Did nationwide act ethically in retrieving the e-mail

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM131470369

Question: Richard Fraser was an "exclusive career insurance agent" under a contract with Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. Fraser leased computer hardware and software from Nationwide for his business. During a dispute between Nationwide and the Nationwide Insurance Independent Contractors Association, an organization representing Fraser and other exclusive career agents, Fraser prepared a letter to Nationwide's competitors asking whether they were interested in acquiring the represented agents' policyholders. Nationwide obtained a copy of the letter and searched its electronic file server for e-mail indicating that the letter had been sent. It found a stored e-mail that Fraser had sent to a co-worker indicating that the letter had been sent to at least one competitor.

The e-mail was retrieved from the co-worker's file of already received and discarded messages stored on the server. When Nationwide canceled its contract with Fraser, he filed a suit in a federal district court against the firm, alleging, among other things, violations of various federal laws that prohibit the interception of electronic communications during transmission. In whose favor should the court rule, and why? Did Nationwide act ethically in retrieving the e-mail? Explain. [Fraser v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co., 352 F.3d 107 (3d Cir. 2004)] After you have answered this problem, compare your answer with the sample answer given on the Web site that accompanies this text. Go to www.thomsonedu.com/westbuslaw/ele, select "Chapter 3," and click on "Case Problem with Sample Answer."

Reference no: EM131470369

Questions Cloud

Discuss the transporters role and the ports role : Discuss the transporters role, the port's role and the government's role in controlling invasive species and other hazards inherent.

Temperature increase of the water : If all of the water's potential energy is converted to kinetic energy at the bottom of the falls and the kinetic energy goes to heat the water.

Has the jones act outlived its purpose : Has the Jones Act outlived its purpose? What governmental policies and regulations could enhance the prosperity derived from ports and their operations?

Slope-intercept form that passes : Write the equation of the line, in slope-intercept form, that passes through the point (6,8) and is parallel to the line x+7y=3.

Did nationwide act ethically in retrieving the e-mail : Richard Fraser was an "exclusive career insurance agent" under a contract with Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. Fraser leased computer hardware and software.

Find some information about the history of anti-semitism : Find some information about the history of Anti-semitism, provide us with a brief summary of that history pointing out some significant events etc.

What is the best tool for each given area : Compare and contrast, at least, one tool for each of the three network management areas. What is the best tool for each area?

Identify the risk factors present in this audit engagement : MAA303 Auditing Assessment - Case study. Identify the risk factors present in this audit engagement. Justify your answer

Should any of parties be considered ethically responsible : Ethical Conduct. Ernest Price suffered from sickle cell anemia. In 1997, Price asked Dr. Ann Houston, his physician, to prescribe Oxycontin, a strong narcotic.

User Account

All Pages