Deontological thinkers might label carols actions the best

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics

Reference no: EM133418534

Scenario

Imagine that there are three residents of Austin, and that each of them has an elderly grandmother who also lives in town. Each of the grandchildren faithfully visits his or her grandmother for three hours each and every Saturday morning. Each grandchild helps to clean up, get groceries and medicines, make small repairs, and anything else their grandmother needs. But, the grandchildren have different motivations for the Saturday visits.

Ann visits her grandmother because she loves her. They have had a great relationship all Ann's life, and Ann is happy to go and help her grandmother.

Ben does not have a particularly good relationship with his grandmother. In point of fact, he has never gotten along particularly well with her. But Ben's family expects his to help his grandmother, because no one else in the family lives remotely close to Austin. To avoid future conflicts with his family, Ben gets out of bed and heads over to his grandmother's house every week.

Carol also does not have a good relationship with her grandmother - the two have never really connected. But unlike Ben, Carol's family gives her no trouble if she does not help her grandmother. Carol is motivated to visit on Saturdays purely out of a sense of obligation. If she were asked to put it into words, Carol would probably say something like, "Look, she's my grandmother. It's my duty to check in with her, even if I'd rather do something else."

Discussion Questions

Utilitarian thinkers might say that the actions of the three grandchildren are equivalent, because each does the same amount of good and offers the same level of assistance to his or her grandmother. Do you agree with that assessment? Are these equivalent actions?
Deontological thinkers might label Carol's actions the best, because she acts out of a sense of duty. If you believe that one grandchild's actions are better than the others, do you agree that Carol's are best, or do you have a different favorite? Why?
Apply the idea of the moral minimum to the scenario.

Reference no: EM133418534

Questions Cloud

Made a short speech in which he called brown an idiot : made a short speech in which he called brown an idiot and his suggestion rubbish. Statements made at a social club meeting are subject to absolute priviege

Examples of sales of particular goods to particular buyers : examples of sales of particular goods to particular buyers and briefly explain whether the buyers of these goods would be 'consumers', and why

How do the various forms of structural racism build on each : How do the various forms of structural racism build on each other? Please give at least one specific example. What types of long-term harms did you notice

Discuss leadership theory that applies to your leadership : What kind of leader are you? As a manager, your team will look to you during times of change. What innovative leadership strategies and tactics can you use

Deontological thinkers might label carols actions the best : Deontological thinkers might label Carols actions the best, because she acts out of a sense of duty. If you believe that one grandchild's actions are better

What did film argue about the portrayal of people of color : What did the film argue about the portrayal of people of color and masculinity? Why is this sociological? Use course material to support.

List the status of this creature in terms : List the status of this creature in terms of whether it is threatened or endangered if it says it on the photo description. If it doesn't, you may have to do so

Briefly summarise the facts of the article : Briefly summarise the facts of the article and then provide an analysis covering issues such as: (a) Where did the event take place

What are some of the challenges a social worker in a school : What role, if any, do schools should play in intervening the rising rates of depression and suicidal ideation among adolescents? What are some of the challenges

User Account

All Pages