Liability for misstatement or misrepresentation, Business Law and Ethics

Liability For Misstatement Or Misrepresentation:

This will be governed by the general principles of the law of contract, depending on whether the misstatement was:-

a)A FRAUDULENT MISREPRESENTATION because the company made it—

i)knowingly, or

ii)recklessly, careless whether it be true or false, or

iii)without belief in its truth: DERRY v PEEK (42)

b) AN INNOCENT MISREPRESENTATION because the company made it honestly, believing what was stated to be true: DERRY v PEEK (42)

If the statement amounted to a fraudulent misrepresentation, the allottee may sue for damages; DERRY v PEEK. But the House of Lords held in HOULDSWORTH v CITY OF GLASGOW BANK that the allottee can only get damages if he is also in a position to rescind the contract of allotment. If the rescission is no longer possible, there will be no remedy. This is an exception to the general principle of the law of contract that a person who has been induced to enter in a contract by a fraudulent misrepresentation has the option of affirming the contract but suing for damages.

If the statement amounted to an INNOCENT misrepresentation, the allottee CAN ONLY SUE FOR RESCISSION (i.e. asking the court to order the company to remove his name from the members' register and refund the money he paid for the shares and he in turn returning the shares to the company). Damages cannot be awarded for an innocent misrepresentation. This was held by the House of Lords in DERRY v PEEK (42).

However, the allottee's right of rescission (whether for innocent or fraudulent misrepresentation) will be lost if—

a)He did not institute rectification proceedings within a reasonable time after becoming aware of the misrepresentation: FIRST NATIONAL REINSURANCE CO. V. GREENFIELD (43). in seven months' delay was held to be unreasonable delay.

b)He affirmed, or is deemed to have affirmed the contract after discovering the truth (e.g. by accepting dividends, attending and voting at meetings, selling or attempting to sell the shares).

c)Third party rights acquired in the meantime would be interferred with, or

d)The company has gone into liquidation and so the rights of creditors have crystallized and precede other claims: HOULDSWORTH Vs CITY OF GLASGOW BANK.

Posted Date: 1/12/2013 3:09:43 AM | Location : United States







Related Discussions:- Liability for misstatement or misrepresentation, Assignment Help, Ask Question on Liability for misstatement or misrepresentation, Get Answer, Expert's Help, Liability for misstatement or misrepresentation Discussions

Write discussion on Liability for misstatement or misrepresentation
Your posts are moderated
Related Questions
Publication of Bills in the England Gazette: Such there order 98 which offers that no Bill shall be intract unless it has been published in the Gazette and a certain time of f

Question 1 Consider you are the manager of a banking organisation. You find negligence Question 2 Explain the conflicts involved in decision making Question 3 Consider a

Intention - Element of Contract Moreover to an agreement to constitute a contract then the parties thereto must have intended it for have legal consequences.  Subsequently an

Relief from Liability: Under s.402(1) the court has power in an action against an officer for breach of duty to grant relief where, although the officer is in breach, it appea

Disclosed Principal - Relations between Agent and Third Party Whether the agent acted to a disclosed principal through informing the third party such he was an agent acting to

Group Accounts: Section 150 requires a company which has subsidiaries to lay before the company in general meeting accounts or  statements dealing with the state of affairs an

Stakeholders felt the working definition was broadly appropriate. It was also noted that the Treasury definition, used as the working definition, has been endorsed by the ATO. A nu

Ethics The influence of personal ethics on workplace behaviour. (a) Explain in relation to the organisation you researched in Section A of this report why managers should use ethi

How to solve multiple equilibria problem The approach of equilibrium selection to solve multiple equilibria problem aims to retain the definition of equilibrium and accepts th

Q. Liability based definition of phoenix activity? The definition used by Treasury, and used as a working definition for this project, focuses on the intent with which phoenix