Establishing legal duty of the physician

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM13779876

Case Facts

Physician Dr. Van H. Vu practiced medicine in Orange County (OC), California. In 2012, he was accused of prescribing power pain killer narcotics with lead to the death of three patients as a result of prescription drug overdoses. The Medical Board of California sought to suspend Vu's medical license due to gross negligence with regards to patient care. The plaintiffs were a 22-year-old woman, a 43-year-old mentally ill man, and a 51-year-old single father (Glover & Girion, 2014). Dr. Vu's response to the lawsuit was "Every single day, I try to do the best I can for every single patient, and I can't control what they do once they leave my office." (Glover & Girion, 2014, para. 8). In addition, the OC medical board claimed that Dr. Vu neglected to address signs of distress exhibited by the three patients before they died. Instead, he continued to issue the plaintiffs deadly prescription drug combinations (Glover & Girion, 2014).

Issue

The question presented to the court is negligence, a sub-category of tort law. In order to proceed with medical negligence there are four elements that are required: (1) establishing legal duty of the physician, (2) breach of duty, (3) patient suffered injury, and (4) injury was caused by the substandard of conduct (Matzo, 2014). The burden of proof for all four elements rests on the plaintiff. For this case the physician established legal duty accepting the patient and administering care via medications. The physician breached duty by dispensing strong medications in abundance and not properly assessing patient risk factors for over-sedation or suicidal ideation. Multiple patients died under the alleged negligence proving harm, and since the patients died of respiratory depression, a common side effect of opiate pain medication, his actions caused the harm.

Reference no: EM13779876

Questions Cloud

Do you think mcdonald''s breached its implied warranty : The questions to be discussed this week are as follows:  Do you think McDonald's breached it's implied warranty when it sold Ms Liebeck her coffee
Produce a cognitive map on a provided mis topic area : Produce a Cognitive Map (using FreeMind) on a provided MIS topic area (see list of topics below): Expectations are that the map will have a minimum of:
Problems related to direct marketing : Define direct marketing. Does direct marketing help with relationship marketing?
Inclusion versus segregation : One of the top issues in special education is the ongoing debate of "inclusion versus segregation." The idea of inclusion in education is that all students, no matter what disability they may have, should learn together in the same environment.
Establishing legal duty of the physician : The question presented to the court is negligence, a sub-category of tort law. In order to proceed with medical negligence there are four elements that are required: establishing legal duty of the physician
Developing a new product that is superior : Developing a new product that is superior to competitor's brands or establishing a price for a new product using the law of supply and demand.
Discuss the equal employment acts : Discuss the equal employment acts protecting those groups. How is diversity in the country you chose similar to or different from diversity in the United States?
Write what i think when i see the title of given article : Internal Exiles: The Interventionist Public and Performance Art of Asco by C. Ondine Chavoya. Read the above article and write 1. what i think when i see the title 2. what i want to know 3. what i learned from this essay.
Overview of the swift nature : Begin by giving a general overview of the swift nature in which the Internet was created and presented to the public consumers. Then move forward and discuss the Federal Laws involved in regulating privacy

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Describe the elements of the criminal justice process

What problems are associated with Alford and nolo contendere pleas? How does a plea of not guilty differ from a plea of not guilty by reason of affirmative defense? Briefly list and describe the elements of the criminal justice process

  Show the level of diversification

Look for a firm that has recently engaged in two or more acquisitions, about which you can collect information and the firm should be have two or more alliances or joint ventures with other firms as a meaningful part of one or more of its business u..

  The discussion on nature versus nurture

The discussion on nature versus nurture is one that pits two philosophical frameworks against each other. Nature is the concept that biologically and in personality, humans possess gifts, traits, and abilities that make them the distinct individuals ..

  What state and federal enforcement agencies have

What have some of the principal disincentives for local police involvement with white collar crime been? What state and federal enforcement agencies have played a role in the investigation of white collar crime? Which factors inhibit, and which facto..

  Describe the implied warranties under bc sale of goods act

Describe the implied warranties under the BC Sale of Goods Act. What is a ‘bona fide occupational qualification' and why is it significant

  Barriers that exist between the police and the community

Barriers that exist between the police and the community they serve. What can police officers do to reduce communication barriers? Provide examples

  Definition of the crime and crime rate

Compare and contrast the two (2) countries for their definition of the crime, crime rate, and tools used to measure the crime. Determine each country's legal traditions and their major influences on crime definition, rate, and measurement

  John and jay are college roommates jay is a finance officer

john and jay are college roommates. jay is a finance officer with the bank and earns 200000 per year. john has just

  If you eat 600 calories per day roughly one dessert below

what is the difference between energy and power? what is a unit of power? how does speed relate to power? explain how a

  Identify and clearly define the relevant law

Identify and clearly define the relevant law, either defining a legal doctrine, provisions of a law, or elements of a specific cause of action

  Terry kunkle and vanburan high hosted a christmas party in

terry kunkle and vanburan high hosted a christmas party in berkeley county south carolina. guested had drinks and hors

  In accepting an early retirement package from his employer

1.alice jones was employed as a clerk-typist by a company. she requested and was refused a vacation day. the employers

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd