Analyzing the case

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM1330894

Your case analysis will be based on Echazabal v. Chevron USA, Inc. starting on page 180 of the text. I would like for you to address the following questions and issues :

1) Summaries the relevant facts of the case.

2) What are the central issues presented in the case that were decided by the court?

3) What laws were relied upon by the court in deciding the case?

4) What was the outcome of the case (Holding)?

5) Analysis â?" How did the majority of judges tie the facts, issues and laws presented in the case together to reach their holding in the case?

6) What law or laws did the dissent rely upon in reaching their decision in the case?

7) Do you agree, based upon the laws presented, with the position taken by the majority or the dissent in this case? Why?

8) Why do you think Echazabal was willing to risk his health to work in the coker unit? Assuming he had a complete grasp of the risk involved, was it ethical to allow him to work? For this, re-examine the ethical toolkit from Chapter 1.

9) From an ethical standpoint, how do you believe the case should have been decided? Why?

10) In this case, we see both the company and the employee between a rock and a hard place. Echazabal must choose to either further endanger his health, or lose a coveted opportunity. At the same time Cheveron is caught between liability under the ADA, and liability based upon unsafe working conditions. Suppose you were a top manager inside Cheveron responsible for workplace safety. What could be done to prevent, or minimize, this type of scenario from developing in the future?

Reference no: EM1330894

Questions Cloud

Learned intermediary rule : What is the Learned Intermediary Rule? Explain the context in which it became law.
Write down a program that reads a social security number : Write down a program that reads a social security number written as contiguous digits (for instance, 509435456), uses the charAt method to obtain each character and then prints each digit on a separate line followed by a colon and the digit printe..
Implications of manager-s actions and decisions : The leader of your client organization has observed a lack of flexibility and a slow decision-making process in many of the departments. What are the implications of his actions and decisions?
Determine a project after its completion : Explain What are some of the methods used to determine a project after its completion? Please explain why this works or does not work.
Analyzing the case : Analysis â?" How did the majority of judges tie the facts, issues and laws presented in the case together to reach their holding in the case?
Encrypt and decrypt the message using the caesar cipher : The cipher that Caesar used is simple technique to replace each letter of alphabet with the another letter further down the alphabet for lowercase and uppercase. Encrypt and decrypt the message using the Caesar cipher with (K=3) in Java.
Kraft foods - swot analysis : Kraft Foods: SWOT Analysis - How are they used and the synergies they prepare that make them strategically valuable?
Explaining concepts of manager as motivator : Using examples, explain the concepts of manager as motivator and coach in a way that will help these new supervisors fulfill the duties of their jobs.
Evidence based medicine : Do you feel that evidence-based medicine will improve or reduce the quality of care to patients?


Write a Review


Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Best fit milos symptoms

Which diagnosis presently seems to best fit Milo’s symptoms?

  Concept regarding role of perception in cognitive psychology

Describe at least 5 key role of perception in cognitive psychology, furnishing brief however clear details of its role.

  Individual assignment: two models handout and rubric

Individual Assignment : Two Models Handout and Rubric,    This paper will allow you to understand and evaluate two vastly different organizational models and to effectively communicate their differences.

  Guilty pleas-drawbacks and negotiating pleas

What are the benefits of guilty pleas? What are the drawbacks? What are some reasons for negotiating pleas?

  Concept regarding reward system

How well does your organization's reward system met up the seven questions to consider in designing the compensation or rewards system?

  The main safe traffic considerations within the workplace

Outline the main safe traffic considerations within the workplace List the main legal provisions as per OSHA 2005 relating to vehicle lifts

  Japanese culture emotional expression

Emotions based on the other persons' eyes, more than people do in the American culture?

  Explaining the intoxication as a defence

Why a person who is claiming that he or she was unable to enter into a contract based on his or her inability to understand the terms of the contract due to intoxication would not put on evidence of incapacity?

  Discussing the legal actions against breaching an agreement

If Monarch contracts with another company to provide services for both its facilities, would Quinn be successful in a legal action against Monarch for breaching their agreement as to the Cortland facility? Explain fully.

  Risk factors associated to iq scores

Design an intervention program for the pre-school children who are at risk designed to boost their intelligence test performance.

  Ethical considerations for employee handbook

What are some ethical considerations involved in the design of an employee handbook?

  Introduction of human behavior

Write down some of the ways that psychologists attempt to explain human behavior?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd