Do you agree or disagree with the courts ruling

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM13779227

The case "Kelo v. City of New London" is a land-use case which was decided by the United States Supreme Court in June, 2005. The case arose from a city's use of eminent domain to condemn privately owned real property so that it could be used for economic development.

In 1998, the pharmaceutical company Pfizer began construction of a major research facility on the outskirts of New London. Seeing an "opportunity," the city of New London reactivated the New London Development Corporation, a private entity under the control of the city government, to consider plans to redevelop the area and encourage new economic activities that might be brought in by the Pfizer plant. The development plan included a resort hotel and conference center, a new state park, new residences, and various research, office, and retail space. The plan authorized the corporation to acquire 115 residential lots by exercising its right of eminent domain. However, owners of 15 of these properties did not wish to leave their properties. These owners sued then city, arguing that the city had misused its eminent domain power.

Discuss the Supreme Court's interpretation of the Just Compensation Clause under the Fifth Amendment. Do you agree or disagree with the Court's ruling? Why? Do you understand the basis for their decision? Did the majority decide as "judicial activists" or "strict constructionists" in their analysis? What are some of the arguments against this decision? What are your views on this case---and what has transpired in its aftermath?

Reference no: EM13779227

Questions Cloud

What applications does the fourth amendment hold : In review, what applications does the Fourth Amendment hold for crime scene searches relative to the concept of unreasonable searches and seizures? Explain

Understanding of organizational behavior : Do you think that this knowledge is more important at some levels that others? Why or why

Data file description : Summarize the article in a maximum of 600 words using the DAA Template document located in the Resources area. Specific instructions for completing each section of the DAA Template are listed below.Data Analysis and Application (DAA) Template

What to produce and quantity : What to produce and quantity - how to produce by whom to produce and for whom it will be produced are the questions in the economy?

Do you agree or disagree with the courts ruling : Discuss the Supreme Court's interpretation of the Just Compensation Clause under the Fifth Amendment. Do you agree or disagree with the Court's ruling

Write a tennis-match outline that compare gender or class : write a Tennis-Match Outline that will later become the Project Four Research Essay. Your thesis statement for this essay should do the following: Compare gender or class and how it is handled in short story, play or poem.

Carefully comment each line of the assembly program : The assembly language code segment below is to be inserted into the main.asm file that takes an input controlled by a potentionmeter, converts that input to a digital value, and displays that value on the LEDs according to the following

Difference between a co-payment and co-insurance : What would you do if your patient paid by check, but the check came back due to "non-sufficient funds?"

Define the best interest of the child standard : Define the best interest of the child standard.What are the legal categories considered by the course for abuse and neglect?List three factors or standards the court may use to determine what is in the best interest of a child.

User Account

All Pages