the apparent absence of internal auditing procedures, the AWB managers' ethical and leadership shortcomings; and the company's cover-up of its actions. However, it also questioned the Australian government's apparent lack of monitoring, and its reluctance to confront the problems despite a mountain of diplomatic cables that ?owed to ministers and their staff suggesting that AWB was involved in systematic misbehaviour.

That AWB went to extraordinary lengths to deceive is unarguable. But whether this clears the government of responsibility for not acting on the many tip-offs about AWB's behaviour depends on whose test you use.41 According to Australia's prime minister at the time, John Howard, the test should be one of ‘reasonableness'. In the press conference following his appearance at the Cole Inquiry a few hours earlier, the prime minister countered arguments that his government should have acted on the dozens of warnings by citing others who had been duped by AWB. However, there had been numerous earlier warnings of AWB's unethical practices.42 For example, just a month after AWB made its ?rst payment of US$500 000 into the Jordanian account of transport company Alia (half owned by the Iraqi government), the Canadian Wheat Board was told by the Iraqis that to have its wheat contract processed it would have to pay US$700 000 into the same Jordanian account. The Canadians duly quizzed the propriety of such ‘trucking fees' with the UN's Of?ce of the Iraq Program, to be told it was indeed illegal. If that was the case, then why was AWB doing just this, they asked.

Instructions:

1.Please conduct your own independent research on the topic in addition to the material provided above. Approach the questions by a) identifying the key issues b) outlining the theories of ethics and discussing the competing arguments as a group and c) making your conclusions giving reasons.

2. You must link your discussions to the normative theories of ethics and the course material. It is not sufficient to just give your subjective opinion.

Questions:

1. Why do you think that AWB paid bribes to the Iraqi regime?

2. Did AWB executives abuse their position in making payments to the Iraqi regime in contravention of the UN sanctions? Does the absence of an obvious personal benefit make a difference to the moral evaluation?

3. Do the payments by AWB meet the criteria for bribes, or are they grease payments?

4. Remain loyal or below the whistle? What would you do at the inquiry? And why?

5. The foreign corruption practices act, and the equivalents in many countries, make it a crime to pay bribes to foreign government officials. Why should payments to governments be given special treatment?

6. Did AWB have no option? What pressures might have made it think that way? What options might it have considered if it had approached the situation differently?

7. Would it have been appropriate for AWB to admit to the payment of bribes and justify its action on the basis of the financial benefit that the sales produced for Australian wheat farmers? Are there other justifications AWB could have used?

8. Explain the steps that AWB need s to put in place to combat and minimize the risk of future unethical or immoral practices and to enhance its reputation, including corporate government and/ or CSR systems.

Reference no: EM13371633

Questions Cloud

Mitchell electronics produces a home video game that has : mitchell electronics produces a home video game that has become very popular with children. mitchells managers have
Question 1 capital expenditure decisions and investment : question 1 capital expenditure decisions and investment criteriain recent years morten ltd a company that manufactures
Brief introduction to the assignment academic definitions : brief introduction to the assignment. academic definitions of terms used. clear diagram that draws extensively on the
Read the paper significance of gender and age in african : read the paper significance of gender and age in african american childrens response to parental victimization. then
Ethics morality and leadership the awb scandalthe series of : ethics morality and leadership the awb scandalthe series of corporate scandals and transgressions that have emerged
1 what does an instructional designer know2 according to : 1. what does an instructional designer know?2. according to reiser what is the ?eld of instructional technology?3. what
1 construct an explicit deformation retraction of the torus : 1. construct an explicit deformation retraction of the torus with one point deleted onto a graph consisting of two
Part-11theory of the firmaif in an efficient brewing : part-11.theory of the firmaif in an efficient brewing industry firms operating at lowest possible average cost produce
Assume that capacitor is completely discharged when tlt0 : assume that capacitor is completely discharged when tlt0. plot these graphs in matlab or any other computing software

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Business Management Questions & Answers

  Trade-offs in inputs to improve productivity

Many times trade-offs are necessary to increase productivity. What are important trades-offs involving the inputs to productivity?

  Social psychologists as well as even sociologists

Social psychologists as well as even sociologists a lot of times talk about fragmentary identities that exist in people bicultural people

  Impact of performance appraisals on productivity

Evaluate why organizations can have higher productivity when top managers encourage supervisors to set goals, assess performance,

  Important information about operations management

important information about operations management problemthis is for an online class and i am having trouble

  Evaluate the ts of service at department store

Operations Management Evaluate the three T's of service at department store - Perform a quick service audit the next time you go shopping at a department store.

  Important information about effective leadershipis

important information about effective leadershipis effective leadership really necessary for a project to be

  Chart for job-based or person-based

Compares and contrasts a person-based salary structure with a job based and prepare a table with your jobs in and write a short statement explaining why you placed the job in that category

  Show critical path method

Critical path method - The Critical Path Method is a fundamental topic for all project managers to understand.

  Attributes of tomorrow-s leaders according to linda hill

What are the attributes of tomorrow's leaders, according to Linda Hill?

  State as its members dealt with scheduling

Refer to Mattel. During the first two weeks of its existence, the Mattel team was in the __ state as its members dealt with scheduling and similar concerns? Reforming, forming, performing, forming or conforming?

  Non-market environmentwhat are the three ways in which

non-market environmentwhat are the three ways in which nonmarket issues can be resolved or the boundary between market

  Approaches to contractingif you were entering into a

approaches to contractingif you were entering into a contract with another party as the buyer explain the process you

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd