Compared child detention facilities to concentration camps

Assignment Help History
Reference no: EM133156415

In American politics, people often compare their enemies to Hitler or to the Nazis. Many Democrats compared Trump to a "fascist," and Democrat Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez famously compared child detention facilities to "concentration camps." (Republicans claimed this was an unfair comparison and disrespectful to the real victims of the Holocaust.) On the other hand, Republicans often claim that their Democratic enemies are like Hitler, and often whine that "the Left" is persecuting them similar to how the Nazis persecuted the Jews ("cancel culture" is like the Holocaust, wearing a mask is like wearing a yellow star, etc.). Obviously these are exaggerated, bad comparisons, and are more about scoring political points than teaching history accurately.

But is it always wrong and disrespectful to draw comparisons or lessons from the Holocaust? Isn't it possible--while being respectful and acknowledging all the differences that make the Holocaust uniquely horrible--to try to draw lessons from it and prevent anything like it in the future? What comparisons or lessons for the present, if any, can we learn from the Holocaust?

Using specific evidence/examples/comparisons from the primary source you analyzed, please make a specific argument about a lesson or comparison you might draw from the Holocaust. I'm not interested in your general/vague opinions about politics or Holocaust comparisons. I want you to carefully and respectfully (not politically) draw a lesson from something you learned in your document/film.

Reference no: EM133156415

Questions Cloud

Discuss Egyptian religious beliefs and death rituals : Compare the Egyptian hieroglyphic and Mesopotamian cuneiform writing systems? Discuss Egyptian religious beliefs and death rituals?
Bayeux tapestry depicts the battle of hastings : The Bayeux Tapestry depicts the Battle of Hastings and the events leading to it. How can it be used as a historical source for these events?
The rise of christianity rodney stark book : What does Stark say is the traditional view of the class of early Christians? How does he modify that view? What do you think of his argument and evidence?
Under a Cruel Star : Heda Kovaly endured not one but two of the most violent ideologies of the 20th century: a Czech/Jewish survivor of Hitler's Holocaust
Compared child detention facilities to concentration camps : Many Democrats compared Trump to a "fascist," and Democrat Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez famously compared child detention facilities to "concentration camps."
Whitman epic song of myself : How does Whitman use poetic devices listed below to challenge his readers and create a new direction in poetry? What was unique about his poetic style
Do you think diamond treatment of religion : Do you think Diamond's treatment of religion and the evolution of the scribe class in some of the larger societies is a strength or weakness in his theory?
Discuss effects of mongol domination on russia : Discuss the effects of Mongol domination on Russia, and emphasize how it shaped Russia's economic and political development.
Barber describes several issues : Barber describes several issues as significant in the evolution of McWorld: global capitalism and the erosion of national boundaries,

Reviews

Write a Review

History Questions & Answers

  History of imperialism and colonialism

Discuss the specific connections between economic development and imperialism in the latter half of the 20th century.

  Explain immigration to america

Explain immigration to America during the half of 19 th century

  American society in the making

American Society in the Making

  Conditions of late 19th century worker

Some historians considered the industrialists of the late 19th Century to be captains of industry while others considered them robber barons. Which view do you believe to be correct and why.

  Explaining the transition of humankind

Explain the significance of the transition of humankind from a hunter-gatherer society to a food-producing society. Include the following: A description of the Paleolithic era

  Tombs and monuments

Tombs and Monuments: Compare an aspect of the tomb of Emperor Shihuangdi with the burial tombs of other cultures, such as Egypt or Mesopotamia. Explain whether you think the emperor's elaborate tomb was motivated by power or religious beliefs.

  Accomplishments of egyptian female

Can anyone educate me regarding one distinct Mesopatamian and one Egyptian female and their accomplishments?

  Describing the characteristics of mesopotamia

What are the characteristics of the first civilizations of 5000 years ago? Especially in Mesopotamia.

  Explaining the vulnerability of mesopotamia

Determine why Mesopotamia was so vulnerable.

  Difference between egypt and mesopotamia

Some have said that the strength and endurance of the Empire and the regular, dependable recurrence of the Nile flood gave the artists-craftsmen a sense of consistency that profoundly influenced the nature of their artistic creations.

  Characteristics of first civilizations

What are the characteristics of the first civilizations of 5000 years ago( especially in the Mesopotamia)? what makes these groups "civilized" as opposed to prehistoric peoples?

  Growth and change in society

Cultures of Mesopotamia, especially Summer, and Egypt. How cultures change over time.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd