Liability for misstatement or misrepresentation, Business Law and Ethics

Liability For Misstatement Or Misrepresentation:

This will be governed by the general principles of the law of contract, depending on whether the misstatement was:-

a)A FRAUDULENT MISREPRESENTATION because the company made it—

i)knowingly, or

ii)recklessly, careless whether it be true or false, or

iii)without belief in its truth: DERRY v PEEK (42)

b) AN INNOCENT MISREPRESENTATION because the company made it honestly, believing what was stated to be true: DERRY v PEEK (42)

If the statement amounted to a fraudulent misrepresentation, the allottee may sue for damages; DERRY v PEEK. But the House of Lords held in HOULDSWORTH v CITY OF GLASGOW BANK that the allottee can only get damages if he is also in a position to rescind the contract of allotment. If the rescission is no longer possible, there will be no remedy. This is an exception to the general principle of the law of contract that a person who has been induced to enter in a contract by a fraudulent misrepresentation has the option of affirming the contract but suing for damages.

If the statement amounted to an INNOCENT misrepresentation, the allottee CAN ONLY SUE FOR RESCISSION (i.e. asking the court to order the company to remove his name from the members' register and refund the money he paid for the shares and he in turn returning the shares to the company). Damages cannot be awarded for an innocent misrepresentation. This was held by the House of Lords in DERRY v PEEK (42).

However, the allottee's right of rescission (whether for innocent or fraudulent misrepresentation) will be lost if—

a)He did not institute rectification proceedings within a reasonable time after becoming aware of the misrepresentation: FIRST NATIONAL REINSURANCE CO. V. GREENFIELD (43). in seven months' delay was held to be unreasonable delay.

b)He affirmed, or is deemed to have affirmed the contract after discovering the truth (e.g. by accepting dividends, attending and voting at meetings, selling or attempting to sell the shares).

c)Third party rights acquired in the meantime would be interferred with, or

d)The company has gone into liquidation and so the rights of creditors have crystallized and precede other claims: HOULDSWORTH Vs CITY OF GLASGOW BANK.

Posted Date: 1/12/2013 3:09:43 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Liability for misstatement or misrepresentation, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Liability for misstatement or misrepresentation, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Liability for misstatement or misrepresentation Discussions

Write discussion on Liability for misstatement or misrepresentation
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Capacity - Sales of goods Through S.4 (1) provides such capacity to buy and to sell is governed through the natural law concerning capacity for contract. Although where necess

In a business context, there are thousands of legal claims that happen frequently in a company's course of operations. Frequently, the management team must come to together to veri

Brokerage: Brokerage is a payment made by a company to a broker, or brokers, in consideration for "placing" the company's shares. It differs from underwriting commission in th

How was Negligence the main cause? Negligence was the major cause: A claim for damages can only succeed when there has been damage or loss to the claimant. Illustrations

"Detriment" as consideration  An example of a 'detriment' that will legally suffice like the consideration for a promise is provided with the case of Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke

PROXIES - meetings and resolutions: By S.136(1), any member of a company entitled to attend and vote at a meeting of the company shall be entitled to appoint one more person (

Question 1: (a) Bob works as a machinist in XYZ Ltd where Mr Rony is the director. Bob gets injured whilst using the machine. Explain the action to be taken by Mr Rony in that

(These are short answer assignments; just a few paragraphs for each part is all that is required) Assignment 1: Discussion Questions In this assignment, you will research and appl

QUORUM: However a quorum is the minimum number of persons who must be present at a meeting in order that the meeting may validly transact the business for that it was convened

Explain the term- Sustainability One of the major problems identified for international policy coordination is whether the agreed outcome is sustainable. As can be seen from th