A protracted labor dispute with the clinchfield coal company

Assignment Help Business Management
Reference no: EM131280890

United Mine Workers of America, District 28, engaged in a protracted labor dispute with the Clinchfield Coal Co. and Sea "B" Mining Co. over alleged unfair labor practices.

In April 1989, the companies filed suit in Virginia to enjoin the union from conducting unlawful strike-related activities. The trial court entered an injunction that prohibited the union and its members from, among other things, obstructing ingress and egress to company facilities, throwing objects at and physically threatening company employees, placing tire-damaging "jackrocks" on roads used by company vehicles, and picketing with more than a specified number of people at designated sites. The court additionally ordered the union to take all steps necessary to ensure compliance with the injunction, to place supervisors at picket sites, and to report all violations to the court.

On May 16, 1989, the trial court held a contempt hearing and found that the union had committed 72 violations of the injunction. After fining the union $642,000 for its disobedience, the court announced that it would fine the union $100,000 for any future violent breach of the injunction and $20,000 for any future nonviolent infraction. In seven subsequent contempt hearings held between June and December 1989, the court found the union in contempt for more than 400 separate violations of the injunction, many of them violent.

Each contempt hearing was conducted as a civil proceeding before the trial judge, in which the parties conducted discovery, introduced evidence, and called and cross-examined witnesses. The trial court required that contumacious acts be proved beyond a reasonable doubt, but did not afford the union a right to jury trial. The court levied $52 million in fines against the unions and directed that the money be paid to the state and two of its counties. The union contends that the fines were criminal and could not be imposed absent a criminal trial. The state contends that the fine schedule was intended to coerce compliance with the injunction and therefore the fines were civil and properly imposed in civil proceedings. Decide.

Reference no: EM131280890

Questions Cloud

May an injunction be issued by a court against the neca ibew : EW and NECA argued that no injunction could be issued. May an injunction be issued by a court against the NECA-IBEW agreement?
Effectiveness of a poverty alleviation program : 1. Explain precisely how and why the moral hazard may arise in rural land contract in developing countries. 2. In order to know the effectiveness of a poverty alleviation program, an economist has run the following regression:
Transnational-international and localization strategy : Write a paper in which you identify and describe how the company you selected in Workshop One (“Haynes International” developer of heat and corrosive resistant alloys)could accomplish local responsiveness using the global standardization strategy, tr..
Cobb-douglas production function : The output of an economy is characterized by a Cobb-Douglas production function with constant return to scale and an output elasticity with respect to capital equal to 0.3. Also given are the following parameters: 30% saving rate, 5% depreciation ..
A protracted labor dispute with the clinchfield coal company : The state contends that the fine schedule was intended to coerce compliance with the injunction and therefore the fines were civil and properly imposed in civil proceedings. Decide.
Estimate the mach number of the flow entering the shock : Just upstream of a normal shock in an airflow, Ma = 3.0, T = 600 °R, and p = 30 psia. Estimate values of Ma, T0, T, p0, p, and V downstream of the shock.
Experiences with strategy as it relates to globalization : Evaluate your experiences with strategy as it relates to globalization. Discuss your views and current debates on globalization. For example, discuss how globalization leads to instability and causes lower wages, or discuss how employment practices a..
List and describe four concepts from the video : List and describe four concepts -- two from the video and two from the article -- that we covered in class that were discussed in detail in the materials.
Levels of awareness of organizational issues : The three basic elements of the interpersonal communication process are the source, the encoder, and the decoder. The source's view of the destination of the communication is a communication microbarrier. In servant leadership, leaders view their pri..

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Management Questions & Answers

  Necessary sections of business plan

You have completed all of the necessary sections of your business plan and will now create a final draft. Use any / all feedback you have received to polish your plan to the point that you could confidently show it to investors and potential partn..

  The nichepreneur strategy

Do you feel that the Nichepreneur strategy might work for your future career plans?

  What is the expected fill rate in given case

What is the optimal order-up-to level if you want to target a 98 percent in-stock probability? - What is the expected fill rate in this case?

  Describe what the control helps mitigate in a scada system

Select one control, identify whether the control falls under Management, Operational or Technical Controls and explain what this control helps mitigate in a SCADA system?

  Members of the european union

It is just few days after the members of the European Union in the United Kingdom held referendum to determine their membership fate in the unions especially after the great financial crisis that the U.K members have experienced for the previous y..

  Explain the say on pay rule

Explain the say on pay rule and whether you believe it is likely to have an effect on large compensation packages of CEOs

  Resistance to employee safety as a job requirementassume

resistance to employee safety as a job requirementassume you are assisting in the conduct of a job analysis as an hr

  Fiedlers leadership theoryshow the three situational

fiedlers leadership theoryshow the three situational determinants in fiedlers leadership theory that allow a leader to

  Explain what was the productivity index for chester

The direct labor costs for Chester were $32,460. These labor costs could have been $20,000 higher if investments in training that increased productivity had not been made. What was the productivity index for Chester that led to such savings?

  What objective customer service measurements

What objective customer service measurements are available in JIT environments. Compare also contrast those that work best in make-to-stock versus make-to-order environments.

  Cost of land versus building

Consider the Concepts for Analysis problem CA10-7 on cost of land versus building (ethics) dealing with  Tones Company.

  Explain specific experimentation and observational methods

Describe specific experimentation and observational methods that could be used within your discipline to gather data. Include your rationale. Evaluate their effectiveness with respect to certain areas within your discipline.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd