Reference no: EM132180470

Discussion 1

Many would acknowledge that at one time unions were good for workers and the country as they were able to help workers obtain safer and healthier working conditions, higher pay, and a variety of legal protections.

On the other hand, many argue that they have outlived their usefulness and contribute to lower competitiveness and a decline in the value of merit (with the union emphasis on seniority).

What are three things that you think are positive about unions and three things that you think are negative? Are unions good or bad?

Explain and provide reasons for your opinion. Discuss any personal experiences or observations that you may have had with unions that support your opinion.

(If you have personally not had a personal experience, research on the net for a case study that supports your opinion.) ATLEAST 250 WORDS

Discussion 2

On several occasions in the last decade, the President of the U.S. has threatened to use authority granted by the Railway Labor Act (RLA) to prevent a strike. For example, George W. Bush threatened to use this power to prevent a strike by West Coast dock workers and by aircraft mechanics at Northwest Airlines.

The RLA gives the federal government the authority to intervene to prevent or stop a strike when public welfare or national security is at stake.

Should the president have such authority? Should the president also have the authority to do so at other times?

Does this authority prevent unions from exercising the right to strike given to them by the RLA and the National Labor Relations Act (Wagner Act)?

Should the president have and use this authority for national security and public welfare? If so, why and under what conditions, i.e., what constitutes the public welfare and national security?

If not, why not? Should this authority be extended to other situations such as those that may cause great inconvenience and/or cost to the public?

Justify your answer using examples and reasoning. ATLEAST 250 WORDS